HomeMy WebLinkAboutTC Digest 2009-05-21o'~;00*10
TOWN COUNCIL WEEKLY DIGEST
Week of May 15 - 21, 2009
Tilk-s-irnrn
1. Letter - Mill Valley Refuse - Response to Rate Increase Questions
2. Update Exercise - MCSTOPPP JPA
Agendas & Minutes
3. Minutes - Belvedere/Tiburon Library Agency - April 20, 2009
4. Minutes - Design Review Board - May 7, 2009
5. Minutes - Planning Commission - May 13, 2009
6. Action Minutes - Design Review Board - May 21, 2009
7. Agenda - Planning Commission - May 27, 2009
8. Agenda - POST Commission - May 28, 2009
Regional
a) Public Hearing Notice - Swahn Appeal of Environmental Review
b) Invitation - Welcome Reception for Michael Frank, Novato City Manager
c) Invitation - Ground Breaking Kol Shofar - May 31, 2009
d) Discover Your Outdoors - Marin Parks & Open Space - Summer 2009
e) Service Matters - ABAG Newsletter - May/June 2009
f) News from Marin Conservation League - May/June 2009
Agendas & Minutes
g) Agenda - Marin Co Hazardous & Solid Waste JPA - May 28, 2009
* Council Only
DIGEST
MILL VALLEY REFUSE SERWCE, INC.
P.O. BOX 3557 - SAN RAFAEL, CALIFORNIA 949 12-3557
PHONE (415) 457-9760 FAX (415) 457-3003
RECEIVED
Peggy Curran, Town Manager May 13, 2009
Town of Tiburon - MAY 14 Z009
1505 Tiburon Blvd.
Tiburon, CA 94920 TOWN MANAGERS OFFICE
TOWN OF TIBURON
Dear City Managers and Council Members,
At a recent Belvedere City Council meeting, we were asked in regards to our request for a rate increase,
how we arrived at the CPI figure of 3.1 and why we chose the Annual rate over other available monthly
rates (such as December's 0% rate). I thought these questions might come up in other meetings, so with the
help of Bill Brause of Armanino McKenna (the accounting firm that is doing our annual financial statement
audit and who prepared our rate application), I have prepared the following answers for everyone.
First, the 3.1% rate comes directly from the government website, www.bls.gov. On this site, select the
Inflation & Prices menu item at top left, then Consumer Price Index.
On the CPI page that appears, scroll down to the map of the U.S. labeled Regional Resources. In the drop-
down menu under the map (labeled Select an MSA), choose San Francisco. A CPI chart for the SF area will
pop up.
Finally, choose More Formatting Options, and under Select View of the Data, choose 12 Month Percent
Change and hit Retrieve Data. A table will appear showing the 3.1% change under the Annual column.
Second, why choose the Annual change rather than some other monthly option?
The Annual CPI Index was selected to be consistent with previously approved rate application submissions.
For example, the 2007 approved CPI Increase of 3.2% was based on the Annual index. An annual index
represents the change spread throughout the year and provides the closest index to actual changes, year to
year. The month-to-month index can have significant fluctuations that are not indicative of the year in total.
For example, the December-to-December index is the only published month-to-month index for the year
that had no increase. The other reported 2008 vs. 2007 month-to-month index changes were increases
between 2.8% and 4.2%.
In our view, if a month-to-month index were used rather than the Annual index, the logical month would be
June to coincide with the actual timing of rate changes per our contracts. It would seem random and
arbitrary to choose any other month and, as already mentioned, choosing a month rather than the Annual
index would be inconsistent with past practice. (in June of this year, by the way, the rate was 4.2%.)
Given these points, we think consistent use of the Annual Index is warranted.
Sincerely Yours,
l,eJames Iavarone
ll"TYSTo DIGEST
Marin,County Department of Public Works
P. O. Box 4186 • San Rafael, CA 94913-4186
~c
Tel. (415) 499-6528 • Fax (415) 499-7221 RECEIVED
ov
p 0~4 Date: May 11, 2009 MAY 1 009
~EVEN`~t
TOWN MANAGERS OFFICE
To: MCSTOPPP Agency Staff TOWN OF TIBURON
From: Terri Fashing, Program Manager
Member
Agencies: RE: Revised Joint Exercise of Powers Agreement (JEPA)
Belvedere Please review and recommend approval by your City/Town Council the attached
Corte Madera revised Joint Exercise of Powers Agreement (JEPA) between the Marin County
Flood Control and Water Conservation District (District) and MCSTOPPP members.
County
of Marin The purpose of this JEPA revision is strictly administrative with the primary intent
being to clarify that the Board of Supervisors of the Marin County Flood Control and
Fairfax Water Conservation District is MCSTOPPP's governing body and to reflect that the
Larkspur Marin Streetlight JPA is now known as the Marin General Services Authority.
Previously the JEPA simply referred to the Board of Supervisors. Other minor edits
Mill Valley were made to clarify language related to administrative details, such as the date by
which the MGSA must recommend approval of the MCSTOPPP budget.
Novato
Ross Marin's municipalities originally adopted the JEPA in 2005. The JEPA shifted
governance of MCSTOPPP to the District's Board of Supervisors while the Marin
San Anselmo General Services Authority (formerly Streetlight JPA) continues to serve as an
advisory body to MCSTOPPP for review of the budget and other program elements.
San Rafael
Exhibit A to the JEPA is MCSTOPPP's stormwater management plan (Action Plan).
Sausalito The copy of the plan is not included with the enclosed revised JEPA and will not be
Tiburon revised until next year as MCSTOPPP responds to Phase II permitting requirements.
A copy of the plan can be viewed at www.mcstoppp.org.
To assist you with preparation of an agenda packet for your City/Town Council, we
have attached a sample staff report for your use. Upon approval of the revised JEPA
by your City/Town Council, please return a fully executed copy of the original to my
attention. The revised JEPA will be valid once seven municipalities have
executed the agreement. Thanks for your prompt attention to this request.
Attachments: Joint Exercise of Powers Agreement - final revised version
Joint Exercise of Powers Agreement - revised, showing changes
Sample staff report
c: Farhad Mansourian, Director, Marin County DPW
Michael Frost, Deputy Director, Marin County DPW
Tracy Clay, Division Chief, MCFCWCD
Paul Berlant, Marin General Services Authority
Marin County Administrator and Marin City Managers
Marin Public Works Directors
DIGEST
Regular Meeting
BELVEDERE-TIBURON LIBRARY AGENCY 30
Belvedere-Tiburon Library, Tiburon, California
April 20, 2009
MINUTES
Members Present: Lois Epstein, Mary Falk, Steger Johnson, Bill Kuhns and Heather Lobdell
Members Absent: Beverlee Johnson and Ann Otter
Staff Present: Deborah Mazzolini, Library Director and Mary Vella, Board Clerk
CALL TO ORDER: Chair Johnson called the meeting to order at 6:15PM.
OPEN FORUM:
No Comment
CLAY 2 ~ 2009 1
STAFF, BOARD AND COMMITTEE REPORTS:
1. Chair's Report TOWN CLERK
No report. TOWN OF.TIBURON
2. BTLF Report - Carol Kurland
The Governance Task Force will make a presentation at the next BTLF meeting on May 5th. It is their
goal to recommend a reorganization al structure for the Foundation so it will be able to operate in a more
effective and organized manner. The Leadership Cabinet for the expansion is also working on their
membership, mission and organizational aspects. The next newsletter will be ready for publication in
mid-May. Petrocelli Luncheon tickets are on sale. The luncheon committee is looking for raffle prize
donations. Trustee Epstein will be the BTLA liaison at the May Foundation meeting.
3. Library Director's report - Deborah Mazzolini
The Director distributed the latest statistics on library usage. For the fiscal year ending June 30, 2009
the anticipated growth rate in items borrowed is near 20%.
Work on the Personnel Policy is still in progress. The policy requires major modification to meet today's
legal requirements.
Next the administration office will review and update the Policy Regarding the Use of Bulletin Boards,
Display Case, and Free Printed Matter Distribution.
4. Financial statement
The statement for March is not available yet. This week the second half of the library's tax revenue was
received from both the Town and the City. It appears that the line item for basic taxes may be exceeded
slightly but the parcel tax budget is always exactly as budgeted. ERAF (Educational Revenue
Augmentation Fund) will total $336,389 for the year - the second half should be delivered by the end of
the fiscal year.
5. Committee Reports
This week the Program Committee is showing the film Hats Off by local Jyll Johnstone. The Art
Committee is exhibiting photographs by Len Blau - his reception is on Saturday from 2:00-4:00. The
Film Committee meets every Monday to screen possible selections. The last film shown was Pontiac
Moon.
CONSENT CALENDAR:
6. Approval of minutes of March 16, 2009
7. Approval of warrants and in house check register February 2009
A motion to approve the minutes of March 16`d and the warrants of March 2009 made by Trustee
Epstein and seconded by Trustee Falk passed.
TRUSTEE CONSIDERATIONS
8. Draft Budget FY09/10 discussion
The draft indicates that Grants from the Endowment (Item 5035/36) will be lower next year, as will
interest on the LAIF funds. Total reserves (for operations, insurance and building maintenance) are
expected to be $866,000.
Belvedere Tiburon Library Agency
Apri! 20, 2009
Minutes
Page 2
At this point the draft shows no increase in salaries.
The Town and City are both considering budgeting a 1 % to 3% increase in property tax revenue for the
next year. Utilizing a 2% estimate, this draft exhibits a worst case scenario operating deficit of
$126,469. The library has never included income from ERAF in its budget figures because it was never
guaranteed. However, after seven years of ERAF revenue, it is likely that it will continue. If ERAF were
included in the budget estimates, there would be no deficit.
Currently there is about $1.5 million in unreserved cash which could be tapped in hard economic times.
If the budget is too conservative there is no room for change.
9. Building Program Expansion update
The EIR is in progress. A 2-page summary of the project objectives was distributed which describes the
eight important goals of the library expansion.
10. Marketing, public relations and fundraising
Sally Donnell is organizing the structure of the capital campaign and the Leadership and Community
Engagement Committees are being formed. It is recommended that a shorter simpler concise brochure
be produced to distribute at home meetings to this group. The cost for 2,500 copies of a 10-panel
brochure is estimated at $10,000. While the Trustees liked the example produced, it believes this is too
slick and showy and felt that a 6-panel brochure would be more prudent.
A motion to approve a version of the sample brochure costing up to $7,000 but with the goal of spending
only $6,000 made by Trustee Epstein and seconded by Trustee Kuhns passed unanimously. This will
be funded by BTLF donations.
11. Volunteer Waiver, Release and Indemnity Agreement
This waiver was conceived as a result of the expanding homebound delivery/outreach program. It
should protect the volunteer and the library in case of injury. The library attorney reviewed the
agreement and determined that the wording did not need to be softened, that volunteers typically do not
take offense to "legalese" (most of the time the just scan and sign). The language is somewhat strong in
order to impress upon the reality of what is and is not being provided.
A motion to approve the Volunteer Waiver, Release and Indemnity Agreement made by Trustee Kuhns
and approved by Trustee Falk passed.
COMMUNICATIONS
12. Monthly calendar
13. Schedule of 2009 meeting dates
Director Mazzolini will be out of town on June 15th for the regularly scheduled meeting and the Board
agreed to move the meeting date to June 22nd. The budget for FYE June 30, 2010 will be approved at
that time.
ADJOURNMENT: The regular meeting adjourned at 7:15 pm
Respectfully submitted,
Mary Vella
Upcoming meeting:
Monday, May 18th at 6:15pm. An email will be sent to ensure a quorum.
I
MINUTES #7
TIBURON DESIGN REVEW BOARD
MEETING OF MAY 7, 2009
The meeting was opened at 7:00 p.m. by Chair Doyle.
A. ROLL CALL
Present: Chair Doyle, Boardmembers Chong, Kricensky, Tollini and Wilson
Absent: None
Ex-Officio: Associate Planner Tyler, Assistant Planner Phillips, and Minutes Clerk Rusting
B. PUBLIC COMMENTS - None
C. STAFF BRIEFING
Associate Planner Tyler reported that the application for 1887 Centro West Street was continued
to the June 4th meeting and that the zoning ordinance will be brought up for a courtesy review at
the next DRB meeting.
D. - NEW BUSINESS BEFORE THE BOARD
1. 105 ROCK HILL ROAD HUANG, ADDITIONS
105 ROCK HILL ROAD
LOT SIZE
FLOOR AREA
LOT COVERAGE
BUILDING HEIGHT
SIDE YARDS
FRONT YARD
REAR YARD
VARIANCES/EXCEPTION
PETER AND CHEIKO HUANG
EXISTING
PROPOSED
REQUIRED
2500 S.F.
NA
NA
2,641
3,037
49560 MAX
12.0%
12.8%
15.0% MAX
23'
23
30' MAX
15'& 11'6"
15' & 11'6"'
15'
33'
33'
30'
28'
28'
25'
NONE
The applicant is requesting Design Review approval for the construction of an addition and
alterations to an existing single-family dwelling located at 105 Rock Hill Road. The addition
would be located on the lower level underneath an existing attached rear deck. The addition
would include a new bedroom and bathroom. Other exterior alterations include the replacement
of the existing composition shingles with a dark brown standing seam metal roof, addition of
decorative trim on the existing dormer vents and shutters on selected windows. The lot coverage
on the site would increase by 198 square feet (0.8 to a total of 3,290 square feet (12.8
which is 2.2 % less than the 15.0% maximum lot coverage permitted in the RO-2 zone. The floor
TIBURON D.R.B. MINUTES #7
5/7/09
area on the site would increase by 198 square feet to a total of 3,290 square feet, which is 550
square feet less than the maximum allowed floor area of 3,840 square feet.
Ann Bool, designer, stated the additional square footage of the addition is for an extra bedroom
for a son returning from college. The total square footage is below the maximum allowed and
they are using similar colors and materials to existing structures in the neighborhood. She said
that they wish to change some windows to have shutters and change the front facade, but the
proposal is similar to what was approved previously.
Boardmember Wilson asked for clarification of the changed colors, and Ms. Bool clarified that
they are actually a different material. Boardmember Wilson asked if the Board should be
concerned about different materials with regard to noise, fires, etc., and the other Boardmembers
responded and voiced no concerns.
There was no public comment.
Boardmember Wilson said the new room would not impact anyone or anything and is fine.
Boardmember Chong noted that the addition would be tucked in the back and present no
problems for the neighbors or the neighborhood.
ACTION: It was M/S (Wilson/Tollini) that the request for 105 Rock Hill Road is exempt from
the California Environmental Quality Act and approved the project subject to the attached
conditions of approval. Vote: 5-0.
2. 30 PAMELA COURT SIMONSON, ADDITIONS
30 PAMELA COURT
TODD AND SUSAN SIMONSON
EXISTING
PROPOSED
REQUIRED
LOT SIZE
8,969 S.F.
NA
NA
FLOOR AREA
1,007
2,320
25897 MAX
LOT COVERAGE
14.9%
25.9%
30.0% MAX
BUILDING HEIGHT
13'
17'
30' MAX
SIDE YARDS
6' & 21'8"
6' & 7'5"
6'
FRONT YARD
28'
28'
20'
REAR YARD
29'
20'
25'
VARIANCES/EXCEPTION
NONE
The applicant is requesting Design Review approval for the construction of additions and
alterations to an existing single-family home located at 30 Pamela Court. The additions would
include expanding the existing home behind the garage and on the right side. The additions
would be faced in horizontal wood siding. The garage would be converted into living space and
the driveway expanded to allow for an additional parking space. The proposed additions are
elevated 3 feet in order to comply with the flood zone ordinance as the property is located in
within the flood zone. Other changes proposed with this application include the addition of 10
TIBURON D.R.B. MINUTES #7 2
5/7/09
skylights, reconfigured windows and the sliding glass doors. The lot coverage on the site would
increase by 982 square feet (11 to a total of 2,320 square feet (25.9 which is 4.1 % less
than the 3 0.0% maximum lot coverage permitted in the R-1-BA zone. The floor area on the site
would increase by 1,313 square feet to a total of 2,320 square feet, which is 577 square feet less
than the maximum allowed floor area of 2,897 square feet.
Lara Conte, architect, discussed the rationale behind the design. She stated that the property
presented them with atypical conditions because the property is-located in a flood zone, and
Tiburon Boulevard runs in the back of the property. She stated that the flood zone required that
the addition be 8 feet above sea level. She noted that construction in a flood zone involves strict
requirements, and if they were to go above a certain threshold they would have to tear down the
house and rebuild. She said the owners circulated a notice in their neighborhood about the
construction and made minor changes to window sizes. She said that the master bedroom has
fewer windows and only looks onto front yard to avoid noise from Tiburon Boulevard. She said
that the design was almost identical to other additions in the neighborhood. She stated that their
intent was to keep the house as is and add on separate elements to increase the living space.
Boardmember Kricensky asked if the floor plan indicates windows on the north side. Ms. Conte
said no, there were windows there at one time but they were removed.
There was no public comment.
Boardmember Kricensky thought that this was a reasonable design given the constraints, and
architecturally would be an improvement to the house.
Boardmember Wilson said he liked the fact that the neighbors worked out any issues and he
liked the design. He added that there would be almost no impact to the other properties on the
street.
Chair Doyle said that this was a nice design, would fit in with the neighborhood, and well
thought out.
ACTION: It was M/S (Tollini/Wilson) that the request for 30 Pamela Court is exempt from the
California Environmental Quality Act and approved the project subject to the attached conditions
of approval. Vote: 5-0.
3. 200 GILMARTIN DRIVE LEHMAN, HVAC UNITS
The applicant is requesting Design Review approval for the addition of four exterior HVAC units
for an existing single-family dwelling located at 200 Gilmartin Drive. The units would be located
along the uphill side of the existing home and inside the approved building envelope. This
application is being referred to the Design Review Board as the number of HVAC units exceeds
the maximum allowed units, as stated in the Tiburon Policy and Procedure for Standards for Air
Conditioning Units and Similar Mechanical Equipment.
TIBURON D.R.B. MINUTES #7
5/7/09
Jason Lehman, owner, stated that the purpose of the HVAC units is to cool the home, which has
a southwest exposure and an extensive glass line and gets warm in direct sunlight. He said that
the units would also incorporate particle filtering to address the owner's allergies. He stated that
they want to zone the air conditioning as effectively as possible so that they do not have to turn
on the entire system to cool certain areas.
Adam Gardner, architect, said that the units are along the back of the house, with three larger
units and one smaller unit to serve the guest suite. He presented a letter from an acoustic
engineer stating that the acoustic output is below the maximum level permitted by the Town's
policy. Mr. Gardner said that the units are downhill and therefore fairly well screened. He
acknowledged the importance of preserving the view from the ridge trail, which is why the house
has a strict height limit and large setbacks. He felt that the size of the I V2 acre lot and its
substantial setbacks would allow the units to comply with the Town policy requirement to avoid
impacts on neighbors and would justify an exception to the policy for the number of units.
Jim Curtis, construction supervisor, said that multiple units are required to cool the building and
achieve the desired particle filtering. He said that this is mainly due to courtyard style of the
home and the high vaulted ceiling which prevents duct work from crossing over. He said that the
smaller units would need to be replaced by multiple, larger commercial units which would be
noisier. He said that the guest suite would be served by a smaller unit that would be tucked
down below the driveway and not visible at all from the street or the ridge trail.
Boardmember Kricensky asked about the original mechanical design for heating and cooling in
the house. Mr. Curtis answered that two heating units and one air conditioning compressor were
proposed to be installed adjacent to master bedroom and for that wing only. He said that they
propose to relocate them all together to mitigate noise issues for neighbors. Boardmember
Kricensky asked if the rest of the house was designed to be cooled, and Mr. Curtis said it was
not.
Boardmember Tollini questioned if these were ductless units. Mr. Curtis responded that the
guest room unit is ductless but the other two serving the main floor are ducted.
Boardmember Kricensky asked for confirmation that there is sufficient room in this location for
the units. Mr. Curtis confirmed that there was room, adding that mockups were installed exactly
as the units would be located. He said that the units would be painted to match the color of the
house.
Chair Doyle asked if any plantings will be used from screening. Mr. Curtis said they are not
allowed to plant anything there because there is an open space and conservation easement above
the house.
There were no public comments.
Boardmember Chong asked about the view of the units and the sound they would generate. He
said that he walked on the trail and the units would be viewable, but the panoramic view of the
bay is what gets attention from the trail. He said that sound is a larger concern and that he was
TIBURON D.R.B. MINUTES #7 4
5/7/09
not as concerned about the neighboring houses, but there will be a lot of sound coming from the
units when hiking on the trail.
Boardmember Wilson asked about the distance between the property line and the trail. Mr.
Gardner answered that it was 47 feet.
Boardmember Tollini said it is hard to determine how loud the sound would be at the trail. He
said that there are other locations that could be explored to further mitigate the noise, such as the
meter area on the side of the garage. He did not think the visual aspect was a problem, but he was
more concerned about noise.
Boardmember Kricensky said that the Town's policy was done for a reason, but he did not
believe it was meant to dictate the design or architecture. He said that one small unit by itself
would be acceptable but he had concerns about the other three units. He noted that this is a
retrofit done for the new owner when the house was not originally designed for air conditioning
over the entire house. He questioned whether the center portion of the house or the master
bedroom need such large units, as his biggest concern is the noise from the trail. He walked on
the trail and looked at the magnificent view, but he felt that this was a logical place for the units.
That being said, he did not want to go against the Town policy.
Boardmember Wilson said the location for the heating system might be a good location for air
conditioning units. He felt that it was important to adhere to policy and the applicant could find
another location for the units.
Chair Doyle said the appearance of the units does not bother him, but he is concerned about the
noise. He did not know what the sound level produced by these units would be when walking on
the trail. He suggested moving the units, adding that placing an air conditioning unit outside an
open window is not an issue because the windows would be closed when it is on. He questioned
whether they would gain anything by moving one unit to the side.
Boardmember Wilson suggested putting one unit on each end of the house and two along the
trail. Mr. Gardner said the desire is not to have the units on the other side because it would be
close to their living area. He suggested taking one of the two larger units and moving it over.
That way, they would not have two units next to each other and there would be more room so
that they could plant screening.
Boardmember Wilson asked about the possibility for cooling the house with 3 units instead of 4.
Mr. Curtis responded that reducing the number of units would eliminate cooling in one area of
the house.
Boardmember Tollini said he was leaning toward a continuance to try to either separate the large
units or move one to a different wall or where previously approved on southeast corner. He did
not believe they all needed to be on the wall facing the open space.
Boardmember Chong asked for more information about the sound measurements. Mr. Gardner
said an acoustic engineer was used who has done other work in the Town. Mr. Gardner added
TIBURON D.R.B. MINUTES #7
5/7/09
that sound diminishes as you move away from the unit and this is their estimate of the sound at
that location. He noted that there may be issues with PG&E and physical constraints if a unit is
moved.
ACTION: It was M/S (Chong/Wilson) to continue the application to the May 21, 2009 meeting.
Vote: 5-0.
4. 1 HILLCREST ROAD BORDEN, ADDITIONS/VARIANCE
1 HILLCREST ROAD
WILLIAM AND KRISTINA BORDEN
EXISTING
PROPOSED
REQ UIRED
LOT SIZE
17,173 S.F.
NA
NA
FLOOR AREA
1,565
31429
3,717 MAX
LOT COVERAGE
12.4%
18.0%
30.0% MAX
BUILDING HEIGHT
12'
26'
30' MAX
SIDE YARDS
13'& 11'6"
13'& 5'
8'
FRONT YARD
63'
30'
15'
REAR YARD
106'
106'
25'
VARIANCES/EXCEPTION
REDUCED SIDE YARD SETBACK
The applicant is requesting Design Review approval for the construction of additions to an
existing one-story single-family dwelling on property located at 1 Hillcrest Road. The project
would involve the demolition of an existing attached garage and the construction of a new
addition to the house. The lower floor of the addition would include a new kitchen, dining room,
great room, entry foyer and powder room. The upper floor of the addition would include a master
bedroom suite and office. A new two-car garage would be attached to the lower level of the
house. The existing kitchen would be removed from the main portion of the house. A new
chimney would be installed for a fireplace in the great room. The proposed additions would
increase the lot coverage of this property by 958 square feet to a total of 3,086 square feet
(18.0%), which is less than the 30.0% maximum lot coverage permitted in the R-1 zone. The
proposed project would increase the size of the house from 1,565 square feet to a total floor area
of 31429 square feet, which is less than the 3,717 square foot floor area ratio for a lot of this size.
A variance is requested for reduced side yard setback.
Associate Planner Tyler noted a typographical error on page 3 of the staff report and said there is
no floor area exception for this project. She said that there may also be a discrepancy in the
setback figure, and the project architect would clarify this tonight.
Greg Johnson, architect, clarified that the encroachment on the setback would be 5 feet and not 4
feet and would involve the powder room and not the stairway. He said that the reduced setback
was necessary to minimize the effect on homes on the hillside above, to save a Douglas Fir tree
on the corner of home and also due to unstable filled land in the front portion of the property. He
stated that nothing is generous or over-sized in the floor plan. He stated that they want to blend
in with the single-story ranch style character of the house and they are using materials to match.
He noted that other than one letter about parking, all neighbors are in support of the project.
TIBURON D.R.B. MINUTES #7 6
5/7/09
Kristina Borden, owner, stated that the addition would be relatively modest and was designed to
accommodate their growing family. She said that they have received the support of neighbors,
including the neighbor directly behind them. She said that they did not intend to request a
variance, but it was really important to them to save the tree. She said that moving the addition
out of the setback would involve construction on a part of the property that had slid in the past.
There was no public comment.
Boardmember Kricensky believed that the project was a good solution in terms of the
architecture, but his only concern was the encroachment into the setback, which he felt was fairly
modest at 5 feet. He said that he originally was leaning against the project until he drove up to
the property and saw it. He said that the property has a large 25 foot setback from the curb and
that led him to support the request.
Boardmember Wilson said he loved the architecture, but he struggled with the setback issue and
would like to see another solution.
Boardmember Chong said that this was a nice design and that mature trees would hide most of
the structure. He said that the driveway was not a huge concern to him, although there could be
a little work done to remove grass in front and explore additional parking area. He stated that the
setback was the only issue that would give him difficulty.
Boardmember Tollini said the applicant had done a great job placing the mass of the second
story from the street. As far as the variance, he felt that this was actually a giant setback from
the roadway and there is a lot of screening. He recognized that there needs to be a hardship
determination, but felt that if there ever was a time when a setback could be granted with a
minimal hardship, this was it. He noted that the building pad for this property is not very big and
a big portion of it that is unbuildable. He felt that if the addition was moved forward it would
start impinging on neighbors' views, and this itself presents a hardship.
Chair Doyle noted that other houses in the vicinity have been granted setback variances. With the
trees and minimal impact on neighbors, he did not think the setback was an issue.
ACTION: It was M/S (Tollini/Kricensky) that the request for 1 Hillcrest Road is exempt from
the California Environmental Quality Act and approved the project subject to the attached
conditions of approval. The findings for the unnecessary hardship for the variance were based
on the fact that relocating portions of the house toward a different part of the property would
result in view-related hardships and loss of a tree, and that this is an extremely difficult site to
build on given the size of building pad. Vote: 4-1 (Wilson opposed).
5. 1887 CENTRO WEST STREET NICOLL, NEW DWELLINGNARIANCE -
CONTINUED TO 6/4/09
E. APPROVAL OF MINUTES #6 OF THE 2/5/09 DESIGN REVIEW BOARD
MEETING
TIBURON D.R.B. MINUTES #7 7
5/7/09
ACTION: It was M/S (Chong/Wilson) to approve Minutes #6 of the April 16, 2009 meeting as
written. Vote: 5-0.
F. ADJOURNMENT
The meeting was adjourned at 8:15 p.m.
TIBURON D.R.B. MINUTES #7
5/7/09
•
PLANNING COMMISSION 0
MINUTES NO. 980
May 13, 2009 %S 4t#
Regular Meeting
Town of Tiburon Council Chambers
1505 Tiburon Boulevard, Tiburon, California
CALL TO ORDER AND ROLL CALL:
Chair O'Donnell called the meeting to order at 7:30 p.m.
Present: Chair O'Donnell, Commissioners Corcoran, Fraser, Frymier, and Kunzweiler
Absent: None
Staff Present: Director of Community Development Anderson, Planning Manager Watrous,
Environmental Consultant Hardt-Holoch and Minutes Clerk Levison
ORAL COMMUNICATIONS: None
COMMISSION AND STAFF BRIEFING:
Planning Manager Watrous provided the following preview of upcoming agenda items:
• Paradise Drive Pre-zoning and General Plan Amendments - May 27, 2009
• Zoning Ordinance Update - June 10, 2009
• Parente Vista Precise Development Plan - June 10, 2009
• Tiburon Peninsula Club Annual CUP Review - June 10, 2009
Chair O'Donnell noted that the Town Council/Planning Commission Workshop is scheduled for
May 26, 2009 at 6:30 p.m.
SCOPING SESSION:
1. 1501 and 1505 TIBURON BOULEVARD: SCOPING SESSION FOR AN
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT REPORT (EIR) TO BE PREPARED FOR THE
BELVEDERE-TIBURON PUBLIC LIBRARY EXPANSION PROJECT; FILES #
GPA 2008-02, MCA 2008-14, 30804 and 40801; Belvedere-Tiburon Library Agency
and Town of Tiburon, Owner and Applicant; Assessor Parcel Numbers 058-171-62,
75, 92, 93 and 94
Community Development Director Anderson provided the staff report. The Town of Tiburon is
processing applications for a general plan amendment, rezoning, master plan amendment and
precise plan amendment for an approximately 18,000 square foot addition to the Belvedere-
Tiburon Public Library. The Town has determined that an Environmental Impact Report (EIR)
TIBURON PLANNING COMMISSION MINUTES - MAY 13.2009 MINUTES NO. 980 PAGE 1
must be prepared for this project and has retained the consulting firm of Christopher A. Joseph &
Associates.
Mr. Anderson explained that the scoping session is a part of the EIR process and helps to identify
the reasonable range of actions, project alternatives, mitigation measures, and potentially
significant effects to be analyzed in depth by the EIR. While all topical areas of potential impact
must be addressed in the EIR, Town Staff anticipates that the most in-depth analysis in the EIR
will be related to aesthetics, air quality, biology, hydrology, land use and planning, noise,
transportation and traffic, and cumulative impacts.
Mr. Anderson provided an overview of the proposed project, stating that it calls for expansion of
the existing library building with an 18,000 square foot, two-story addition. As currently
presented, the expansion would be constructed in the parking area adjacent to the current library.
All existing on-site parking, including parking located behind Tiburon Town Hall, would be
eliminated and replaced by additional street parking with access from Mar West Street.
Vice-Chair Kunzweiler recused himself on advice from the Town Attorney but remained in the
room to observe the hearing.
Chair O'Donnell stated that there had been considerable discussion on three possible designs for
the expansion and asked for the current positions of staff, the Town Council, and the Library
Board with respect to the proposed location. Community Development Director Anderson
declined to speak for others but explained that the Town Council was presented with two
conceptual design options some time ago and a majority appeared to prefer the current proposal,
known as the "civic connection" scheme, in concept.
Commissioner Frymier asked what projects were considered in the discussions of cumulative
impacts of this project. Mr. Anderson explained that there are no other projects planned in the
immediate vicinity but, in accordance with CEQA requirements, the potential impacts of other
projects on the peninsula are evaluated for the cumulative impacts on traffic or other
environmental indicators.
There was no public comment.
Commissioner Corcoran said that his only question was whether the EIR would include analysis
of project alternatives and this was answered by Mr. Anderson. He said the staff report was
thorough and adequately recommends areas to be addressed in the EIR.
Commissioner Fraser said that the objective of expanding the library makes excellent sense for
the community, but there is a need to be cognizant of possible traffic impacts. He cited current
traffic safety concerns at the intersection of Tiburon Boulevard and Mar West Street and the
need to analyze both traffic impacts from both construction and the expanded use. He asked that
the EIR carefully consider alternatives that have not yet brought to the table, including the use of
currently existing and underutilized adjacent space in town Hall and the business park across the
street on Mar West Street. He said that there is a need to understand the potential encroachment
TIBURON PLANNING COMMISSION MINUTES - MAY 13, 2009 MINUTES NO. 980 PAGE 2
into the marsh and suggested that story poles for the project would help. He suggested that the
EIR measure the carbon footprint of the existing library against that of the proposed project.
Commissioner Frymier echoed Commissioner Fraser's statements and stated that her primary
concern lies with the land use and planning of the project. She was concerned that the required
General Plan and zoning amendments could create an uncomfortable precedent for the use of
open space. She also shared concerns over the impacts of the parking area and asked that the EIR
consider alternatives in terms of the possible parking surfaces, scale of the parking lot and
possible parking across the street at the business park.
Chair O'Donnell stated his support for the project but added that he has concerns with the "civic
connection" option because of its divergence from the General Plan goals to preserve parks, open
space and views. He suggested that the current project alternative be redesigned to allow for
greater visibility of Zelinsky Park from Tiburon Boulevard and the EIR should look at more
design options. He described his concerns about the traffic impacts at the intersection of Tiburon
Boulevard and Mar West Street, particularly how the new parking access only from Mar West
Street would create confusion at this intersection. He said that there is a need to protect views of
open space and noted that the previous project design would leave other design options open. He
echoed Commissioner Frymier's concerns over the impact of the appearance of the parking lot
and its possible encroachment on the marsh. He asked that the EIR consider the possibility of
undergrounding at least a portion of the new parking, possibly to serve Town Hall and Library
staff.
Commissioner Frymier asked how the number of required parking spaces was calculated.
Community Development Director Anderson clarified that for unusual uses such as a town hall
or a public library, an appropriate parking standard is typically determined through the EIR
processor by special studies specific to the use and location.
PUBLIC HEARING:
2. 145 ROCK HILL ROAD: AMENDMENT TO A CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT
TO EXPAND THE MAXIMUM ENROLLMENT AND OPERATING HOURS AT
A NURSERY SCHOOL; FILE #10811; Community Congregational Church,
Owner; Hawthorne Nursery School, Applicant; Assessor Parcel No. 039-111-21
Vice-Chair Kunzweiler returned to the meeting. Commissioner Frymier stated that she is a
voting member of the Belvedere-Hawthorne Nursery School Board and recused herself from this
hearing.
Planning Manager Watrous provided the staff report, stating that Community Congregational
Church (CCC) currently occupies the property located at 145 Rock Hill Drive. A tenant nursery
school (Hawthorne Nursery School, applicant) currently operates a preschool serving 3 8 children
on this property, operating from 9:00 a.m. to 12:30 p.m. on Mondays, Wednesdays, and Fridays
and from 9:00 to 3:00 p.m. on Tuesdays and Thursdays. The conditional use permit for the pre-
school, dating from 1968, authorizes a maximum of twenty (20) children. The application for
that use permit describes the hours for the pre-school as 9:00 a.m. to 12:00 noon, Monday
TIBURON PLANNING COMMISSION MINUTES - MAY 13, 2009 MINUTES NO. 980 PAGE 3
through Friday. The applicant wishes to amend the existing conditional use permit for the
nursery school to reflect the current and longstanding enrollment and operating hours of the
school. The nursery school does not propose any expansion of its existing operations at this time.
Mr. Watrous described the permit history for the church and nursery school. He said that for the
last 25 years, the school has had an enrollment of approximately 3 8 children. The school has now
submitted an application to amend the use permit to reflect its long-standing enrollment and
operating hours. He noted that the Town has received periodic complaints over the years
regarding other events and activities on the CCC site, but these complaints have centered on
parking and noise impacts from church-related events and not the nursery school.
Chair O'Donnell asked and confirmed that the matter being voted on is the CUP for Hawthorne
Nursery School, and not CCC.
Commissioner Corcoran noted that the mail received from Pilgrim Heights HOA cites traffic
concerns resulting from the activities of both the church and the school and asked if the concerns
could be separated. Planning Manager Watrous shared several conversations he had with Mr.
Pearson of the HOA on the matter. He stated that parking concerns associated with the school do
not result in substantial safety issues and he reminded the Commission and public to address
issues solely related to the school.
Chair O'Donnell asked if staff has any plans to update the Conditional Use Permit for CCC. Mr.
Watrous said no and explained that historically the Town staff traditionally works informally
with the permit holder to address any issues with neighbors. He acknowledged recent CUP
reviews for St. Hilary's and Kol Shofar and explained that both resulted from major expansions
that would alter the intensity of use.
Chair O'Donnell noted that an entire neighborhood association has formally expressed concerns
with the activities of CCC, said that things have changed since the CUP was issued in 1961. Mr.
Watrous explained that the Zoning Ordinance is fairly restrictive as to when a use permit may be
modified or revoked. Community Development Director Anderson advised the Planning
Commission that the matter is inappropriate for discussion at this hearing and stated that the
Commission may request to place it on a future agenda.
Pamela Bonnie, Belvedere-Hawthorne Nursery School Board President, stated that in July 2008
it came to the school's attention that the 1968 CUP was inconsistent with the school's current
hours of operation and enrollment levels. She explained that for the last 25 years, the school has
enrolled 38 students and maintained operating hours of 9 a.m. to 12:30 p.m. on Monday,
Wednesday, and Fridays and 9 a.m. to 3 p.m. on Tuesdays and Thursdays. They are asking for a
CUP amendment to reflect those conditions. Ms. Bonnie noted that the school is in full
compliance with all State requirements that would allow up to 45 students.
Ms. Bonnie stressed the school's commitment to co-exist peacefully with its neighbors and
explained that representatives met with the Pilgrim Heights HOA to listen to concerns over the
use of space. At that meeting, the School Board agreed to act on several issues including
stepping up efforts to encourage parents to behave courteously and in accordance with current
TIBURON PLANNING COMMISSION MINUTES - MAY 13.2009 MINUTES NO. 980 PAGE4
traffic laws and parking restrictions. She stated that the Board also agreed to enlist volunteers at
the start of each school year to monitor drop-off and pick-up procedures as well as work with
Town staff on traffic solutions. They also agreed to pursue a more appropriate sign for the
parking lot. Ms. Bonnie also noted that HOA representatives were informed of 4 special events
per year at which the school may use more than the 34 spaces currently available.
Commissioner Fraser asked for an estimate of traffic increases during those 4 events. Ms. Bonnie
explained that during those events, families would park and remain at the school for
approximately one hour as opposed to circulating through the lot for drop-off or pick-up.
Donna Loersch, Belvedere-Hawthorne Nursery School Operating Committee, reviewed the
history of the school, its importance in the Tiburon/Belvedere area, and the general need for
preschool opportunities in the whole of Marin. She said that if the school is forced to reduce
enrollment, the Board will have to make the difficult decision to reduce staff and contribute to
the economic downturn.
Amanda Honigman, Secretary of the Belvedere-Hawthorne Nursery School, stressed the school's
value to the community as many families come to Tiburon specifically for its educational
opportunities. She cited the school's contributions to the community and reiterated that the
original use permit granted in 1968 is separate from the Use Permit of CCC. She said the school
fully intends to remain steady and courteous neighbors with the HOA.
Alan Littman spoke on behalf of the nursery school, stated that he has been a member of the
church since it was founded and noted that at that time, there were few homes in the area. He
acknowledged that there can be minor traffic difficulties associated with school commutes but
felt that a minute or two is too much to sacrifice in the name of children's education.
Chair O'Donnell opened the public hearing.
Ian Pearson, Pilgrim Heights HOA representative, expressed support for the school and
assurance that the HOA has no issue with the school's activities. He stated that this hearing is on
a use permit which is held by the church and has been violated for years. He stated that neither
the application or CUP clearly state what is being requested nor has the church submitted a letter
authorizing the permit application. He asked that the new permit include annual review and not
be granted until CCC has submitted the required letter. He stated that the initiatives posed by the
school seem sufficient and are much appreciated.
Vice-Chair Kunzweiler asked if a letter from the church is required for this application. Mr.
Watrous stated that while that is the general requirement, in circumstances where the applicant
has a long-standing operating lease, staff considers a letter from the applicant to be sufficient.
Commissioner Corcoran asked if the applicant would object to Mr. Pearson's request for an
annual review. Ms. Bonnie said that it seems unnecessary and reminded the Commission that the
school has taken substantial initiative on its own to resolve any issues.
Chair O'Donnell closed the public hearing.
TIBURON PLANNING COMMISSION MINUTES - MAY 13, 2009 MINUTES NO. 980 PAGE 5
Vice-Chair Kunzweiler stated that he was very impressed with the presentation and commitment
offered by the school and he applauded their initiative to update the CUP. He felt that the school
should be allowed to continue as they have been operating.
Commissioner Fraser concurred and stated that the community has a clear need for additional
preschool opportunities and, having visited the school, he was wanned by what he saw. He
appreciated the school's attempts to resolve issues with neighbors and stated that he supports the
requested amendment. He asked staff to work with CCC and the homeowners association to
resolve any outstanding issues with the church.
Commissioner Corcoran concurred and seconded the request that staff engage in a dialogue with
the church regarding traffic and parking. He thanked the school for working to update the use
permit to reflect the reality of their operations and for their efforts to be good neighbors.
Chair O'Donnell seconded the comments of the Commissioners as well as his support for the
draft resolution. He noted that all parties share common goals and asked staff to work with CCC
and neighbors to get a handle on church events, especially during evening hours.
ACTION: It was M/S (Kunzweiler/Fraser) to adopt resolution as drafted. Motion carried: 4-0-1
(Frymier recused).
DISCUSSION ITEM:
3. ANNUAL REVIEW OF DRAFT FY 2009-2010 CAPITAL IMPROVEMENT PLAN
BUDGET FOR CONSISTENCY WITH THE TIBURON GENERAL PLAN [SA]
Commissioner Frymier returned to the meeting.
Community Development Director Anderson presented the staff report, stating that the Planning
Commission is required to review the Town's proposed Capital Improvement Program (CIP)
budget for fiscal year 2009-2010 for consistency with the Tiburon General Plan. He reviewed the
proposed projects and noted that the bulk of the expense is for street maintenance and drainage
improvements.
Chair O'Donnell confirmed with staff that the parking improvements at Lyford Drive would
circulate like the lot in front of Frank's Ice Cream. Commissioner Corcoran questioned and
confirmed that Caltrans approval has been a historic issue with this location. Mr. Anderson stated
that the current concept seems to meet with their preliminary approval.
Vice-Chair Kunzweiler asked for an update on the Town's storm drain system and whether it
was true that a substantial amount of deferred maintenance existed in that area. Mr. Anderson
explained that during the preparation of its Drainage Master Plan, the Town assessed all pipes
and drains over the last few years. That draft plan has been received by staff and identifies
significant work that will be required over time. Mr. Anderson said the current lack of funding in
that area is most likely a reflection of tightened economic conditions.
TIBURON PLANNING COMMISSION MINUTES - MAY 13. 2009 MINUTES NO. 980 PAGE 6
Vice-Chair Kunzweiler acknowledged the limited financial resources but noted that it is also a
key element of the General Plan that the Town remain in good repair. He suggested that it may
be necessary to trade off other line items in favor of these improvements.
Commissioner Frymier asked when the completion of the Lyford Drive lot is anticipated. Mr.
Anderson explained that this budget reflects the estimate for completion and that the project
could be conceivably be completed by June 2010, pending Caltrans approval. Commissioner
Corcoran said this has been a long-standing issue for residents and thanked the Town Council for
working on the project.
Chair O'Donnell asked what the impetus was for the Recreation Master Plan. Mr. Anderson
stated that this was spelled out in a General Plan program and that there have long been concerns
about a perceived lack of recreational opportunities in the community and that this plan would
cover a variety of issues including facilities and programs. He stated that the Council
periodically receives funding requests for recreation-related entities and the Plan could create a
framework for how to prioritize and respond to such requests.
MINUTES:
4. PLANNING COMMISSION MINUTES - Regular meeting of April 22, 2009
Commissioners requested the following amendments to the minutes:
• Page 6, 1St full paragraph - "...could allow for repositioning of the site's amenities to so
as not to..."
• Page 6, 2"d full paragraph - "He said that the issues on were..."
• Page 8, 3rd full paragraph - "Vice-Chair Kunzweiler concurred that the scale ands
inventory of improvements is are the principal concern.
ACTION: It was M/S (Kunzweiler/Fraser) to approve he minutes of the April 22, 2009 meeting,
as amended. Motion carried: 5-0.
ADJOURNMENT:
The Planning Commission adjourned the meeting at 9:05 p.m.
TIBURON PLANNING COMMISSION MINUTES - MAY 13, ?009 MINUTES NO. 980 PAGE 7
6.
ACTION MINUTES #8
TIBURON DESIGN REVIEW BOARD
THURSDAY, MAY 219 2009
1505 TIBURON BOULEVARD
A. ROLL CALL: Present: Boardmembers Chong, Kricensky, Tollini and Wilson
Absent: Chair Doyle
Ex-Officio: Planning Manager Watrous, Assistant Planner Phillips, Minutes
Clerk Rusting
B. PUBLIC COMMENTS (FOR ITEMS NOT ON THE AGENDA)
C. STAFF BRIEFING
D. OLD BUSINESS BEFORE THE BOARD
1. 200 Gilmartin Drive Lehman HVAC Units APPROVED
E. NEW BUSINESS BEFORE THE BOARD
2.
181 Stewart Drive
Doyle
Additions/Variance APPROVED
3.
4 Apollo Road
McElreath
Additions/Variances APPROVED
4.
604 Ridge Road
Cohan
Garage/Variance/Floor Area Exception
CONTINUED TO 6/4/09
5.
526 Comstock Drive
Singh
New Dwelling/Variances CONTINUED TO 6/18/09
6.
Courtesy Review of Updated Zoning Ordinance CONTINUED TO 6/4/09
F. MINUTES #7 OF THE 5/7/09 DESIGN REVIEW BOARD MEETING - APPROVED
G. ADJOURNMENT - 9:00 PM
10
TOWN OF TIBURON Regular Meeting
Tiburon Town Hall Tiburon Planning Commission
1505 Tiburon Boulevard May 27, 2009 - 7:30 PM
Tiburon, CA 94920
4C
AGENDA
TIBURON PLANNING COMMISSION
CALL TO ORDER AND ROLL CALL
Chairman O'Donnell, Vice Chairman Kunzweiler, Commissioner Corcoran, Commissioner
Fraser, Commissioner Frymier
ORAL COMMUNICATIONS
Persons wishing to address the Planning Commission on any subject not on the agenda may do
so under this portion of the agenda. Please note that the Planning Commission is not able to
undertake extended discussion, or take action on, items that do not appear on this agenda.
Matters requiring action will be referred to Town Staff for consideration and/or placed on a
future Planning Commission agenda. Please limit your comments to no more than three (3)
minutes. Testimony regarding matters not on the agenda will not be considered part of the
administrative record.
COMMISSION AND STAFF BRIEFING
Commission and Committee Reports
Director's Report
PUBLIC HEARING
1. PARADISE DRIVE PREZONING AND GENERAL PLAN AMENDMENT
PROJECT: CONSIDER MAKING RECOMMENDATIONS TO TOWN COUNCIL
REGARDING THE PREZONING OF APPROXIMATELY 85 ASSESSOR
PARCELS TOTALING APPROXIMATELY 230 ACRES OF LAND LOCATED
AT THE SOUTHEASTERN END OF THE TIBURON PENINSULA &
AMENDMENTS TO THE TIBURON GENERAL PLAN LAND USE MAP
AFFECTING 22 OF THOSE ASSESSOR PARCELS AND MAKING MINOR
CORRECTIONS TO GENERAL PLAN TEXT AND MAPS; Town of Tiburon-
initiated; Files R2008-01 and GPA2008-01 [SA]
Tiburon Planning Commission Agenda May 27, 2009 Page 1
MINUTES
2. PLANNING COMMISSION MINUTES - Regular Meeting of May 13, 2009
ADJOURNMENT
Future Agenda Items a052709
Zoning Ordinance Update (June 10)
Parente Vista PDP (June 10)
TPC Conditional Use Permit Annual Review (June 10)
Congregation Kol Shofar Conditional Use Permit Amendment (June 24)
Tiburon Planning Commission Agenda May 27, 2009 Page 2
19
TOWN OF TIBURON Regular Meeting
Tiburon Town Hall Tiburon Parks, Open Space and Trails Commission
1505 Tiburon Boulevard May 28, 2009 - 6:00 PM
Conference Room
Tiburon, CA 94920
AGENDA O/GFSp
TOWN OF TIBURON
PARKS, OPEN SPACE AND TRAILS COMMISSION
CALL TO ORDER AND ROLL CALL
Chair Winkler, Vice-Chair Sperber, Commissioners Feldman, Leighton and McMullen
ORAL COMMUNICATIONS
Persons wishing to address the Parks, Open Space & Trails Commission on any subject not on
the agenda may do so under this portion of the agenda. Please note that the Parks, Open Space &
Trails Commission is not able to undertake extended discussion, or take action on, items that do
not 4ppear on this agenda. Matters requiring action or follow-up may be referred to Town Staff
or placed on a future Parks, Open Space & Trails Commission agenda. Please limit your
comments to no more than three (3) minutes. Testimony regarding matters not on the agenda
will not be considered part of the administrative record.
COMMISSION AND STAFF BRIEFING
• Staff Information Items
Cypress Hollow Park Improvement Proposal
Open Space Management Plan Development
Multi-Use Path Striping
SUBCOMMITTEE REPORTS
• There Are None
MINUTES
• Approval of Minutes - Regular Meeting of January 20, 2009
ADJOURNMENT
Tiburon Parks, Open Space & Trails Commission May 28, 2009 Page 1
Agenda
MARIN COUNTY
MAY 2 0 2009
COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT AGENCY
BRIAN C. CRAWFORD. DIRECTOR
NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING
SWAHN APPEAL OF THE ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW FOR THE SWAHN DESIGN REVIEW (DR
08-17) AND SECOND UNIT PERMIT (SU 08-14)
NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the Marin County Planning Commission will hold a public hearing to consider
the Swahn appeal of the findings of the Initial Study prepared to evaluate the environmental effects of the
Swahn Design Review and Second Unit Permit application. The owner proposes to construct a 15,482 square
foot, two-story main residence with an attached garage; a 2,250 square foot, two-story guest house, and; a 737
square foot single-story second unit on a vacant, 14.73 acre property in Tiburon. The owner also proposes to
construct a driveway, septic system, and various utilities and appurtenant structures to improve the property.
The approximate area of site disturbance is estimated as 1.51 acres for the entire project. The structures,
particularly the main residence, would be constructed with fire resistant materials and sprinkler systems to
meet the heightened fire safety requirements of the Tiburon Fire Protection District. The Initial Study identifies
several significant environmental impacts and mitigation measures intended to mitigate those impacts to levels
of insignificance. The property is identified as Assessor's Parcel 059-231-02, and is located on Paradise Drive
in Tiburon.
Said public hearing will be held at the regular meeting of the Marin County Planning Commission on Monday,
June 8, 2009, in the Planning Commission Chambers (Room #328 - Administration Building), Civic Center,
San Rafael, California, at which time any and all persons interested in this matter may appear and be heard.
Please call the Community Development Agency - Planning Division at (415) 499-6269 on or after Monday,
June 1, 2009, in order to be informed of the place on the agenda and the approximate time of the hearing or to
obtain a copy of the staff report, or visit our website at
http://www.co.marin.ca.us/depts/bs/members/mcbds/Brdpage cfm?BrdlD=62. Written material should not be
mailed or delivered directly to Commissioners because it will not be accepted or considered as part of the
administrative record for the project. Written material for the Planning Commission should be submitted to the
Community Development Agency at least 10 days prior to the meeting date so that it can be distributed and
considered by the Planning Commission with the staff report. Any written material submitted after this date will
be distributed to the Planning Commission prior to or at the meeting.
If you challenge the decision of this project in court you may be limited to raising only those issues you or
someone else raised at the public hearing described in this notice, or in written correspondence delivered to
the Community Development Agency - Planning Division at, or prior to the public hearing. (Government Code
Section 65009(b)(2).)
If you have any questions or concerns regarding the proposed project, or want to be notified of the decision,
please contact me at (415) 499-3798. 1
BRIAN C. CRAWFORD Jeremy Tejirian, AICP
Agency Director Principal Planner
3501 Civic Center Drive, Room 308 - son Ro f oel, CA 94903-4157 - 415-499-6269 - Pox 415-499-7880
kttp://www.c'o.mci,rin.cci.us/Jepts/CD/moin/InJex.cfm
THE CITY COUNCIL AND STAFF ko
OF THE CITY OF NOVATO
INVITE YOU. TO A WELCOME RECEPTION FOR
MICHAEL FRANK, CITY MANAGER
TUESDAY, JUNE 2, 2009
44-00 - 64-00 PM
AT THE NOVATO TEEN CENTER
950 SEVENTH STREET
LIGHT REFRESHMENTS WILL BE SERVED
PLEASE RSVP BY MAY 27 TO
899-8920 OR CITY@CI.NOVATO.CA.LIS
Congregation Kol Shofar DIGEST C.
(Exodus 25:8) And let them make Me
a sanctuary that I may dwell among them
Please Join Us to Celebrate the Official
Groundbreaking for our New Buildin
g
Sunday7) May 12009
31st7
9
11:00 am -12:00 noon
215 Blackfield Drive, Tiburon
Festivities include Songs, Blessings, Champagne, Snacks and Shovels
Wear comfortable shoes appropriate for construction site
Please RSVP by May 27 to Hagar Ben-Eliezer: 415-388-1818 ext. 10 Ill
Email: hben-eliezer0kolshofar.org
MARIN COUNTY HAZARDOUS & SOLID WASTE
JOINT POWERS AUTHORITY
Board of Directors Meeting
Thursday, May 28, 2009 s
Marin Municipal Water District
220 Nellen Avenue, Corte Madera
9:00 =9:30 AM
AGENDA _
Call to Order.
1) Approval of JPA Board Meeting Minutes from October 30, 2008. (Action)
2) CIWMB Grant Resolution. (Action)
3) Approve JPA FY 09-10 Budget, Contract and. Tipping Fee Resolution. (Action)
4) 2008 Financial Statements and Auditors Report. (Action)
5) Zero Waste Feasibility Study Presentation. (Information)
6) Executive Committee Report. (Information)
a) Executive Committee Meeting Minutes from January 21, 2009.
b) Executive Committee Meeting Minutes from April 15, 2009.
7) Local Task Force Report. (Information)
a) Local Task Force Meeting Minutes from November 5, 2008.
b) Local Task Force Meeting Minutes from December 3, 2008.
c) Local Task Force Meeting Minutes from February 4, 2009.
d) Local Task Force Meeting Minutes from March 4, 2009.
e) Local Task Force Meeting Minutes from April 1, 2009.
f) Local Task Force Meeting Minutes from May 6, 2009.
8) 2007 Annual Report submittal. (Information)
9) Set Date for November 2009 JPA Board. Meeting. (Action/Information)
• Next Executive Board Meeting to be held on Wednesday, July 15, 2009, 2:00 - 3:00PM,
65 Mitchell Boulevard, San Rafael.
10) Open Time.
11)Adjourn.
The full agenda including staff reports can be viewed at
www.marinrecycles.org/mins_agendas.cfm
F: \W a ste\J PA\AG E N D A\09-05-28. doc
I
i
'
NNNE
All public meetings and events sponsored or conducted by the County of Marin are held in accessible sites.
Requests for accommodations may be made by calling (415) 473-4381 (voice/TTY) or 711 for the California Relay
Service or e-mailing disabilityaccess(a.co.marin.ca.us at least four work days in advance of the event. Copies of
documents are available in alternative formats, upon written request.
Contact the County's Waste Management Division, *at 499-6647 for more information. 1