HomeMy WebLinkAboutTC Digest 2007-11-30
~
TOWN COUNCIL WEEKL YDIGEST
Week of November 26. - 30, 2007
Tiburon
1. Memo from Scott Anderson - Resignation of Kirk Lindgren
2. Memo from Scott Anderson - MMWD Desalinization Project DEIR
3. Letter from Dan Watrous - Soroko DEIR
4. Thank You - Prayer Group Use of Fountain Plaza
Agendas & Minutes
5. Minutes - POSC - January 9, 2007
6. Minutes - POSC - April 10, 2007
7. Agenda - Design Review Board - December 6,2007
8. Meeting Cancellation - Town Co~ncil-12/19/07 & 1/2/08
Regional
a) Invitation - Meet the Artist Reception - Shirley Hodges - 12/5/07 *
b) C & L Newsletter - Fall 2007 *
c) Letter - "No on the Unfair Gambling Deals" *
d) Zero Breast Cancer - Newsletter - Fall 2007 *
e) Service Matters - ABAG Newsletter - NovJDec 2007 *
f) Letter - Homeward Bound of Marin - "Next Key Center" *
g) Asthma Coalition of Sonoma County Newsletter *
h) Farewell Invitation - San Rafael Council Members Cohen & Phillips *
i) The Phoenix - Recycling Industries Newsletter *
j) Conference - "Lead-Safe Holidays" - Toy Recalls & Alternatives *
k) Letter - WTA Community Advisory Committee - SB 976
1) Letter - MMWD Notice of Availability - DEIR - Desalination Project
Agendas & Minutes
m) Agenda - Marin Bd of Supervisors - Special Meeting - November 16, 2007
n) Agenda - Marin Bd of Supervisors - November 20,2007
0) Agenda - Marin Open Space District - November 20,2007
p) Agenda - Marin Bd of Supervisors - November 27, 2007
q) Agenda - WTA - December 5, 2007
* Council Only
Town of Tiburon
DIGEsr
.
MEMORANDUM
...............
....... ..... ...........
SUBJECT:
Town Council
Scott Anderson, Director of Community Development ~
Resignation of Kirk Lindgren, Building Inspector
TO:
FROM:
DATE:
November 29,2007
................. ... ..................... ...
Building Inspector Kirk Lindgren has submitted his resignation to the Town after accepting the
newly-created position of Senior Building Inspector with the City of Mill Valley, where he will
start work right after the New Year.
Kirk has held the position of Building Inspector since April 1999 and has performed thousands
of inspections intended to keep Tiburon residents safe and sound.
We offer him our sincere thanks for nearly 9 years of Town service and wish him well in his
new job.
Town of Tiburon
MEMORANDUM
D1GEsr
TO: Town Council
FROM: Scott Anderson, Director of Community Development a-
SUBJECT: MMWD Desalinization Project Draft EIR
DATE: November 28, 2007
The Town has received the attached DEIR notice of availability for the MMWD Desalinization
Project. A compact disk containing the DEIR is available for review in the Planning Division.
As preliminarily reported to the Town Council a February 2004 memo (attached), the project
proposes a 2 million gallon water storage tank (25 feet high and 120 feet in diameter) on
Town-owned open space located in unincorporated territory below and to the west (freeway
side) of the ridge at the top of Via Los Altos.
Three alternative sites (see attached map) for the placement of this water tank are briefly
discussed in the DEIR. All three sites were only lightly studied, on the basis that
environmental impacts would either be greater or no different than for the preferred location on
Town-owned land. The DEIR concludes that substantial grading would be necessary to
construct the tank, but that the impacts of the grading could be mitigated. The DEIR
concludes that visual impacts of the tank would not be significant. A photo-simulation is
attached. The DEIR states that the water tank use is incompatible with the established open
space land use for the site, and states that "MMWD would mitigate the loss of this property
with the purchase or development [sic] of another property to be kept in Open Space. Such
mitigation would ensure that no net loss of Open Space would result." Staff notes that the
mitigation measure for this impact mentions working only with the Marin County Open Space
District toward an "exchange" of open space land to off-set the loss. Town staff will comment
accordingly.
It seems probable that if the project proceeds as described in the DEIR, MMWD will need to
condemn the amount of Town property necessary for the tank and any access roads leading
to it, as well as condemn or secure a release of the reversionary interest held by La Cresta
Associates, the former owner that dedicated the land to the Town for open space purposes.
Please let me know directly if there is any interest by the Council in having this item placed on
a future agenda or in receiving a presentation by MMWD on this project or its effects on
Tiburon.
MARIN MUNICIPAL WATER DISTRICT
NOTICE OF AVAILABILITY
Draft Environmental Impact Report
Marin Municipal Water District Desalination Project
Date:
November 19, 2007
To:
Interested Parties
From:
Marin Municipal Water District
220 N ellen Avenue
Corte Madera, CA 94925
Subject:
Draft Environmental Impact Report
Marin Municipal Water District Desalination Project
This is to advise that Marin Municipal Water District (MMWD), acting as lead agency, has prepared
a Draft Environmental Impact Report (DEIR) to identify potential environmental impacts that might
result from this proposed project.
MMWD is forwarding the DEIR to appropriate agencies and interested parties for review and
comment in compliance with the CEQA Guidelines, California Code of Regulations (CCR), section
15087.
The DEIR and supporting studies are available for review at the office of MMWD. Electronic copies
of these documents are also available on the District's website at www.marinwater.org. In an effort
to reduce the use of paper, free copies of the DEIR are available from the District on CD-ROM. To
request a CD-ROM please contact Eric McGuire at 415-945-1586.
TITLE AND DESCRIPTION. Marin Municipal Water District Desalination Project. A
desalination plant is proposed that could ultimately supply up to 15 MGD. As currently envisioned,
the project would be constructed in phases. The first phase would construct a 5 MGD facility. A 5
MGD facility would provide supplemental water supply, particularly during drought years, but would
not completely balance projected supply and demand. In 2025, a continued imbalance of
approximately 2,100 acre-feet of demand is projected, compared to supply available, even with a 5
MGD facility. MMWD has a number of options to make up this shortfall, one of the most promising
of which is conservation. In June 2007, MMWD adopted a Water Conservation Master Plan, which
defines a roadmap for augmenting MMWD's existing conservation programs and forecasts demand
reductions that could result from successful implementation of these programs. These
conservation programs are analyzed in this document as a supplement and an alternative to a
desalination facility.
Subsequent phases could add capacity to the facility for an ultimate capacity of 15 MGD. The
desalination plant would take "raw water" or "feed water" from San Rafael Bay and subject it to
various forms of treatment to produce drinkable (potable) water. Treatment would involve a
"pretreatment" phase to remove solids from the raw water, then desalination using RO technology,
followed by "post treatment" of desalted water to produce drinking water with taste and other
characteristics comparable to that currently provided to MMWD's customers. The RO process
would produce "permeate" or "product water" for drinking, and saline "concentrate" or "brine" that
would be discharged back into San Rafael Bay. The desalination plant would be located on
MMWD-owned land near Pelican Way in the City of San Rafael, California. Bay water would be
piped from an intake at the end of a newly refurbished Marin Rod & Gun Club pier near the
Richmond-San Rafael Bridge. Pretreatment of raw water to remove solids would generate sludge.
This sludge would be hauled for disposal at Redwood Landfill in northern Marin County.
Implementation of the proposed project would include the following major process and construction
components:
. Raw water intake system
. Raw water pretreatment system
. Reverse osmosis system
. Post treatment and disinfection
. Brine disposal
. Plant site facilities and improvements
. Delivery of product water
LOCATION. The proposed desalination plant would be located on MMWD-owned land at Pelican
Way in San Rafael. The raw water intake would be at the 'end of a rebuilt Marin Rod & Gun Club
pier, north of the west end of the Richmond-San Rafael Bridge. Raw water would be piped west
under existing roads to the desalination plant site. Desalination brine would be piped to CMSA's
existing treated effluent outfall for discharge to the Bay. Suspended material in the feedwater
would be removed by filters and trucked to Redwood Landfill in northern Marin County for disposal.
The in-system improvements, including pipelines, pumps, and tanks, generally follow Highway 101
from Mill Valley in the south to North Redwood Drive in the north (north of Freitas Parkway) in
Marin County.
SIGNIFICANT ENVIRONMENTAL EFFECTS ANTICIPATED AS A RESULT OF THE PROJECT.
Significant impacts identified in the DEIR that could not be eliminated or reduced to a less-than-
significant level by mitigation measures imposed by MMWD are stated below. . The final
determination of significance of impacts and of the feasibility of mitigation measures will be made
by MMWD's Board as part of their certification action for the EIR.
The follow.ing significant and unavoidable impacts were identified that would result from
development of the proposed project:
Aesthetics - Project development would degrade the visual character of San Quentin Ridge.
Noise - Project construction would temporarily increase ambient noise levels during the
construction period.
The project site is not on any list of hazardous waste facilities, land designated as hazardous
waste property, and is not a hazardous waste disposal site or any other site that would qualify for
listing under Government Code Section 65962.5,'
PUBLIC REVIEW AND COMMENT PERIOD. The public review period for this DEIR is 120 days,
which began on November 8, 2007 and ends on March 6, 2008. Comments on the DEIR must be
submitted by 4:30 P.M. on March 6, 2008. Please submit comments to: Eric McGuire,
. Environmental Coordinator, Marin Municipal Water District, 220 Nellen Avenue, Corte Madera, CA
94925. Comments may also be sent via email to desalinationeir@marinwater.org.
PUBLIC HEARINGS ON DEIR. The first of at least two public hearings on the DEIR will be held on
December 17, 2007 beginning at 6:30 P.M. The public hearing will be held at: Marin Center, 10
Avenue of the Flags, Manzanita Room, San Rafael, CA. (This is part of the Marin County Civic
Center Exhibit Hall complex near the auditorium) Subsequent hearing(s} will be noticed when
scheduled.
2
Town of Tiburon
MEMORANDUM
... .... ..... .............. .......... ..... ...
TO: Mayor & Members of the Town Council
Planning Commission
FROM: Scott Anderson, Director of Community Development ~
SUBJECT: MMWD Water Tank for Desalinization Project
DATE: February 9, 2004
Staff of the Marin Municipal Water District (MMWD) recently met with Planning Manager Dan
Watrous and me to provide a preview of MMWD's plans for construction of a water
desalinization plant along the San Rafael shoreline of San Francisco Bay. MMWD is
apparently beginning work on the environmental impact report (EIR) for the desalinization
plant project.
MMWD staff indicated that in addition to the desalinization plant itself, a network of new water
distribution lines and new water tanks will be required. This includes perhaps two large water
tanks on San Quentin Ridge and one large tank in Southern Marin. The Southern Marin water
tank would be approximately 30 feet high, 130 to 150 feet in diameter, and would have a
capacity of 2 to 3 million gallons. For comparison purposes, the water tank at 99 ~ Mount
Tiburon has a capacity of 0.5 million gallons, while the tank off Spring Lane has a 1.5 million
gallon capacity (with a doubling of capacity now underway with a second tank).
MMWD is considering five sites in Southern Marin for this tank (see attached drawing). Site
48 is located on property within unincorporated County of Marin territory, but which is owned
(as dedicated open space) by the Town of Tiburon. Nearby Site 4A is located in Corte Madera
and Sites 1-3 are located on the west side of U. S. Highway 101. MMWD staff has indicated
that Site 48 may be identified as the "project" water tank, with the other four sites analyzed as
"alternatives" to the project in the EIR.
Town staff advised MMWD staff that visual and access issues would be most closely
scrutinized. While the tank would probably be visible only from a tiny part of Tiburon (the
ridge-top and the end of Via Los Altos), it could potentially have much greater visual impacts
from areas outside of the Town limits. Town staff also provided MMWD staff with a copy of the
open space dedication instrument, including the reversionary clause and the "undeveloped,
open and unimproved land" limitations stipulated in the dedication. The approximately 55-acre
parcel in question was dedicated to the Town by the developers of the La Cresta (Tiburon
Crest) Subdivision in 1982.
Staff will keep the Council advised as to any new information on this matter as it arises.
Cc: Town Manager
Planning Manager
'~"'-,
'Y",
\
\
--.-_._-._'.~.._-"---
I
(~,'JS---7 /,
'. ~ It
\ {~J'S ~
\
CMSA Outfall
J
o
Ql
Gi
~
..l<:
III
Qj
E
III
Z
::!:
D..
~
t:
N
~
o
o
~
~
in
Qj
ro
o
~
C::::,~
Legend
D Plant Site
& Pumping Station
El Proposed Tank Site
. Alternative Tank Site
EJ Alternative Plant Site
Proposed Pipeline
- Alternative Pipeline (Reach 4)
- Alternative Intake Location
- Major Roadways
- Minor Roads
D City Boundaries
r
I
L__}
.,__1f
S
x
Lt)
cOl
~ Marin Rod & i
Gun Club Pier (Intake) ~I
u
Ql
'0-
n:
QlI
,~
ro
E
Ql
~I
~
i'
Cl
u:::
~
o
is
x
;;
I
I
~I
~
::!:
::!:
(i)
&l
'j2'
g,
.:..i
c:
o
~
o
c.
5
()
Miles ~
::::>
~
$::a
;:
~
...
~
~
....
fI.l
~
-=
a
(/
pj!
,_J.J'L..
MILL
VALLEY
~
"
MMWD Desalination Project Figure
Alternative Project Features 6-1
26814346
4.1 AESTHETICS
Proposed Tank
NOTE:
The Corte Madera Del Presidio development in
Corte Madera is in the foreground.
MMWD Desalination Project
Simulation of Ridgecrest A Tank Viewed From Sonora Way
FIGURE
4.1-7
26814346
MMWD Desalination Project Draft EIR
4.1-13
04.01_ Aesthetics.doc\S- NOV -07\OAK
./
/
-./;/'
Town ofTiburon · 1505 Tiburon Boulevard. Tiburon, CA 94920. P. 415.435.7373 F. 415.435.2438 · www.ci.tiburon.ca.us
Office of Community Development Department/(415) 435-7393
!f1'G
Ir ; 1 ",,~ ,t
A;.~,!' Ii ,lei," j~I'~J, ,',,''''' ~/'"
f} 4-r;j:
November 20, 2007
Tim Haddad
Environmental Coordinator
Marin County Community Development Agency
Planning Division '
3501 Civic Center Drive, Rm. 308
San Rafael, CA 94903
RE: Sorokko Draft: Environmental Impact Report
Dear Tim,
Thank you for giving the Town of Tiburon the opportunity to review and comment on
the Draft Environmental Impact Report for the Sorokko property. Our comments on
the DEIR are as follows:
1. We disagree with the conclusion of the DEIR that the removal of trees
associated with the project and its mitigation measures would less this
impact to a less than significant level. The DEIR does not indicate the
final number of trees that would be removed if the mitigation measures
are imposed, but states that 430 trees would still need'to be removed
for fire hazard reduction. This tree removal would not appear to
"preserve the main oak woodland on the site;" would be consistent with
Goal 1-3 of the Paradise Drive Visioning Plan to "preserve trees... that
contribute to the area's rural appearance;" and would be inconsistent
with Tiburon General Plan Policy OSC-33 to preserve protected trees,
tree stands and tree clusters "to the maximum extent feasible." The
extensive tree removal would also contribute to potential soil erosion,
and should be addressed under Impact 4.1-8.
2. The Town strongly supports the recommended Mitigation Measure 4-
11-8.1 to connect the project to the public sewer system, as the septic
system proposed for the project would not only be inconsistent with the
ongoing pattern of development in the vicinity, but would also
substantially contribute to the removal of trees on the site.
3. The visual impacts of the lengthy retaining walls described on Page 3-
11' need to be addressed.
4. Table 4.0-1 needs to be updated to reflect the most recent submittals
for the Ling Precise Development Plan (3 dwelling units, not 5) and
Parente Precise Development Plan (2 dwelling units, not 3),
.
I
.:-. ~ 0 f TIe v ~~
O~E' ~~
I- ',*-"
r ~___
.-4 . .,~ , ~ ~, .
t';~ ~~~,~
,,~ :::- ~/\O
('~~~~ ,Ot
~ o.~.-"- (.. ~
. Iitv/A \~ .
J
.
1.
....
Tom Gram
Mayor
Jeff Slavitz
Vice.M:~yor
l'v,liles ,Berger
Councihneriiber
Alice.Fred.ericks
Councilmember
. . . '., -.".,. eo ill . . . .
Paul Smith
Councilmember
Margaret A. Curran
Town Manager
Marin County Community Development Agency
November 20, 2007
Page 2 of 2
5. The Town strongly supports the recommended Mitigation Measure 4.8-
A.2 to limit the size of new homes on the site, but would encourage a
lower maximum floor area for consistency with the size of other homes
in the vicinity.
6. Mitigation Measure 4.8-C.3 encourages that the scale of the residence
on Parcel 1 "avoid a massive appearance when seen from the bay,"
although this dwelling would be much more visually prominent from
Paradise Drive, as indicated by the project simulation of this residence.
A similar mitigation measure should be imposed for the views from
Paradise Drive, with clear direction given as to how this mitigation
measure would be enforced through the design review process for a
home on this lot.
7. The buffers proposed to protect the area of Marin western flax adjaCent
to adjacent to the driveway access for Parcels 3, 4 and the Remainder
Parcel would likely be inadequate to protect this site during or after
construction. The driveway should be relocated to increase the long-
term buffer of all construction and residential uses for this plant
population.
8. The Town encourages approval of the Reduced Density Alternative,
which would be more consistent with the pattern of recently approved
development (including the Tiburon Glen project, which approved 3
homes on 26 acres).
Thank you once again giving us the opportunity to comment on this DEIR. Please call
me at (415) 435-7393 if you have any questions regarding this letter.
Sincerely,
JleA~
Daniel M. Watrous
Planning Manager
......
.
I
.s ~ .~. f!lll v ",I..
~:.^ ~~~ -.
('I\~~~!<:t
y\~::::-,- ~~'O
("'....A'~....
.'.':. o~Nnc\~c.' ~.
I
.
If.
t)
~ ~ t' f t ~ t ~ ::[ ~ J F ~,
~ ~~, v. ~ ,..( ~ ~ . .<
ffi g l<\ " ". ~ \ ~ ~
!~~~ J~~ f~l ~~~)~ ~V~ ~j~
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ , f' l ~ ~ ~l:i ~ ~ ~
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ . ~~ ~ ~
~ "~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~ ~ ~ ~~.!
~
5.
APPROVED
PARKS AND OPEN SPACE COMMISSION
DfGEsr
MINUTES NO. 214
January 9, 2007 6:00 P.M.
SPECIAL MEETING
TOWN COUNCIL CHAMBERS
1505 TIBURON BOULEVARD
CALL TO ORDER
Chair Chris Wand called the regular meeting of the Parks and Open Space Commission
to order at 6:04 P.M., Tuesday, January 9,2007 in Town Council Chambers, 1505
Tiburon Boulevard, Tiburon, California.
I. ROLL CALL
PRESENT: . Chair Wand, Commissioners McMullen, Lindqvist and Canter
ABSENT: Vice Chair Zender was delayed and arrived at 6: 1 O.
EX-OFFICIO: Director of Public Works/Town Engineer Nick Nguyen
II. PUBLIC QUESTIONS AND COMMENTS
None
III. STAFF AND COMMISSION BRIEFING
None
IV. CONSENT CALENDAR
MINUTES of December 12, 2006 (No. 213) approved with the following
changes:
II. line 3, delete 'south of the Knoll' and insert "of the drainage gully"
III. line 1, after items add "D", and delete' and H'
line 8, change "will replacement' to "will be replaced"
page 2, line 7, to individually visit
line 8, delete 'dissented' insert "abstained'
V. B. page 2: Change to one table and seats
line 5, Change to "table's relocation to the site"
V.C. line 6, delete 'of insert "around"
V.H. line 8, delete 'sign for playground fundraising' and insert "commemorative
tile with a rock-mounted plaque. "
M/S 5-0 to approve Minutes No. 213 as amended.
v. BUSINESS ITEMS
A. Tiburon Peninsula Foundation's Proposal to maintain Blackie's Pasture/
Trees
Commissioners McMullen and Lindqvist indicated they were members of a
2003 subcommittee which addressed this same set of trees. At the time, there
was a general agreement that the Foundation would work with POSC and the
community regarding their care. He opined that the December 2006 Moritz
report's findings/recommendations were reasonable and in keeping with the
earlier understanding regarding their care.
Commissioner Canter did not recall such an agreement and expressed concern
these matters seem to repeat themselves every two years or so. She referred to a
controversy three years ago as to maintenance of a resident's view. The
Commissioner also reported on her two visits in early January 2007 when she
noted the very healthy specimens of Cypress trees one of which had its lower
branches lightly pruned.
Commissioner Lindqvist spoke of the earlier subcommittee's concern that
Cypress trees are fast growing, would be too close to utility lines and were
impinging into the parking lot. She opined that the cypress have become a
serious visual obstruction at the entrance of Blackie's parking lot. She was
under the impression that certain designated cypress' heights were to be
maintained by the Town but no report was ever received about this. This
Commissioner also referred to the proposal's description of unsuitable trees and
she recommended lower growing vegetation.
Commissioner Zender reminded the Commission that the Tree ordinance
established residents' views when they first occupy a residence. Director
Nguyen noted that the Community Development assessment of the application
indicated that they were not heritage trees and supported the application as it
relates to the Ordinance.
Larry Smith was invited to speak to the proposal. He affirmed that the cypress
had not been part of a planned planting and noted that the trees were expected
to grow another 10-20 feet. The Tiburon Peninsula Foundation proposal's intent
is to return the pasture to its original design, remove the threat of view
blockage, and clear impingement on the utility wires. He opined that the trees
were probably volunteers self started in the mulch brought to the area. He also
commented that the work was going to be done pro bono but that the
chipping/removal would probably have to be paid for. Later, he indicated that
the trimming/removal/clean-up will be done at the same time as the
replacement plantings. The plan will entail a ratio of 2 fifteen gallon trees to
replace the three Monterey Ash. He is hopeful the project can be completed this
season and stated that there is $2,000 set aside and neighbors' pledges if more
is needed.
A general discussion regarding the types and attributes of the established and
proposed replacement trees ensued.
M/S McMullen/Zender 4-1 (Canter dissented) to accept the Tiburon
Peninsula Foundation proposal and execute the plan.
B. Tree Management Plan for Knoll's Grove of Eucalyptus Trees
Director Nguyen explained that this was an agenda item because the Moritz
report was received just before the 12/12/06 meeting began and that there'd
been no time to review it. He indicated the agenda had been properly noticed.
The Commission agreed to discuss the matter.
Director Nguyen pointed out that in prior POSC meetings there had been
approval of trimming and of Public Works staff selecting those trees and
secondary growth which should be trimmed. He noted that POSC is being
asked for their recommendation of the management of the Knoll's eucalyptus
trees. He pointed out that historically these are contentious issues in Tiburon
and indicated that it would be well to have some public testimony so there
would be a consensus. Additionally, there is a need for a Town Council budget
amendment to pay for it.
The public was asked for comment. Henry Broderick, 20 Rowley Circle, was
present and spoke about the importance of the trees south of McKegney Green
as he sees them being the entry point for the Town. He referred to the May
2006 Marin Tree Service report's emphasis on tree preservation which he
disagrees with as he is strongly in favor of precise designation of those trees
which need trimming and/or removal.
Commissioner Zender pointed out that Superintendent Davenport has been
designated to oversee the trimming project and that he is expected to be on site
when the work is done. She noted the Moritz Report has outlined the safety
issues well.
Commissioner McMullen considers the trees to be heritage; however, he defers
to the Superintendent for decisions about necessary removal. He supports
secondary growth removal. The Commissioner likes opening up the area to
recreational use, nicer appearance, and, most importantly, maintenance of
safety. Commissioner Canter agreed and urged that the Superintendent be given
full rein to safety manage the growth of the Eucalyptus.
Commissioner Lindqvist found the report to be thorough and satisfied that it
was conducted by an independent arborist who would not be doing the work.
She pointed out that the section of the tree that fell in May 2006 had been
growing at an odd angle and was rotted at the bottom.
Commissioner Wand said he had spent 3 hours in the field reviewing the Knoll
area and was in complete agreement with the Moritz Report. Further, he agrees
the Superintendent should make the decisions keeping in mind to do as much
and possibly less than the Report recommends.
Director Nguyen indicated he will have the Superintendent do what he can on
this project to make it cost effective; however he will be mindful of Public
Works resources of time. Anticipated costs are $5-10,000 based on the bids
received for trimming 9 trees.
MIS CanterlWand (4-0), [Zender recused herself due to possible
appearance of a conflict of interest] to have DPW Staff use their judgment
in implementing the December 12, 2006 Moritz Report recommendations.
VI. ADJOURNMENT
The meeting was adjourned at 7:05 PM.
~~ \~~
CHRISTOPHER WAND, HAIR
Parks & Open Space Commission
ATTESA\ -6 .//
<LAj ~/
NICHOLAS T. NGUYEN, SECRETARY
,.
PARKS AND OPEN SPACE COMMISSION
DIG
~(\~
VI
APPROVED
MINUTES NO. 215
April 10, 2007 6:00 P.M.
REGULAR METING
TOWN COUNCIL CHAMBERS
1505 TIBURON BOULEVARD
CALL TO ORDER
Chair Christopher Wand called the regular meeting of the Parks and Open Space
Commission to order at 6:04 P.M., Tuesday, April 10, 2007 in Town Council Chambers,
1505 Tiburon Boulevard, Tiburon, California.
I. ROLL CALL
PRESENT: Chair Wand, Commissioners Zender, McMullen and Lindqvist
ABSENT: Commissioner Canter
EX-OFFICIO: Director of Public Works/Town Engineer Nick Nguyen
II. PUBLIC QUESTIONS AND COMMENTS
None
III. STAFF AND COMMISSION BRIEFING
None
IV. CONSENT CALENDAR
MIS 4-0 to approve Minutes of December 12,2006 (No. 213) with the following
changes:
II. line 3, delete 'south of the Knoll' and insert "of the drainage gully"
III. line 1, after items add "D", and delete 'and H'
line 8, change "will replacement' to "will be replaced"
page 2, line 7, to individually visit
line 8, delete 'dissented' insert "abstained'
V. B. page 2, Change to one table and seats
line 5, Change to "table's relocation to the site"
V.C. line 6, delete 'of insert "around"
V.H. line 8, delete 'sign for playground fundraising' and insert "commemorative
tile with a rock-mounted plaque. "
MIS 4-0 to approve Minutes No. 214 as amended per written submission by
Commissioner Lindqvist
V. A. para. 1, line 4: Change to Tiburon Peninsula Foundation's
para. 3, line 8: Delete also referred to the proposal's description of
unsuitable trees; insert after vegetationfor the berms around the car park.
para. 5, line 10: Delete "a ratio of'.
v. BUSINESS ITEMS
A. Broom Remov,al from Open Space
Alison Pence, 70 Granada Dr., Corte Madera, presented for Tiburon resident
(Ill Hacienda Drive) Botanist Eva Buxton's new letter of April 7, 2007 along
with earlier submitted exhibits V.B. p.l&2. Their main points are that since
open space has been acquired through the Open Space Bond Fund in the 1973
to 1983 decade, an urgent need has developed to maintain the areas particularly
because of the presence of endangered plants. The Middle Ridge which spans
both sides of Gilmartin Drive; the portion located to the west of the Hacienda
Drive fire road, between Hacienda Drive and Gilmartin, is of specific concern
because it includes serpentine soils which are home to three Federally and
State-listed threatened and endangered species, Tiburon black jewel flower
(Streptanthus niger), Tiburon paint brush (Castilleja affinis ssp. neglecta), and
Marin dwarf flax (Hesperolinon congestum). There are approximately 400 paint
brush plants in this area and they are only ones which exist in the world.
At the same time, non-native French broom and Pampas grass have invaded the
area and are rapidly spreading into the rare plant habitat, and, on the Middle
Ridge, into sensitive serpentine grassland. The paint brush are the most
impacted/threatened by these non-natives. The Serpentine crops out also on the
southern portion near Old St. Hilary's Church and on Ring Mountain. Ms Pence
and Buxton opine that because the above listed flowers are so severely
threatened a concerted effort is immediately needed by the Town and a work
crew to remove the large plants with appropriate equipment.
Ms. Pence suggests the immediate low cost remedy of developing a
management plan so the land can be ensured and enjoyed for generations.
However, more immediately, she urges signage which warns of the sensitive
habitat and accordingly directs hikers with their dogs to remain on the trails.
The signage would be placed at the Hacienda and A venida Miraflores entrances
into the Open Space areas. They are also suggesting that a fence be raised to
encircle the most sensitive locations.
Commissioner Wand spoke of his hiking a few days earlier in the area with Ms.
Buxton and Pence, and confirmed their analysis of the endangered situation. He
noted the many aspects of developing a management plan but says he considers
it of the utmost importance.
Commissioner Lindqvist reported on the past removal of broom by the Boy
Scouts and the Boom Busters Group; Public Works took away the debris. The
present encroachment of the non-natives on the area would require education of
the people doing the extracting.
Commissioner McMullen would like to direct Staff to work on a management
plan while also considering its Town budget impact, available grant monies,
and management of volunteer groups.
To this recommendation, Director Nguyen replied he had requested that open
space management be reviewed for the 2007-08 fiscal year. Further, he
suggested that POSC make a recommendation to Town Council. He mentioned
the concerns of the agreement as to who was to maintain the space after
purchase of open space land. His approach is to have a management plan
completed, address the purchase agreement, liability issues, review the
inventory of the plants of the area, and to gauge the habitat and costs. He noted
that Public Works doesn't have the manpower to maintain the corridor being
discussed let alone the 60-70 acre open space area or the crucial fire roads. The
eroding fire roads haven't been tended for a number of years. The Director
noted the overall cost could approach several million dollars.
Commissioner Lindqvist urged Ms. Pence to have marked on a comprehensive
map the sensitive areas so that they can easily discerned in the winter season
when the broom and grass would most likely be eradicated; she also requested
that most advantageous eradication times be noted. Ms. Pence is to pass along
this suggestion to Ms. Buxton.
Commissioner Zender raised the past existence of the Tiburon Ridge Trail
Committee which had seen that signage was posted in various areas over the
years. She will research the current status of this subcommittee.
MIS Wand/Zender (4-0) To convey to Town Council POSC's
recommendation supporting the Budget Item for an Open Space
Management Plan.
MIS Wand/Zender (4-0) To have Staff review sensitive habitat areas and
implement temporary signage.
B. Peter Berg Kite Day
Commissioner Zender reminded everyone of the event on May 5 at 11 :00. She
said all preparation was under control.
c. Zelinsky Playground for School-Age Kids
Derice Tao, 200 Bay View, Belvedere, and Pam Bonnie, 24 Southridge West,
Tiburon, were present to update the commission regarding the subcommittee's
progress on the new project establishing a renewed school-age children
playground. The committee has three new members: Michele George, Felicia
Goldstein and Sunny Lyreck They have developed a budget and a fundraising
plan, as well as assessed playground equipment for safety/ADA standards.
They are recommending purchase of a new Tire Swing and of a new play
structure which would fit the same footprint (27'x 22') of the present
playground. They noted that the recently completed Tot Lot with its enhanced
landscaping has brought renewed interest to the area. The budget is for
$165,000, with the committee raising 55% or $90,000 through tile sales, one to
three fundraising events, and soliciting from corporations and foundations.
The subcommittee is requesting POSC' s recommendation to the Town Council
for this proj ect.
Commissioner Wand inquired about the expected life of the equipment; Ms.
Tao responded it was 10 years. She also responded to his question about the
impact of new government standards that once something is built to code that it
does not need to be changed to meet new ones.
Commissioner Zender inquired about the past drainage issues, which Ms.
Bonnie replied had been rectified with the rebuilding of the tot lot. The
commissioner opined it had excellent play value for the cost. She urged that
that there be a minimal gap of time between the removal of the old structures
and installation of the new.
Commissioner Lindqvist raised the issues of ADA usage and access. The
surface will be composed of Fibar which compacts to the point it can be walked
on and will accommodate wheelchairs. Additionally, the walkway will be in a
horseshoe shape to enhance approaching the play structures (see exh. V.C.
page 7).
MIS ZenderlWand (4-0) to recommend to Town Council approval of the
new school-age playground's plan and budget presented at the 4/10/2007
POSC meeting.
VI. ADJOURNMENT
The meeting was adjourned at 7:15 PM.
c~~~k
Parks & Open Space Commission
ATTEST: ~t ~ ---n__
NICH~AS T~1~UYEN, SECRETARY
74
DESIGN REVIEW BOARD
AGENDA
lJ1G~8'"
TOWN OF TIBURON
1505 TIBURON BOULEVARD
TIBURON, CA 94920
DATE: 12/6/07
MEETING TIME 7:00 P.M.
AGENDA NO.: #21
PLEASE NOTE: In order to give all interested persons an opportunity to be heard, and to ensure the presentation of all
points of view, members of the audience should:
(1) Always address the Chair; (2) State name for the record; (3) State views/concerns succinctly; (4) Limit presentation
to three minutes; (5) Speak directly into microphone and (6) All documents submitted at the meeting must first be
submitted at the Staff table, to be entered into the record and retained by the Town.
If an item is continued, it is the responsibility of interested parties to note the new meeting date. Notices will not be sent
out for items continued to a specific date.
Any documents produced by the Town and distributed to a majority of the Design Review Board regarding any item on
this agenda, including agenda-related documents produced by the Town after distribution of the agenda packet 72 hours
in advance of the Board meeting, will be available for public inspection at Tiburon Town Hall, 1505 Tiburon Boulevard,
Tiburon, CA 94920.
A.
ROLL CALL:
Chair Doyle, Boardmembers Corcoran, Frymier, Glassner and Teiser
B. PUBLIC COMMENTS (FOR ITEMS NOT ON THE AGENDA)
C. STAFF BRIEFING
D. CONSENT CALENDAR
1. 1601 Tiburon Blvd. Zelinsky/Bank of America Sign Permit
E. OLD BUSINESS BEFORE THE BOARD
2.
3 Southridge Drive Peitz
New Dwelling
F. NEW BUSINESS BEFORE THE BOARD
3.
4.
13 Roseville Court Van Dusen
132 Hacienda Drive Milano
5.
6.
17 Venado Drive
3 Parente Road
Coomber
ChulPark
CabanalPoolN ariance
AdditionsN ariance
CONTINUED TO 12/20/07
Addition/V ariance
New DwellingNariances
G. APPROVAL OF MINUTES #20 OF THE 11/15/07 DESIGN REVIEW BOARD MEETING
H. ADJOURNMENT
**PLEASE NOTE THAT AGENDA ITEMS MAY BE TAKEN OUT OF ORDER**
fJ
DIGEsr
NOTICE OF MEETING
CANCELLA TION
The regular Town Council Meetings scheduled for
December 19,.2007 and January 2, 2008
have been cancelled.
THE NEXT REGULAR MEETING
will be on
WEDNESDAY, January 16,2007,
in the Town Council Chambers located at
1505 Tiburon Blvd. Tiburon CA 94920.
"}' (;,7 ;;
/..' ..' ..' /1.. ......../
I " ,
;/ ," i . .... l~- f.,'" A /A
L -"-'f 'c L-? v(
DIANE CRANE OPI, TOWN CLERK
Posted at Town Hall
cc: The Ark and Marin Independent Journal
Community
Advisory
Committee
DIGEST I<.
tif~fArER' TRAf\fS1T AUTf'=lORJTY
November 16, 2007
RECEIVED
NOV 1 9 2007
Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger
State Capitol Building
Sacramento, CA 95814
TOWN MANAGERS OFFICE
TOWN OF TJ8URON
Subject: SB 976 Clean Up Legislation
Dear Governor Schwarzenegger,
This letter is a follow up to my September 18 letter, which was written on behalf of the Water
Transit Authority's Citizens Advisory Committee (CAC) in response to SB 976. We continue
to believe that WET A will be most successful if it capitalizes on the work WT A has already
done over the last four years and optimizes regional representation and local input.
My letter included several suggestions for ensuring the continued development of a well
coordinated water transit and ferry emergency response system. We understand that clean
up legislation will be introduced in January or February to address suggestions and many
other issues that have been raised in response to SB 976. To reiterate our concerns, we urge
the clean up legislation to specifically provide for:
o A WET A Board that is representative of the 7 counties that make up our region and
especially those jurisdictions where a water terminal exists or is proposed;
o Retaining some of the existing WT A board members to ensure continuity; and
o Continuing a broad based CAC to advise the WET A board on issues affecting the
local affected communities, similar to the CAC that has been in place since WT A
was established.
Thank you again for your consideration. I look forward to hearing from you on the progress of
the SB 976 clean up legislation. Feel free to contact me bye-mail at
dhoward@redwoodcitV.oro or by phone at 650-208-4774.
Sincerely,
(-~:"~j ..,,". C"? (-~" "" (?
t>CZ~-tf Jt--"_-/ fir /.C.("~C.;A
..... -.....~----~
-~~--,
Diane Howard
Chair, WT A Community Advisory Committee
Councilmember, City of Redwood City
Co-Chair, Water Transit Advocates of San Mateo County
Cc. Steve Castleberry
Charlene Haught-Johnson
.L.
MARIN MUNICIPAL WATER DISTRICT
NOTICE OF AVAILABILITY
Draft Environmental Impact Report
Marin Municipal Water District Desalination Project
D1GEsr
Date:
November 19, 2007
To:
Interested Parties
From:
Marin Municipal Water District
220 N ellen Avenue
Corte Madera, CA 94925
Subject:
Draft Environmental Impact Report
Marin Municipal Water District Desalination Project
This is to advise that Marin Municipal Water District (MMWD), acting as lead agency, has prepared
a Draft Environmental Impact Report (DEIR) to identify potential environmental impacts that might
result from this proposed project.
MMWD is forwarding the DEIR to appropriate agencies and interested parties for review and
comment in compliance with the CEQA Guidelines, Califomia Code of Regulations '(CCR), section
15087.
The DEIR and supporting studies are available for review at the office of MMWD. Electronic copies
of these documents are also available on the District's website at www.marinwater.org. In an effort
to reduce the use of paper, free copies of the DEIR are available from the District on CD-ROM. To
request a CD-ROM please contact Eric McGuire at 415-945-1586.
TITLE AND DESCRIPTION. Marin Municipal Water District Desalination Project. A
desalination plant is proposed that could ultimately supply up to 15 MGD. As currently envisioned,
the project would be constructed in phases. The first phase would construct a 5 MGD facility. A 5
MGD facility would provide supplemental water supply, particularly during drought years, but would
not completely balance projected supply and demand. In 2025, a continued imbalance of
approximately 2,1.00 acre-feet of demand is projected, compared to supply available, even with a 5
MGD facility. MMWD has a number of options to make up this shortfall, one of the most promising
of which is conservation. In June 2007, MMWD adopted a Water Conservation Master Plan, which
defines a road map for augmenting MMWD's existing conservation programs and forecasts demand
reductions that could result from successful implementation of these programs. These
conservation programs are analyzed in this document as a supplement and an altemative to a
desalination facility.
Subsequent phases could add capacity to the facility for an ultimate capacity of 15 MGD. The
desalination plant would take "raw water" or "feed water" from San Rafael Bay and subject it to
various forms of treatment to produce drinkable (potable) water. Treatment would involve a
"pretreatment" phase to remove solids from the raw water, then desalination using RO technology,
followed by "post treatment" of desalted water to produce drinking water with taste and other
characteristics comparable to that currently provided to MMWD's customers. The RO process
would produce "permeate" or "product water" for drinking, and saline "concentrate" or "brine" that
would be discharged back into San Rafael Bay. The desalination plant would be located on
..1
MMWD-owned land near Pelican Way in the City of San Rafael, California. Bay water would be
pip~dArofn an intake at the end of a newly refurbished Marin Rod & Gun Club pier near the
to RichrT1o.nd-San Rafael Bridge. Pretreatment of raw water to remove solids would generate sludge.
.."Fhissludge would be hauled for disposal at Redwood Landfill in northern Marin County.
Implementation of the proposed project would include the following major process and construction
components:
. Raw water intake system
. Raw water pretreatment system
. Reverse osmosis system
. Post treatment and disinfection
. Brine disposal
. Plant site facilities and improvements
. Delivery of product water
LOCATiON. The proposed desalination plant would be located on MMWD-owned land at Pelican
Way in San Rafael. The raw water intake would be at the end of a rebuilt Marin Rod & Gun Club
pier, north of the west end of the Richmond-San Rafael Bridge. Raw water would be piped west
under existing roads to the desalination plant site. Desalination brine would be piped to CMSA's
existing treated effluent outfall for discharge to the Bay. Suspended material in the feedwater
would be removed by filters and trucked to Redwood Landfill in northern Marin County for disposal.
The in-system improvements, including pipelines, pumps, and tanks, generally follow Highway 101
from Mill Valley in the south to North Redwood Drive in the north (north of Freitas .Parkway) in
Marin County.
SIGNIFICANT ENVIRONMENTAL EFFECTS ANTICIPATED AS A RESULT OF THE PROJECT.
Significant impacts identified in the DEIR that could not be eliminated or reduced to a less-than-
significant level by mitigation measures imposed by MMWD are stated below. The final
determination of significance of impacts and of the feasibility of mitigation measures will be made
by MMWD's Board as part of their certification action for the EIR.
The following significant and unavoidable impacts were identified that would result from
development of the proposed project:
Aesthetics - Project development would degrade the visual character of San Quentin Ridge.
Noise - Project construction would temporarily increase ambient noise levels during the
construction period.
The project site is not on any list of hazardous waste facilities, land designated as hazardous
waste property, and is not a hazardous waste disposal site or any other site that would qualify for
listing under Government Code Section 65962.5.
PUBLIC REVIEW AND COMMENT PERIOD. The public review period for this DEIR is 120 days,
which began on November 8, 2007 and ends on March 6, 2008. Comments on the DEIR must be
submitted by 4:30 P.M. on March 6, 2008. Please submit comments to: Eric McGuire,
Environmental Coordinator, Marin Municipal Water District, 220 Nellen Avenue, Corte Madera, CA
94925. Comments may also be sent via email to desalinationeir@marinwater.org.
PUBLIC HEARINGS ON DEIR. The first of at least two public hearings on the DEIR will be held on
December 17, 2007 beginning at 6:30 P.M. The public hearing will be held at: Marin Center, 10
Avenue of the Flags, Manzanita Room, San Rafael, CA. (This is part of the Marin County Civic
Center Exhibit Hall complex near the auditorium) Subsequent hearing(s) will be noticed when
scheduled.
2
DIGEST IJt
fD)~@~~W~rnI
mJ NOV 1 6 2007 lW
SPECIAL MEETING TOWN ATTORNEY'S OFFICE
Friday, November 16, 2007 TOWN OF TI:U;::;ON
Board of Supervisors Chambers, Room 330, Civic Center
BOARD OF SUPERVISORS
COUNTY OF MARIN
NOTICE IS GIVEN that President Steve Kinsey, Marin County Board of Supervisors, has called a
special meeting of the Marin County Board of Supervisors on Friday, November 16, 2007, to be held at
9:00 a.m. in the Board of Supervisors Chambers, Room 330, Civic Center, San Rafael, California.
The business to be transacted at the special meeting consists of one matter described below.
AGENDA
9:00 a.m.
1.
Request to adopt resolution ratifying the Proclamation of Local Emergency for the
County of Marin issued by the Director of Emergency Services on November 9,
2007, and continuing the local emergency for the County of Marin.
Recommended action: Adopt Resolution.
This will be a public meeting and interested persons may make comments to this Board on the
proposed actions.
Copies of this notice have been hand delivered or sent via facsimile to all members of the Board of
Supervisors and media outlets who have requested notice of special meetings.
~
JI
~
JI
I "..,.
.....
....
.....
-
All County public meetings are conducted in accessible locations.
If you require American Sign Language interpreters, assistive listening devices or other accommodations to participate in
this meeting, these may be requested by calling (415) 499-7331 (voice) or (415) 499-6172 (TTY) at least 72 hours in advance.
Copies of documents used in this meeting are available in accessible formats upon written request.
The agenda is available on the Internet at htto:llwww.co.marin.ca.us/efiles/BS/AoMn/cvbaonda.htm
The Board meeting is broadcast live over the Internet at htto:llwww.co.marin.ca.us/deots/BS/Archive/Meetinos.cfm
A copy of the agenda will be faxed upon request by dialing (415)-499-6060 and entering "181" after the brief introductory message.
.at\
DIGESN
AGENDA FOR roJ ~NO~ ~ 6 ~ 2~7 ~ ~
MARIN COUNTY BOARD OF SUPERVISORS UlJ ill
MARIN COUNTY HOUSING AUTHORITY BOARD OF COMMISSIONII~ATIORNEY'SOFFICE
MARIN COUNTY OPEN SPACE DISTRICT BOARD OF DIRECTORS TOWNOFTIBURON
Agenda items will be heard at the time specified or later, depending on the progress of the
meeting.
AGENDA
Tuesday, November 20, 2007
Board of Supervisors Chambers, Room 330, Civic Center
9:30 a.m. Convene as the Marin County Housina Authoritv Board of Commissioners
1 a. Approval of minutes of the meeting of October 16, 2007.
1 b. Open time for public expression, up to three minutes per speaker, on items not on
the Housing Authority agenda.
1 c. Board of Commissioners' matters.
1 d. Executive Director's Report.
1 e. Presentation of "Big Shot" Awards, recognizing outstanding service of nominated
community members and staff.
1f. Request to adopt Marin Housing Authority Personnel Management Regulations,
effective January 1, 2008.
Recommended action: Approve.
1 g. Authorize Executive Director to issue Request for Proposal ("RFP") for legal
services on a fee for service basis related to tenant actions.
Recommended action: Approve.
1 h. Authorize the submission of applications for Housing Operating Subsidy to the U.S.
Department of Housing and Urban Development ("HUD").
Recommended actions: Approve.
Adiourn as the Marin County Housina Authoritv Board of Commissioners
[5J
rI
".
.....
....
~
~
rI
All County public meetings are conducted in accessible locations.
If you require American Sign Language interpreters, assistive listening devices or other accommodations to participate in
this meeting, these may be requested by calling (415) 499-7331 (voice) or (415) 499-6172 (TTY) at least 72 hours in advance.
Copies of documents used in this meeting are available in accessible formats upon written request.
The agenda is available on the Internet at htto:/lwww.co.marin.ca.us/efiles/BS/AaMn/cvbaanda.htm
The Board meeting is broadcast live over the Internet at httD:/Iwww.co.marin.ca.us/deots/BS/Archive/Meetinas.cfm
A copy of the agenda will be faxed upon request by dialing (415)-499-6060 and entering "181" after the brief introductory message.
~
10:00 a.m. Convene as the Board of Supervisors
2. Board of Supervisors' matters.
3. Administrator's report.
4. Open time for public expression, up to three minutes per speaker, on items not on
the Board of Supervisors' agenda.
5. Consent Calendar A (Items CA-1 through CA-11)
("Consent Calendar A" reflects those agenda items that have prior policy approval
from the Board.)
6. Consent Calendar B (Item CB-1)
("Consent Calendar B" reflects those agenda items requiring four affirmative votes
relating to budgetary matters.)
7. Presentation of Resolution of Commendation to Senator Carole Migden for her
work on SB 418 regarding local property tax funding.
8. Request from the County Administrator to approve transfer of $2,000,000 to the
County's Affordable Housing Trust Fund for further development of high priority
affordable housing opportunities.
Recommended actions: Approve actions as detailed in staff report dated
November 20,2007.
9. Request from the County Administrator for Board concurrence and adoption of
response to 2006-2007 Grand Jury Report "The Disability Retirement Process:
Perception and Reality" (May 11, 2007).
Recommended actions: Concur in and thereby adopt the response and
direct the President to submit the response to the Presiding Judge.
10. Request from the County Administrator to adopt resolution of notice of intention to
lease property with option to purchase for the building at 3110 Kerner Boulevard,
San Rafael, in the Health and Wellness Campus.
Recommended actions: (a) Adopt resolution setting hearing for December
18, 2007, at 10:30 a.m. for consideration of consummation of lease with an
option to purchase property; and (b) instruct clerk to publish a Notice of
Intention to Lease Property with Option to Purchase.
10:30 a.m.
11. Hearing: Ordinance amending portions of Title 19 of the Marin County Code for
the purpose of adopting the 2007 California Building Standards Code, increasing
fire sprinkler and energy efficiency requirements and clarifying the County wood
stove replacement requirements.
Recommended actions: Conduct scheduled public hearing and consider
adopting ordinance.
Marin County BOS Agenda
2
11/20/20(-
12. Request from the Parks and Open Space Director to approve personnel
adjustments related to internal administrative staffing needs.
Recommended actions: Approve (a) deletion of 1.0 FTE Administrative
Services Associate position (Class #0319); (b) addition of 1.0 FTE
Administrative Services Technician position (Class #0318); and (c) related
budget actions as detailed in staff report dated November 20, .2007.
13. Request from the Department of Public Works to authorize President to execute
amendment to agreement with the Marin Sanitary Service, reflecting a 2.40/0 rate
increase for refuse and recycling services in the Ross Valley North Franchise area.
Recommended actions: Approve.
11 :00 a.m.
14. Hearing: Ordinance amending Chapters 16.10 and 16.16 of the Marin County
Code regarding fees for services provided by the Marin County Fire Department
and adopting portions of the California Fire Code, International Fire Code and
Uniform Fire Code. .
Recommended actions: Conduct scheduled public hearing and consider
adopting ordinance.
15. Appointments:
a. Wildlife and Fisheries Committee
One term expiration representing Conservation. Applications have been
received from Ed Baquerizo and Susan Ristow (incumbent).
Recommended action: Conduct interviews and make appointment.
b. County Service Area ("CSA") #33 - Stinson Beach
Two term expirations. Applications have been received from the incumbents,
Lance Meade and Ralph Robinson.
Recommended action: Make two (2) appointments.
c. In-Home Supportive Services (1IHSS") Public Authoritv Governino Board
Two term expirations for Consumer representatives. The incumbents, Doris
Enberg and Aneice Taylor, have reapplied.
Recommended action: Make two (2) appointments.
d. Intearated Pest Manaaement (1IPM") Commission
Three term expirations as follows: Licensed Pest Control Operator (Kevin
Davis, incumbent), District 1 At-Large representative (Pamela Reaves,
incumbent), and District 3 At-Large representative (Sandy Ross, incumbent).
Recommended action: Schedule appointments for December 11, 2007.
e. Maior Crimes Task Force Oversiaht Committee
One term expiration for the Board of Supervisors' appointee (Terrence
Murphy, incumbent).
Recommended action: Schedule appointment for December 11,2007.
Marin County BOS Agenda
3
11/20/2007
f. Mental Health Board
i. One vacancy representing Public Interest. An application has been
received from Dan Leach and a letter dated October 9, 2007, has been
received from the Mental Health Board Chair recommending his
appointment.
Recommended action: Make appointment.
ii. One term expiration representing Public Interest (Alan Carr, incumbent).
Recommended action: Schedule appointment for December 11,
2007.
g. Tam Desion Review Board
i. One vacancy due to the resignation of Crystal Barriscale. An application
has been received from April Post.
Recommended action: Make appointment.
ii. One vacancy due to the resignation of Robert Freitas.
Recommended action: Schedule appointment for December 4,
2007.
h. Workforce Investment Board ("WIB")
Two vacancies representing Business. Applications have been received from
Craig Nelson and Pat Sorber.
Recommended action: Make two (2) appointments.
Recess as the Board of Supervisors
11 :15 a.m. Convene as the Marin County Open Space District Board of Directors
16a. Approval of minutes of the meeting of October 30, 2007.
16b. Board of Directors' matters.
16c. Open time for public expression, up to three minutes per speaker, on items not on
the Open Space District Agenda.
16d. General Manager's report.
16e. Request to adopt resolution honoring the 35th anniversary of the Midpeninsula
Regional Open Space District.
Recommended action: Approve.
16f. Authorize President to execute Notice of Completion, and take related actions as
detailed in staff report dated November 20, 2007, related to the Top Flight Trail
Bridge I nstallation Project.
Recommended actions: (i) Authorize Notice of Completion; and (ii) approve
release of the retention amount of $14,842.10, 35 days after Board action, to
W.R. Forde Associates of Richmond. (Project No. 2007-07)
Marin County BOS Agenda
4
11/20/2007
16g. Authorize President to execute License Agreement with French Ranch LLC to
allow trail improvements, maintenance and public access on property adjacent to
the San Geronimo Valley Golf Course.
Recommended action: Approve.
Adiourn as the Marin County Open Space District Board of Directors
Reconvene as the Board of Supervisors
17. Closed Session:
a. Instructions to labor negotiator (Human Resources Director) regarding all
bargaining units pursuant to Government Code Section 54957.6.
b. Conference with legal counsel regarding anticipated litigation pursuant to
California Government Code Section 54956.9(b)(1). Number of potential
cases: One or more.
c. Conference with legal counsel regarding anticipated litigation pursuant to
California Government Code Section 54956.9(b)(1). Number of potential
cases: One.
1 :30 p.m. Reconvene in Open Session
Announcement from Closed Session.
18. Workshop to discuss Capital Projects, priorities, and Facilities Asset Management
Planning. (To be conducted in Room 324 A, with supporting informational materials
to be made available at the time of the meeting.)
CA-1.
CA-2.
**********************
CONSENT CALENDAR A (Items CA-1 throuah CA-11)
("Consent Calendar A" reflects those agenda items that have prior policy approval
from the Board.)
Aud itor -Controller:
a. Request to adopt Resolution No. 2007- authorizing temporary transfer
of funds, in an amount not to exceed $2,744,000, to the San Rafael
Redevelopment Agency for meeting obligations incurred for maintenance
purposes for FY 2007-08.
b. Request to adopt Resolution No. 2007- authorizing temporary transfer
of funds, in an amount not to exceed $800,000, to the Marinwood Community
Service District for meeting obligations incurred for maintenance purposes for
FY 2007-08.
Board of Supervisors:
a. Supervisor Adams requesting resolution proclaiming the week of November
26-December 2,2007, as "National Influenza Vaccination Week."
b. Supervisor Arnold requesting resolution commending Ernie Gray for his many
accomplishments and service to the Novato community.
Marin County BOS Agenda
5
11/20/2007
CA-3.
CA-4.
CA-5.
CA-6.
c. Supervisor Kinsey requesting resolution recognizing the 50th anniversary of
the National Council on Alcoholism, and the work of this organization
throughout the Bay Area.
d. Supervisor Kinsey requesting resolution commending the Marin County
Auditor-Controller's Office for receiving the State Controller's "Award for
Achieving Excellence in Financial Reporting".
Community Development Aqency:
Authorize President to execute Third Addendum to agreement with Terrell Watt,
increasing the amount by $10,000 for a total contract amount of $200,000 and
extending the contract term to December 31, 2007, to provide additional consulting
services for the Marin Countywide Plan.
County Administrator:
a. Authorize President to execute agreement with the Marin Resource
Conservation District, in the amount of $100,000, for program support.
b. Authorize President to execute agreement with the Marin County Bicycle
Coalition, in the amount of $40,000, for program support of the Coalition in
identifying grant opportunities for pedestrian and bicycle projects, to support
the County goals identified in the Marin County Pedestrian and Bicycle
Master Plan and to partner with projects that benefit the unincorporated areas
of the County.
Health and Human Services:
NOTE: Agreement in item CA-5c is a renewal of an existing agreement that
was included in and funded in the FY 2007-08 budget.
a. Authorize President to execute the following FY 2007 -08 subcontract
agreements, totaling $685,939, with the following community-based agencies
for services to older adults in Marin: (i) Catholic Charities CYO, in the amount
of $429,263, for nutrition services; (ii) Jewish Family & Children's Services, in
the amount of $230,676, for case management services; and (iii) West Marin
Senior Services, in the amount of $26,000, for case management services.
b. Authorize President to execute two-year agreement with Buck Institute for
Age Research, in the amount of $84,375, to provide laboratory services for
the Marin Women's Study ("MWS") breast cancer research project.
c. Authorize President to execute FY 2007-08 agreement with Marin Advocates
for Children, in the amount of $53,000, to provide training for the prevention of
child abuse.
Information Services and Technoloqy:
Request to approve purchase of scheduling software, in the amount of $153,095,
from Tidal Software to support the job scheduling requirements of the new property
tax system and of the MERIT financial system.
Marin'-"ounty BaS Agenda
6
11/20/2007
CA-7.
CA-8.
CA-9.
CA-10.
CA-11 .
Parks:
Authorize President to execute agreement with John Avots, in the amount of
$30,000, for engineering-related work to assist with storm related repair work and
construction projects.
Probation:
Approve request for Discharge of Accountability pursuant to Sections 25257 and
25259 of the Government Code for FY 2006-07 probation fees totaling $47,681.
Public Defender:
Authorize President to execute First Amendment to the agreement with the State
of California, extending the term to 2009, to provide representation in juvenile
dependency hearings.
Public Works:
a. Request to approve assignment of existing corporate hangar site C-403
lease, located at Gnoss Field, from Barney Aldridge (Aldridge Aircraft LLC) to
Colin Lind (Hangar C-403, LLC).
b. Authorize President to execute Second Addendum to agreement with Sally
Swanson Associates, extending the contract term to December 31,2009, .and
assigning a new contract manager, to provide assistance with State and
Federal laws, regulations and building codes related to accessibility for
persons with disabilities.
c. Authorize President to execute Notice of Completion for the 2007 Pavement
Rehabilitation Program-Phase 2, Northern Region; and approve release of
the retention amount of $50,193.69, 35 days after Board action, to
Intermountain Slurry Seal, Inc. of Rancho Cordova. (Project No. ER06045b)
d. Authorize additional contingency funds, in the amount of $120,000, for the
2007 Pavement Rehabilitation Program - Central Region Resurfacing.
(Project No. ER07036) .
e. Request to accept Report of Award of Contract for the North San Pedro Road
Streetlight Replacement, Garden to La Pasada Project. (Project No.
ECMCLD).
f. Approve single source four (4) month rental of a Vac-Con Combination Sewer
and Storm Drain Cleaner, in the amount of $43,300, from Municipal
Maintenance Equipment of Sacramento, CA, for the Department of Public
Works Roads Division.
g. Authorize President to execute First Addendum to the agreement with
Stetson Engineering, Inc., extending the contract term to January 1, 2008, for
hydraulic modeling engineering services in Ross Valley, District 2.
Sheriff:
Request to adopt Resolution No. 2007-_ establishing the Jail Access Fee, in the
amount of $242.00, to charge each law enforcement agency with arrest powers in
the County, pursuant to Government Code Section 29551 and AB 1805.
~\f BOS Agenda
7
11/20/2007
CONSENT CALENDAR B (Item CB-1) (Four affirmative votes reauired)
("Consent Calendar B" reflects those agenda items requiring four affirmative votes
relating to budgetary matters.)
CB-1. Health and Human Services:
Request from the Department of Health and Human Services, Division of Social
Services to (a) accept FY 2007-08 award of $25,000 from the California
Department of Social Services ("CDSS") for Kinship Support Services Programs
("KSSP") to provide community-based family support services to relative
caregivers and their dependent children; and (b) approve related budget actions as
detailed in staff report dated November 20, 2007.
f
Marin County BOS Agenda
8
IJJ~
~
or)
S
~....
AGENDA
DIGEST. 0
fD)~@~~W~rm
mJ NOV 1 6 2007 l0
TOWN ATTORNEY'S OFFiCE
TOWN OF TIBURON
Tuesday, November 20, 2007
BOARD OF DIRECTORS
MARIN COUNTY OPEN SPACE DISTRICT
Board of Supervisors Chambers
Marin County Civic Center
11: 15 a.m. Agenda items will be heard at the time specified or later, depending on the
progress of the meeting.
A. Approval of Minutes from the meeting of October 30,2007.
B. Board of Directors' matters.
C. Open time for public expression, up to three minutes per speaker, on items not on the
Open Space District Agenda.
D. General Manager's report.
E. Request to adopt a resolution honoring the 35th anniversary of the Midpeninsula
Regional Open Space District.
Recommended action: Approve.
F. Authorize President to execute Notice of Completion, and take related actions as
detailed in staff report dated November 20,2007. re;ated tp theTop Fight Trail Bridge
Installation Project.
Recommended actions: (1) Authorize execution of Notice of Completion; and
(2) Release retention amount of $14, 842.10 thirty-five days after Board action to
W.R. Forde Associates of Richmond (Project No. 2007-07).
G. Authorize President to execute License Agreement with French Ranch LLC to allow trail
improvements, maintenenance and public access on property adjacent to the San
Geronimo Valley Golf Course.
Recommended action: Approve.
~fI
I ,,~l 'itl ~
i .~~ ~ ~
American Sign Language interpreters may be requested by calling (415) 499-6172 (TTY) or (415) (499-7331) (voice) at least
72 hours in advance. Copies of documents are available in accessible formats upon written request. The Board Agenda is
available on the internet at htto:/www.co.marin.ca.us/efiles/BS/AQMn/cybaQnda.htm.
The Board meeting is broadcast live over the Internet at http://www.co.marin.ca.us/depts/BS/Archive/MeetinQs.cfm.
A copy of the Board of Supervisors agenda will be faxed upon request by dialing (415) 499-6060 and entering "181" after the
brief introductory message.
OPEN SPACE DISTRICT AGENDA FOR NOVEMBER 20, 2007 MEETING
."
DIGEST ,.
RECEIVED
AGENDA FOR NOV 2 6 2007
MARIN COUNTY BOARD OF SUPERVISORS TOWN
MANAGERS OFFICE
TOWN OF TIBURON
Agenda items will be heard at the time specified or later, depending on the progress of the
meeting.
AGENDA
Tuesday, November 27, 2007
Board of Supervisors Chambers, Room 330, Civic Center
10:00 a.m.
1. Presentation of "Employee of the Month" Award, November 2007, to Rosie
Hernandez of the Health and Human Services Department.
2. Approval of minutes of the special meeting of November 16,2007.
3. Board of Supervisors' matters.
4. Administrator's report.
5. Open time for public expression, up to three minutes per speaker, on items not on
the Board of Supervisors' agenda.
6. Consent Calendar A (Items CA-1 through CA-7)
("Consent Calendar A" reflects those agenda items that have prior policy approval
from the Board.)
7. Consent Calendar B (Item CB-1)
("Consent Calendar B" reflects those agenda items requiring four affirmative votes
relating to budgetary matters.)
8. At the req~est of Supervisor Kinsey, request from the County Administrator to
support HR 2262, a bill that would update the Mining Law of 1872 and provide
funding to clean up abandoned mines, create an abandoned mine reclamation
program, and establish environmental standards for hardrock mining on federal
land.
Recommended actions: Approve.
[CJ
rI
,.,.
.....
....
~
~
JI
All County public meetings are conducted in accessible locations.
If you require American Sign Language interpreters, assistive listening devices or other accommodations to participate in
this meeting, these may be requested by calling (415) 499-7331 (voice) or (415) 499-6172 (TTY) at least 72 hours in advance.
Copies of documents used in this meeting are available in accessible fonnats upon written request.
The agenda is available on the Internet at htto:/Iwww.co.marin.ca.us/efiles/BS/AaMn/cvbaanda.htm
The Board meeting is broadcast live over the Internet at htto://www.co.marin.ca.us/deots/BS/Archive/Meetinas.cfm
A copy of the agenda will be faxed upon request by dialing (415)-499-6060 and entering "181" after the brief introductory message.
.~.
.
t-.,.:. .#!r '\ ...
5.
.';: ..
9.
Report from the County Administrator on the results of the 2007 Countywide
Community Survey.
Recommended actions: Accept Report.
10. Request from the Community Development Agency, Environmental Health
Services Division, to take the following actions related to the development of an
improved beach water quality monitoring test:
a. Authorize acceptance of grant agreement, in the amount of $848,000, for the
Beach Monitoring-Phylochip project; and
b. Approve related budget actions as detailed in staff report dated November 27,
2007.
Recommended actions: Approve.
11. First Reading: Ordinance amending Chapter 7.70 of the Marin County Code
pertaining to smoking regulations.
Recommended actions: Request clerk to read ordinance by title only and
schedule merit hearing for December 11, 2007, at 10:30 a.m.
12. Hearing: Consideration of a resolution establishing the Alameda del Prado
Underground Utility District.
Recommended actions: (a) Conduct hearing; (b) consider adopting
resolution establishing the Alameda del Prado Underground Utility District;
and (c) authorize expenditure of Rule 20A funds to perform the
undergrounding of utilities along Alameda del Prado between Alameda de la
Loma and Posada del Sol.
13. Request from the County Administrator to adopt resolution establishing retiree
health Plan 3 allocation for 2008.
Recommended actions: Adopt resolution.
14. Appointments:
a. Children and Families Commission
One term expiration representing Health and Human Services (Charlene
Reid, incumbent).
Recommended action: Schedule appointment for December 18,2007.
b. Economic Commission
One term expiration representing the Center for Volunteer and Nonprofit
Leadership. The incumbent, Marilee Eckert, has reapplied.
Recommended action: Make appointment.
c. Law Library Board of Trustees
Court Executive Officer Kim Turner has requested that the Board of
Supervisors appoint an additional member to this Board. An application has
been received from Jason Nelson and a memorandum dated November 8,
2007, has been received from Law Library staff recommending his
appointment.
Recommended action: Make appointment.
Marin County BOS Agenda
2
11/27/'Lr: J7
d. Workforce I nvestment Board
One vacancy representing Labor due to the resignation of Kris Organ.
Recommended action: Schedule appointment for December 11, 2007.
11 :00 a.m.
15. Hearing: Cox Appeal of the Planning Commission's Conditional Approval of the
Cox Minor Design Review. 555 McClay Road, Novato. (APN 146-180-44)
Recommended actions: (a) Review the administrative record; (b) conduct
public hearing; and (c) make determination on Appeal.
16. Closed Session:
a. Conference with Legal Counsel regarding consideration of initiating litigation
pursuant to California Government Code Section 54956.9(c): Number of
potential cases: One (1). Name of case: City of Novato v. North Coast
Railroad Authority, Superior Court of the State of California, County of Marin,
Case No. 074645.
b. Conference with legal counsel regarding anticipated litigation pursuant to
California Government Code Section 54956.9(b)(1). Number of potential
cases: One.
CA-1.
CA-2.
CA-3.
Reconvene in Open Session
Announcement from Closed Session.
**********************
CONSENT CALENDAR A (Items CA-1 throuah CA-7)
("Consent Calendar A" reflects those agenda items that have prior policy approval
from the Board.)
Board of Supervisors:
Supervisor Brown requesting resolution recognizing Gloria Simoneaux for her work
supporting the well being of homeless children.
Community Development Aaencv:
Authorize President to execute First Addendum to the agreement with Robert W.
Hayes, Architect, extending the contract term to December 31, 2009, and
increasing the contract amount by $3,800 for a total of $45,500, for services
related to the Toussin Senior Affordable Housing project.
County Administrator:
a. Authorize President to approve report of delegated agreements executed by
the County Administrator during the months of July, August and September
2007.
b. Authorize President to execute amendment to agreement with Alcade &
Associates, Ltd., providing for payments of $78,000 plus expenses, effective
January 1, 2008, for representation services in Washington, D.C.
Marin County BOS Agenda
3
11/27/2007
CA-4.
CA-5.
CA-6.
CA-7.
CB-1.
c. Adopt Resolution No. 2007- continuing the local emergency declaration
for the County of Marin, related to the COSCO BUSAN oil spill which created
a local environmental disaster, in conformance with Government Code
Section 8630.
Health and Human Services:
NOTE: Agreement in item CA-4b is a renewal of an existing agreement that
was included in and funded in the FY 2007-08 budget.
a. Authorize President to execute FY 2007-08 agreement with Tarcisio Ching, in
an amount not to exceed $32,000, for consultation and training services
related to the preparation of Targeted Case Management ("TCM") and mental
health cost reports.
b. Authorize President to execute FY 2007-08 agreement with the Marin
Children and Families Commission, in the amount of $30,000, to provide early
childhood health and safety trainings to participants in the Health
Advocacy/Health Literacy Initiative.
Probation:
a. Authorize President to execute agreement with the California Institute for
Mental Health ("CIMH"), in the amount of $78,000, to provide clinical training
in Multidimensional Family Therapy.
b. Authorize President to execute agreement with the California Institute for
Mental Health ("CIMH"), in the amount of $70,250, to provide Functional
Family Therapy Development Team training.
Public Works:
a. Approve single source purchase of pharmaceuticals, from Contract Pharmacy
Services (CPS) of Warrington, PA, in the amount of $28,780.82, for the Marin
County Health and Human Services Detention Medical Department.
b. Authorize (i) President to execute Second Addendum to the agreement with
Township Building Maintenance, increasing contract by $6,684 for a total
contract amount of $400,236, for janitorial services at the Marin Civic Center and
Jail; and (ii) Public Works Director to approve annual contract extensions for up
to three subsequent years, as detailed in staff report dated November 27, 2007.
Treasurer:
Request to approve Annual Statement of Investment Policy in accordance with
Government Code Sections 53646.
CONSENT CALENDAR 8 (Item CB-1) (Four affirmative votes reauired)
("Consent Calendar B" reflects those agenda items requiring four affirmative votes
relating to budgetary matters.)
Community Development Aqencv:
Request from the Community Development Agency to (a) accept $25,000 grant
from the California Department of Health Services, to monitor water quality at
beaches around the County; and (b) approve related budget actions as detailed in
staff report dated November 27, 2007.
Marin County 80S Agenda
'I
11/27/2007
DIGEST ~
WATER TRANSIT AUTHORITY
.L
JJ.~U U .x._
"11
V'I
~
~
I
.....
INTA
RECEIVED
NOV 2 1 2007
COMMUNITY ADVISORY COMMITTEE
AGENDA
TOWN MANAGERS OFFICE
TOWN OF TIBURON
Wednesday, December 5,2007 -- 10:30 am to 12:00 pm
Port Commission Room, San Francisco Ferry Building
Ferry Building, Second Floor Committee Room
Embarcadero at Market Street, San Francisco
1. Call to Order
2. Roll Call
3. Motion to Approve - Minutes of September 12, 2007 meeting
4. Report of CAC Chair Diane Howard
A. Recent CAC Activities
B. Follow up Activities
5. Update on 58976
A. Review of S8 976 requirements, CEO Steve Castleberry
B. Status of Clean-up Legislation, CEO Steve Castleberry
6. Service Updates
South San Francisco/Redwood City
A Funding, Diane Howard and Pedro Gonzalez
B. Terminal Construction packages, John Sindzinski, Manager of Planning and Development
Berkelev and Hercules
Overview, John Sindzinski, Manager of Planning and Development
Antioch Presentation
Mr. Victor Carniglia, City of Antioch (invited)
Martinez Presentation
Mayor Rob Schroeder, City of Martinez (invited)
- 1 -
~
j
7. Community Outreach & MarketinQ
. Report on Marketing and Community Outreach Activities - Shirley Douglas, wr A
Community Relations Manager
8. Next SteDs
. Remarks from wr A Board President Charlene Haught Johnson
9. Public Comment A 15-minute period of public comment will be held at the end of the meeting.
Please fill out a speaker card. No action can be taken on any matter raised during the public
comment period. Speakers will be limited to a maximum of 3 minutes and will be heard in order of
sign-up.
PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION
FERRIES: Entrance to the Ferry Building Committee room is on the second floor of the Ferry
Building on the Embarcadero side of the building. Enter the center doors to access the stairwell.
Elevators are also provided.
BART/MUNI: Embarcadero Station is 1 1/2-blocks away, at the corner of Market and Beale.
CALTRAIN STATION: Approximately a 20-minute walk from 4th and Townsend. Suggest
connecting with Muni outbound N-Judah, getting off at Embarcadero Station.
GOLDEN GATE TRANSIT: Stops on Fremont, directly across from the Downtown Center. Walk 10
I minutes to Embarcadero, cross Embarcadero and enter Ferry Building
PARKING GARAGES: There are many public garages near the Ferry Building around Market
Street, but capacity is limited and they can be up to $25 per day. Some charge hourly.
Here are some options for parking near the Ferry Building:
. Parking is available at the north end of the Ferry Building at the Pier 1/2 and the Washington
and Embarcadero Lot directly across from Pier %, also at the 75 Howard Street Garage.
. There is usually plenty of metered street parking, however these spaces are $1 per hour and
meter maids are strict about ticketing.
- 2 -
MEETING SUMMARY
San Francisco Bay Area Water Transit Authority Community Advisory Committee Meeting
Summary
CAC List of attendees attached hereto.
ATTENDEES:
MEETING September 12, 2007
DATE:
FROM: Karen Shelver, Board Secretary
DATE: December 5,2007
----. NEXT MEETING: December 5.2007 -10am-12Dm. Location TBD. SF CA
The Community Advisory Committee held its meeting on September 12, 2007 from 10:00 a.m.-
12:00 p.m. The meeting began at 10: 15 am.
1. Call to Order and Motion to Approve Minutes of (April 18, 2007) CAC Meeting
A motion to approve the April 18, 2007 meeting minutes was made by Mr. Arne Simonsen
(Antioch). The motion was seconded by Mr. Pedro Gonzalez (South San Francisco) and the item
was approved unanimously. There were neither abstentions nor any opposition.
2. Report of Committee Chair
Chair Diane Howard had no report to make.
3. ReDort of WT A CEO
Mr. Steve Castleberry reported on SB 976, reviewing the particulars of the bill that is scheduled to
pass through the legislature and how it will affect the WfA if it passes. He noted key aspects of the
bill including the following:
(a) Board of Directors reduction from 11 to 5 members (will have until April 08 to appoint
Directors) - 3 appointed by the Governor, 1 appointed by Senator Perata and 1 appointed
by Assemblyman Nunez.
(b) Broad authority for emergency response
(c) Consolidates Alameda and Vallejo ferry operators
(d) Places requirements for transportation and emergency response plans
(e) New flexibility for implementation of ferry service through RM1 and RM2 funds
Mr. Arne Simonsen (Antioch) asked who provided input into the bill. Mr. Castleberry responded that
input was given by Senators Torlakson and Perata and the Bay Area Council, as well as from the
Wf A. He noted that the Authority was aware of imminent changes to our governing legislation but
unaware to what extent those changes would alter the agency. He further noted the legislation, as
written, does not specifically include a Community Advisory Committee. He recommended that
CAC members write to their representatives to voice concerns related to each member's City's
representation.
Chair Howard asked if the legislation clarifies the way funds will be distributed in emergency
response. Mr. Castleberry answered that the language is generic on the subject, but that a clean
up bill has been proposed to clear up ambiguities in this version of the bill.
MINUTES SEPTEMBER 12, 2007
SAN FRANCISCO BAY AREA WATER TRANSIT AUTHORITY COMMUNITY ADVISORY COMMITTEE MEETING SUMMARY (9/12/07)
Mr. Pedro Gonzalez (South San Francisco) expressed concern that each City is adequately
represented in the new legislation.
Mr. Simonsen asked if they are locked in on the agency's new name. Mr. Castleberry said yes, the
name will change.
Ms. Jewel Okawachi (Albany) asked if a sample letter to the Governor and Senator Perata could
be provided by staff. Chair Howard requested that staff draft and distribute a sample letter for CAC
members to respond to the legislation.
4. INFORMATIONAL PRESENTATION: Spare Vessel update
Mr. Charles Walther, Walther Engineering, gave a PowerPoint Presentation on the status of the
WT A's spare vessels.
Mr. Fred Hansson (San Mateo) asked if the vessels are on schedule for delivery. Mr. Walther
answered that they are on schedule with the first vessel due to be delivered August 2008.
5. INFORMATIONAL PRESENTATION: South San Francisco update
Mr. John Sindzinski, WT A, gave a PowerPoint Presentation updating the South San Francisco
terminal project.
Mr. Gonzalez asked if there will be outdoor seating available. Mr. Sindzinski said there will be
some seating for waiting passengers, in particular the disabled and seniors.
6. INFORMATIONAL PRESENTATION: Berkelev/Albanv update
I Mr. Sindzinski gave a PowerPoint Presentation updating the Berkeley/Albany service project.
Mr. Hansson asked how a change in ridership is accounted for should Bay Meadows Race Track
close and the area get redeveloped. Mr. Sindzinski answered it would be difficult to quantify
ridership in such a case. The ridership model is now based on commuters only.
Ms. Okawachi commented that in a 3 -2 vote, the Albany City Council voted against pursuing the
two Albany sites and noted that the Buchanan site in Berkeley is the best location for emergency
response.
7. INFORMATONAL PRESENTATION: Redwood City update
Mr. Michael Giari, Port of Redwood City, gave a PowerPoint Presentation updating Redwood City
service plans.
Mr. Paul Albritton (Sausalito) asked about transit access to the proposed terminal site and to what
depth it would be dredged. Mr. Giari answered that shuttle service to the terminal from parking lots
is being studied as well as use of an existing rail line during the day. The existing rail line now is
only being used at night for freight purposes. He added that dredging would occur at 10 feet at
West Point Slough and 12 feet at the dock. He noted that this information has been presented to
CCAG, the San Mateo County Transportation Authority and Water Transit Advocates of San Mateo
County.
Chair Howard added that the ridership estimates will be updated because approximately 1 million
square feet of office space near the terminal site is now occupied.
8. INFORMATIONAL PRESENTATION: Proposition 1B Fundina update
Ms. Nina Rannells, WT A, gave an update on Proposition 1 B safety and security program funding.
Mr. Albritton asked if GGBHTD is eligible for the Prop 1 B ferry-specific funds. Ms. Rannells
responded that SB 88, which identifies the program criteria, specifies that only regional ferry
MINUTES (MTG.DA TE)
SAN FRANCISCO BAY AREA WATER TRANSIT AUTHORITY COMMUNITY ADVISORY COMMITTEE MEETING SUMMARY (9/12/07)
agencies ineligible to receive safety and security funds through the alternative statewide ST A
formula program are eligible to receive the special ferry funds. Since GGBHTD is an ST A recipient
they will not be eligible to receive the ferry security funds. .
Chair Howard introduced WT A Board President, Charlene Haught Johnson, who gave a brief recap
of SB 976 and thanked the CAC for its hard work over the years, and hoped that the legislation will
be rewritten to allow for the CAC to continue advocating for ferry service. Chair Howard thanked
President Johnson and Director Secchitano for their outstanding work on the Board of Directors
and mimicked President Johnson's hope to continue with the CAC.
9. COMMUNITY OUTREACH AND MARKETING
Ms. Shirley Douglas, WT A, gave an update on community outreach and marketing. She noted the
following efforts:
(a) Newsletter - spotlighting Senator Patty Murray and the recent keel laying ceremony at the
Seattle boatyard where the WTA's spare vessels are being built
(b) Lunch Bunch ferry events during the summer - highlighting increased ridership during the
events and an overall satisfaction with the events
(c) Employer Transportation representatives meetings, focusing on building awareness for
those who live in the East Bay and commute to South San Francisco
10. NEXT MEETING: The next meeting of the CAC is scheduled for December 5,2007.
Mr. Albritton suggested inviting staff from Senators Torlakson and Perata's offices to the December
meeting.
11. PUBLIC COMMENT
There was no public comment.
Chair Howard adjourned the meeting at 12:00 p.m.
###
MINUTES (MTG.DA TE)
0...""'"
>0
(/)~
0::: -
o>N
C"-
;.;:; 0)
0).0
0) E
:E 0)
0-
<(g-
O(/)
~ 0>
t "m t:: c
a .L:- a "C
0... 0 0... 0)
0)
m ~ ~ ~ c
c '0,
; a (3 a"E (3 U "C C
C ~ W
Q) a 0) "C 0) co "C "C co
- m a - a a a a ~
II) (ij a co [C ~ ~ >- [C .L:- a>
Q) :E ~ :E c 0 .L:-
g. f/) LL ~ co ~ 0 -
:;j C "C C "C "C ;.;:; ~
Q) co co a> (/) co a> 0) .0 C
~ (/) (/) 0::: (/) (/) c::: 0::: <( <(
Q)
E 0)
ns c f/)
Z a 0) a> - co 0)
- 0) 0) L- "C 't: C 0) C 0) 't:
~ "S 'w ~ "C a> co "~ 0 ~ 'C c ro
co :;j ~ a> L- .L:- .C a> co L- .L:-
u: 0... (/) 0... LL 0 Cl W ...., :E <( 0
c
a
f/)
c
Q) .L:- a
E N a E c c
c ...., co a>
ns c a> a :E "C ~ 0 - f/) L-
Z ~ c (ij f/) L- a> co E c a>
- co N f/) 0> co L- ~ 0 a :;
II) L- .5 'C c c :;j ~ Q. co 0 E (ij
ns .0 co a co co a co ~ 0)
..J <( <( (5 C> J: J: J: Z 0 (/) U5 ~