Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutTC Res 2010-09-01iu u niu Timm c010-e044707 Recorded I REC FEE Official Records I RECORDING REQUESTED County Of I ! R1 =TURN TO: Morin JOAN C.THAYER A I ssessor_Recorder I TOWN CLERK I TOWN OF TIBURON 07:O2Aq 14-Sep-010 ! Page i of 19 1505 TIBURON BOULEVARD TIBURON, CA 94920 RESOLUTION NO. 47-2010 A RESOLUTION OF THE TOWN COUNCIL OF THE TOWN OF TIBURON AMPLIFYING AND SUPPLEMENTING PROVISIONS OF TITLE IV, CHAPTER 16 SECTION 16-21.020 (F) OF THE TIBURON MUNICIPAL CODE (ZONING) WITH RESPECT TO PLANNED DEVELOPMEN T #4 BY APPROVING A PRECISE DEVELOPMENT PLAN (PARENTE VISTA PDP) AND ADOPTING A MITIGATION MONITORING PROGRAM ASSESSOR PARCEL NO. 038-111-16 WHEREAS, the Town Council of the Town of Tiburon does resolve as follows: Section 1. Findin-gs. A. The Town of Tiburon has designated a 10.2-acre property located at the end of Antonette Drive and Parente Road as Residential Planned Development (RPD) on the Zoning Map and in the zoning regulations of the Tiburon Municipal Code, Title IV, Chapter 16, at Section 16-14.020 (B), with a further zoning designation of Planned Development #4 on the Planned Development Map in the aforesaid Section. All future Tiburon Municipal Code Section references in this resolution and its attachments shall be to Title IV, Chapter 16 (Zoning) unless otherwise specified. B. Tiburon Municipal Code Section 16-21.030 (D[3]) provides zone regulations for the RPD zone, specifying the approval of a Precise Development Plan prior to subdivision, grading, or the making of improvements on property so designated. Basic zoning parameters such as density of development, floor area limits, height limits, and setbacks are to be specified in an approved Precise Development Plan for the property, based on site-specific characteristics to which an appropriate amount and layout of development may be tailored. The purpose of the RPD zone is set forth as follows: The Residential Planned Development (RPD) Zone is intended to protect and preserve open space land as a limited and valuable resource without depriving owners of a reasonable use of their property for residential purposes. The regulations of the zone are designed to insure, to the extent feasible, the conservation of natural resources and the retention of land in its natural or near 0.00 TIBURON TOWN COUNCIL RESOLUTION NO. 47-2010 9/1'2010 natural state in order to, among other things, assist in the containment of urban sprawl and protect the community from the hazards of fire, flood, seismic and other catastrophic activity, and to otherwise implement the goals and policies of the General Plan. C. Tiburon Municipal Code Section 16-52.060 (B) establishes the Precise Development Plan purposes as follows: 1. To provide for review by the Town a detailed development proposal for a designated area with unique site characteristics or environmental conditions, in both written and graphic form, to ensure that new development in such areas is compatible with the existing land uses, development standards (including but not limited to, setbacks or building envelopes, coverage limits, and height limits) and identified constraints; 2. To demonstrate consistency of a development proposal with the goals and policies of the General Plan; 3. To preserve and conserve critically limited open space for the protection of the ecology and the environment, and to safeguard against the adverse impacts of fire, noise, water pollution, the destruction of scenic beauty and hazards related to geology, fire and flood, while at the same time providing a reasonable use of the land. Section 16-52.060 (E) sets forth principles to be applied in the review of Precise Development Plan applications. Section 16-52.060 (D) declares approval of a Precise Development Plan by the Town Council to be a legislative act. E. The Town of Tiburon has received and considered an application filed by Lionel Achuck for a Precise Development Plan (the Parente Vista Precise Development Plan) to augment and supplement provisions of Section 16-21.030 (D[3]) of the Tiburon Municipal Code specific to Planned Development #4 by proposing the development of two (2) single- family dwellings and appurtenant improvements on an approximately 10.2-acre property. Approximate lot acreages would be 2.1 acres for Lot 1 and 8.1 acres for Lot 2. The proposed Parente Vista Precise Development Plan would establish a maximum density of 0.20 dwelling units per acre (exclusive of any secondary dwelling units), and provide a basic layout and RPD zoning district parameters for the property, including but not limited to, permanent open spaces, building envelopes, residential use areas, height limits, and floor area limits. F. The Parente Vista Precise Development Plan application consists of File #30703, on file with the Town of Tiburon Community Development Department. Materials from that application include but are not limited to the following: TIBURON TOWN COUNCIL RESOLUTION NO. 47-2010 9!1;2010 2 I . Project description, dated October 9, 2009; 2. Project plans (7 sheets) prepared by Thayer Architecture, Inc., dated October 9, 2009; 3. Project plans (11 sheets) prepared by ILS Associates, Inc., dated September 9, 2009 4. Project plans (2 sheets) prepared by Herzog Geotechnical Consulting Engineers, dated September 9, 2009 5. Project plans (3 sheets) prepared by Pedersen Associates Landscape Architects, dated February 18, 2010 6. Drainage analysis prepared by ILS Associates, Inc., dated June 15, 2007 7. Geotechnical Hazards Evaluation and Geotechnical Investigation letters prepared by Herzog Geotechnical Consulting Engineers, dated January 26, 2007 and April 20, 2007; 8. Supplemental Noise Impact Study prepared by Rosen, Goldberg, Der & Lewitz, Inc., dated April 27, 2007. The official record for this project is hereby incorporated and made part of this resolution. The record includes the Staff Reports, minutes, application materials, and all comments and materials received at the public hearing. G. An Environmental Impact Report (EIR) analyzing a five-lot project on this site was certified by the Tiburon Town Council on October 6, 2004. An Addendum to the EIR, dated March 2010, was prepared to evaluate the current two-lot project design. The Planning Commission considered the certified EIR and the EIR Addendum in making its recommendation to the Town Council on the merits of the project. H. The Planning Commission held a duly noticed public hearing on the application on June 23, 2010. Following the public hearing the Planning Commission adopted Resolution No. 2010-(Draft) recommending to the Town Council conditional approval of the project as evaluated in the EIR Addendum No. 2 for the project, and adoption of a Mitigation Monitoring Program for the project. 1. The Town Council held a duly noticed public hearing on the application on July 21, 2010, at which it heard and considered testimony from interested persons. The Town Council found, based upon application materials and analysis presented in the staff report, the certified Final EIR and the March 2010 Addendum No. 2 thereto, that the proposed project is, on balance, consistent with the goals and policies of the Tiburon General Plan and in conformance with provisions of the Tiburon Zoning Ordinance. The facts in support of this finding are set forth in the official record for this project. TIBURON TOWN COUNCIL RESOLUTION NO. 47-2010 9/1/2010 3 Section 2. Acceptance of Addendum to the EIR NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the Town Council hereby accepts the Addendum No. 2 to the Final Environmental Impact Report ["Addendum"] dated March 2010. CEQA guidelines sections 15164 (a) and (b) state that an addendum should be prepared when none of the conditions triggering a subsequent EIR or supplemental EIR have occurred. _ Section 15162 of the CEQA Guidelines advises the-preparation of a subsequent or supplemental EIR when substantial changes to the project require major revisions to the EIR because of new significant environmental effects or a substantial increase in the severity of previously identified effects. The two-lot Parente Vista project that is currently proposed is within the range of alternatives and impacts discussed in the certified EIR. The Addendum concludes that this project design would not result in new significant environmental effects or a substantial increase in the severity of previously identified effects. The Final Environmental Impact Report and Addendum were prepared under contract to the Town of Tiburon by the consulting firm of Leonard Charles & Associates. Detailed CEQA findings have been adopted by separate resolution. The Addendum further concludes that with the implementation of Mitigation Measures contained therein, all environmental impacts associated with the two-lot project design have been or would be mitigated to a less-than-significant (LTS) level. Section 3. Conditional Project Approval and Adoption of Mitigation Monitoring Program. BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the Town Council hereby approves the Parente Vista Precise Development Plan (PD #4) subject to the following conditions and adopts a mitigation monitoring program for the project: 1. The approved Parente Vista Precise Development Plan shall consist of the following: a. The Project description, dated October 9, 2009, as may be modified herein; b. The project plans (7 sheets) prepared by Thayer Architecture, Inc., dated October 9, 2009, as may be modified herein; C. The project plans (11 sheets) prepared by ILS Associates, Inc., dated September 9, 2009, as may be modified herein; d. The project plans (2 sheets) prepared by Herzog Geotechnical Consulting Engineers, dated September 9, 2009, as may be modified herein; e. The project plans (3 sheets) prepared by Pedersen Associates Landscape Architects, dated February 18, 2010, as may be modified herein. TIBURON TOWN COUNCIL RESOLUTION NO. 47-2010 9/1!2010 4 2. This Precise Development Plan approval incorporates all mitigation measures as shown in the Parente Vista Mitigation Monitoring Program, attached hereto as Exhibit A and incorporated herein. Applicant shall bear all costs for implementation and monitoring of said Mitigation Monitoring Program. 3. Prior to the issuance of grading or building permits for project construction, the project sponsor shall submif a Design Review application to the Town of Tiburon Planning Division and receive written approval from the Design Review Board. 4. In furtherance of Section 16-21.040 (C[2]) of the Municipal Code, this Precise Development Plan approval establishes a maximum density of 0.20 dwelling units per acre on the property (not including any Town-approved secondary dwelling units) and is intended to reflect ultimate development of the property. No additional subdivision for the purpose of creating additional building sites is permitted, and a note to that effect shall be placed on the parcel map. 5. In furtherance of Section 16-52.020 (I[3]) of the Municipal Code, this Precise Development Plan approval establishes the limit of "'floor area, gross", as defined in Section 16-100.020 (F) therein, that may be constructed on each lot as follows: Lot 1: 6,000 square feet, with additional garage/carport area of up to 750 square feet. Lot 2: 9,000 square feet for a single-family dwelling, with additional garage/carport area of up to 1,000 square feet, additional area for a secondary dwelling unit of up to 1,000 square feet, and additional garage/carport area for the secondary dwelling unit of up to 500 square feet. The Design Review Board is directed to ensure that the final house design minimizes visual mass and bulk and fits with the current contours and topography of the site. Any garage/carport floor area in excess of the amount specified above shall be counted as additional gross floor area on the lot. The floor area of all accessory buildings, including any secondary dwelling unit, pool houses or cabana, shall be included in the total allowable floor area for each lot. Floor areas meeting the definition of "basement" in the Municipal Code shall not be included in the calculation of gross floor area. It is understood that the floor area for each lot as specified above is a maximum allowable square footage, and the Design Review Board may, in its reasonable discretion in reviewing Site Plan and Architectural Review applications for each lot, approve a lesser amount of square footage in order to ensure that the building sizes are consistent and compatible with surrounding neighborhoods in compliance with, and as set forth in, General Plan Land Use Element Goal LU-I. TIBURON TOWN COUNCIL RESOLUTION NO. 47-2010 9/1/2010 5 6. In furtherance of Section 16-21.040 (A) of the Municipal Code, this Precise Development Plan approval establishes that the dwelling unit (main building on each lot) shall be confined to the approved "building envelope" on each lot. Dwelling units shall not exceed thirty (30) feet in height from grade. It is understood that these height limits represent a maximum height, and the Design Review Board may, in its reasonable discretion in reviewing Site Plan and Architectural Review applications for each house, approve a lesser height for the dwelling units pursuant to guiding principles of site plan and architectural review as set forth in the Municipal Code. 7. In furtherance of Section 16-21.040 (A) of the Municipal Code, this Precise Development Plan approval establishes the following standards for the secondary building envelopes associated with this application: a. Lot 1, Secondary Building Envelope. All elements allowed within these building envelopes are limited to landscape improvements, including swimming pools and spas, terraces, walkways, and retaining walls and fences with a maximum height of six (6) feet. Trellises may have a maximum height of eleven (11) feet, six (6) inches. Plantings are limited to those species with a maximum height at maturity of thirty (30) feet or less. b. Lot 2, Secondary Building Envelope. This envelope may be developed with a single-story (maximum height of 15 feet above grade) secondary dwelling unit, with a maximum floor area of 1,000 square feet, and a garage with a maximum size of 600 square feet. This envelope may also be developed with landscape improvements, including swimming pools and spas, a tennis court and a bocce ball court terraced into the slope, terraces, walkways, and retaining walls and fences with a maximum height of six (6) feet. Trellises may have a maximum height of eleven (11) feet, six (6) inches. Plantings are limited to those species with a maximum height at maturity of thirty (30) feet or less. All elements allowed in the Lot 1 Secondary Building Envelope and the Lot 2 Secondary Building Envelope may also be located in the Primary Building Envelopes for Lots 1 and 2. 8. In furtherance of Section 16-21.040 (A) of the Municipal Code, this Precise Development Plan approval establishes a designation of "private open space" for all areas on Lot 2 outside the primary and secondary building envelopes. The disturbed areas shall be landscaped immediately following the landslide repair work. Additionally, all landslide repair areas shall be hydro-seeded following grading for dust control and soil stability in accordance with geotechnical engineering recommendations. No new landscaping or vegetation shall be planted TIBURON TOWN COUNCIL RESOLUTION NO. 47-2010 9/1 /20 10 6 on any private open space area outside the "building envelopes" for both Lot 1 and Lot 2 other than that approved as part of a detailed landscape plan and palette to be submitted with the tentative subdivision map application and incorporated into the subdivision improvement drawings. 9. In furtherance of Section 16-21.040 (A) of the Municipal Code., no improvements of any type, including fencing, shall be permitted outside the approved primary and secondary building envelopes for each lot. This limitation does not apply to the private roadway leading to Antonette Drive; driveways and retaining walls supporting driveways; utilities; landslide repair devices and revegetation; drainage ditches; or other ancillary improvements necessary for installation of the subdivision improvements as approved in the subdivision improvement drawings. 10. In furtherance of Section 16-21.030 (D[3]) of the Municipal Code, all portions of each lot designated as "private open space" herein shall be contained within and protected by an open space easement or easements to be offered for acceptance to the Town of Tiburon by separate instrument as part of the parcel map application. Said open space easement or easements (if accepted) shall be recorded in conjunction with the recordation of the parcel map. All portions of said open space easement or easements shall acknowledge, if necessary, any existing or required roadway, drainage and/or utility easements and any landscape installation (e.g. entry landscaping, retaining wall screening, and mitigation planting) and maintenance agreements that are required as part of this Precise Development Plan or permits issued in reliance thereon. Open space easement or dedication documents shall be reviewed and approved by the Town Attorney and Director of Community Development prior to acceptance for filing of the parcel map application. 11. Colors and materials of residential improvements shall be low-reflectivity; medium and/or dark hues that minimize contrast with surroundings and reduce visual impacts, as shown on the project plans (7 sheets) prepared by Thayer Architecture, Inc., dated October 9, 2009. 12. Draft CC&R's, deed restrictions, and/or joint maintenance agreements or other similar instruments for the subdivision shall be prepared and submitted for review and approval by the Town Attorney and Director of Community Development as part of the tentative subdivision map application. Said CC&Rs or other instruments acceptable to the Town Attorney shall contain provisions and limitations as set forth in this Precise Development Plan approval and the adopted Mitigation Monitoring Program to the satisfaction of the Town Attorney and Director of Community Development. These instruments shall contain, without limitation, provisions for ongoing maintenance of the private roadway, common areas, ongoing maintenance of drainage structures and facilities, and ongoing removal of invasive plant species (French broom, pampas grass, etc.) from the TIBURON TOWN COUNCIL RESOLUTION NO. 47-2010 9/1/2010 7 property, and shall be recorded in conjunction with the parcel map. 13. As part of the installation of the subdivision improvements, applicant shall remove dilapidated fencing and fence-posts, litter, garbage, and other junk materials from the entire site. 14. If lighting is proposed for the project roadway, lighting details shall be reviewed by Planning Division Staff prior to the approval of subdivision improvement drawings for the project. 15. Appearance and any proposed vegetative screening of project retaining walls shown on the subdivision improvement drawings in excess of forty-two (42) inches in height shall be subject to review and approval by Planning Division Staff prior to approval of said drawings. 16. A detailed landscape plan prepared as part of the subdivision improvement drawing submittal shall be reviewed and approved by Planning Division Staff. This landscape plan shall include removal of any remaining invasive plant species, common area plantings, entry landscaping, retaining wall screening, and any landscaping required in adopted mitigation measures. 17. All grading involving the use of heavy construction. equipment shall be limited to the period between April 15 and October 31. The Building Official may authorize limited extensions of time to this period in his reasonable discretion.. 18. No smoking shall be pennitted on site by any person, contractor or employee during any phase of project construction. A water truck shall be present on the site during vegetation removal. These requirements shall be noted on the subdivision improvement drawings and shall be incorporated into construction documents for the contractor(s) performing the work. 19. This Precise Development Plan approval shall be valid for thirty-six (36) months following its effective date, and shall expire unless a time extension is granted or a tentative subdivision snap has been approved in reliance on this Precise Development Plan, in which instance the Precise Development Plan shall remain valid coterminous with the tentative map approval. Section 4. Effective Date. BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that this Precise Development Plan approval shall become effective thirty (30) days after adoption of this Resolution, pursuant to Section 16-52.060 (D) of the Tiburon Municipal Code. TIBURON TOWN COUNCIL RESOLUTION NO. 47-2010 9/1/2010 PASSED AND ADOPTED at a regular meeting of the Town Council of the Town of Tiburon held on September 1, 2010 by the following vote: AYES: COUNCILMEMBERS: Collins, Fraser, Fredericks, O"Donnell, Slavitz NOES: COUNCILMEMBERS: None ABSENT: COUNCILMEMBERS: None l° i r RICHARD MAYOR Town of Tib brio" n ATTEST: DIANE CRANE IACO , TOWN CLERK Attachment: Exhibit A (Mitigation Monitoring Program) TIBURON TOWN COUNCIL RESOLUTION NO. 47-2010 9.1/2010 9 J H H O ~t* W W W W W W W W W W N IV N ~ :-L LA LA L& pp y n OO D D D D L A W N N N 0) (a CL -j °o N N ~ ~ ~ n a) O O v, 2) CD •a -0 C0 0 0) D__ n Go o ° m 0 a) - ' 0 O CD n (D (D O(D 0 'o =r c n CD 0 (D il O O 'C 0~~'C CD 00 O 0 ~O p10 cr = ~ .z 0(D CL, Q (D cD 0 zmy N ~ rt (000 CD 64 m°0) boy ~rn~D a ~oD ~rn~D a o~~(°n~ `°=1 D) = w X32 o,a`<> > " U) n 0 0- N O O0 3 •o CD c o o . N NO 3 O 0 m e o°•o N 0 0 CL (D (D Cr y r 01 (D j O a> CL A N O _ O. 3 0 3 - 4l 7 0 ° ) p ~ y (D0 C 7 -1 7 - 3 < d ('n 00o_p = 0 g < r=. o O H p O cD p~ V CO (D N it ~ =r y t! p (A - c ~~O o CD • c (D 0(D 3 ms's 0 -2 (D P. 20 ~ 3 rt~N m N0o v, . ► 3 0 o ~ -43 ~ ~ w 5, (D c c ~2 o Q 3 0=c d 0) (D °o o (D C °o --gym 00 = ) ( =r (A-= D = - - =o CL CD = c coon (o o ~ C4 *o 0 - (D 'a D =r = ° =r ~c Co D U =r = ° ~ ~o °.m °n (D CD ~ . 3 ao g o 0 3 ~ N -0 (D = N 3 0 3 M p CO r%) 0.0 O (D w O Q NN n -w o o~ m O, s. O Nw 0 CD n CO a n n O < 0 UO 0 y N.~ 4R Z (3p ° m O ,rt0 Q n - CD 0 CD co 0n Cl) L LA. S S (D 5. n 7C =a " co n m0 coa)°m . « O j co O_ ago (o0°(D Cl) 0 (D 7 0) N0 ~41 n 0 0 ~~lw cD3 ((D j 0) C =r 0 ° ° n n n 0 o go; 3: m~ ~ 0 am 0 5 m cD0 n ~ Cl) 0 ~m 0 (D (D0 n I rn rn oQ., o -a :D 0 m> v,0m N0 (a c o- CD o n 90) (D 0 0 o CD O2 ,te =r0 ~3 0Cr CD f3rt CD -0 3 00 < <'CL=r ° ' o ~0 "0 (D o~0 ~,3 m-0 CL ~ o ~,3 m-0a ~ o CL a) o 0 0~ a0 = ~N n T).oN.a 0 m m . .(O0 =r =4 N . n 0) (D0 CD W - %I w N . 8 n rnCD (D W • % c~vo CD mo. 0, 0.0 o -ft t7 3 = .~~m (D=r N 0 ov2 CL = 0 o-v2 o0=r CD -,ID 0 Er a CD =r m " c =r CD (D CD oua :3 0 0. Co (D a 0 a CO = CD CO n (D 0 (D (D 0 6-0 =r s rn o CD G) m 0 (D Er m CD • -I cD 9 -9 (D CD 'a 0 (D o~ 'o o 0 CL CL W =r CD 72 (D CD - CL CD 0 0 0 v, 3 co 'a -2 ~•S=r nw 0CD w CL ID CD 05.S c cL O 0a G m E; M fl.= m c(DD • (D (~D c f O = O L QD O a ~ D ~C(° ~O c o> > m~ _ m 0~° a m~ 3~W mrn 3~w C 3m 0 0ID(om mm ac°~~ co =r CD = =r CD 8 6 CL 0 CD cL-< 0 m-•,m o~ 0°'.: Q om o°' (0,2 Er 02= n o°-o~ CD o.cfDD ~QQ (o (D (D CL N -7 7 co Er 3 B CO) 3 0 3 to 2.0 0 CO) o 0 N o 0 to O c 0 y -ONO 0 to 0 0 0 ca 0 ~ W3 °a o 3 a 3 . 3 . (D . 3 a. . 3 ca. . .o c m .a e~ = O = a a) O -9 (o o ~ a on O O.mc3D C o o ° ° O 0 ° o ev an 0 „may, 0 o Q ( 0 s o (Q 0 s =r c° = 0 n (Q 0 =r 0 C 4, 0 m c: v, 41 (o (D 0 0 o~ 3 0 Q c 3 o •p O s C (D ° 3 0 3 o (D C 8 ° 7 (D CD ~ U3 O =r D) 0 0) 0 m 0 CD 3 O S co v V1 0 c c 0 0 0 ~ .r .a . O 0 .n. 0 0 (D ~ C 51 ~ n .n. 8 a 01 O 3 > > W j (~D 3 O C m 7 = cil w m 0 w 2 2 °@ s c co 2 2 rn n m o (n > c o > o > m ~ cD _ v m o 9 0 > 0 w > =r 0 cr CL 0) ` ' -h CD N m o CD o c N co 7 Q"F v 'v O v O O (D O CD O CD O CD O CD O m v Cl) o v r, r Cl) (1) -o CD a 0 0 w O 1 (A O 1 (p o ~7 N O 1 N O .7 1 4 o .7 ((A O 1 O O ~G)mmG)-u 0(D 37(D3 --I G)mmG)-0 O(D77(Da 00r- 0M0 -40MM0T Om==mO ~0mM0T om==m8 --1 0 mmOT om==m" > > :e 0 (a 0 > 0 3 7 (~D 20(0(00-. 0 7 3 (CD N O N O * 0 (o (o 0- 5. 1 (D j 0 co (o 0- 0 7 7(D 0 * 0 (0 0 -0. 7 0>> ((D (D M > m > 0 MS. (D (D 0 > m (D (D S MS. (D (D C) 0 4) (D (D C co o~ 5 m co, (D (D 7 H N (D M (O ~ (D 0 o H N M co (D CD 0 O H (D (D S (0 .w 2. 7 (D 0 CD 7 (o (D 0 7 (Q 0 7 co 0 m 7 co o 7 (p na 0 CL 0 m n (D n CD n CD C n 3 O z 3 c m 3 T m 3 m z a O z N m mX rm m m mp ZZ V 0) :jw zm mcn~ CZ~ a v, AW mm O v m z m a O m 1 c (O 0 O 7 O X _0 (o w 3 w w w p0 D C7 N N N A W N OG =N0= O NmO=n~~0p 01 - p 0 fD N C7 M 0 rn CD 0 rtm(D~ : = _ -c (n C C O co ~ H -D pCl) ~ mI=vv(3= D 0;= O ° • o- ~ - Mrn m o (em goo.0~ ° 0 (D ;30Q c O 0) w ~ Ca ~ N a o -+mm 10 ° Q N coo N o ~ m ~m m a n o o ~ mo a(u o m vv a o~ C). M (n m ~i m c° (n :k cr Q m ..3 -,mcn r w 2) (A 0 0 o3mC 0a 0 - ~ 3_ =Mm 3~- CD Rio ~ ~ wcDa ? N~m°a ~~~D a 0) M..cr ' a i 1 3co ID omm a_ ~m..0 m' W - . y0 m(A ~v mU0m0CaCQ O CL CL 0 M co D-an(71-V1 O p 3 co (?.o? -0 w l L. 0 N n-% (A O n m c 3 (=A ~ (N =r M M. .+p> 01 01 O m 3 - m • m o 3 N - to ErCco m.. 7 'CO m ? 0 7C . O ~ 0 d d N m • • p O (R = v O O p (D rt? < m O m O 0 0n 0 c m~ amvc~n~~°~~'~w 0 ;r c ~N Q m n(n3°:u' - o N ~ M ~N~ ."o 0 'a w c ' n(,~m=,,.'mom.. m m ° ' CL ^ N= w .M .o ic 3 o :•('c -o o ~ Q~(A ! CL 3 @ obi 0) S c 3.0 c~aM i, ( - tea; (n m gym O (N~ - X (D C N N N m 7 ¢.a O-9 ~'N Qm c n W S mt~ O? 031 3 Q 00 w O y'p C O a ID M n- n~ -w3 cg v ° ° ° ( - 0 w 5 - =n ° 3 o 3 c 0 c3 - M -..am oc oc ° -anrnm CL <m O0 NQ. m n 03 a) (°A3m~i 0) CL :3 N ~ 3 m CL 0 0 a (n a o m m C O m n3 O (D m M CL M r_ w 7 .0 CL go - 0) m O(o O 3v U' :3. ' Q3 ~`s< N .•m w0~ 3 m° ~3 (u c m =r CL m 5.<0C (D c0 SO100 a O (D yS(DQ- . a a to ' U) wNm O of O c3a`~G o-O A (p (D - (/1 3 o;N art ~(a d ~ OCc 0 7_= 0 O co C < C .►a 7 rtN 1 c c w O ~ _ n o o O C ~'m = w (D 0 .3.0 m 0 CL a a m< n~ N O 7 m O O (A N y aN_ 2 5'(0 m 0 o , 7 M 3 o CD m 5,3 3 CD M'o 5* (a 0 o o 3 cr a 0~ =r ' CD c . ~ ~3 w a CDN~ rn:3 ==M o c Asa@A 0 Er 0) cr =r n N O 3 0D n N O O 3 O co O 5'0 O - 3 ~w V ° < a ;z 75 o v 3 3 G o 0 CD C CD 3 ° ° o 3 o p 1 0 3 ► o 0 1 N m ► 0 ° r (D rt n ° o 5 (D 0 0 m 0 w m m ' O 'O« C N O --h 'C C 01 0 0 A~ O 0 3 CD _ 0 r. = c . ~ c ni o c c a cc 0 = o Q < =r CL Z 0 CD ~ 0 0 0 CD 0 CD a a -a Cl) v 0 > > m ~ 0 O O ' 0 n~ < m m 1 3 a O Z 3 D N c m a M Z I M M O C- 0 m --00 =-1 c; C =i c. a 3 ~ O Z 3 3 O M Z a O O M 2 Z M M x m 0 3 OD MM 34 '0;0 r- MM 3~ M ZZ z " Opm> 3c~ r 0 F. z N m~ M _m 0. ~a co 4 aZ (D c co CA) w CA) CA) w w w 0 n C7 D :-L IV W N 0~ N 7 (D 0, n 'a D ~ ~ U1 A W N - 0 N o~ Q -i - 0.0 C 0700 a C r 3 2 am ° 3 go 0 ° (D c = ° ~0 -0 z-I -a ~ O N D ~ w 5::T, 0) =r0 ; a QN~ ~c =r n O o► N (<Do (D0 (D°(SD 0rtcN N(7 (Dc y0 0m 3 ~ Cy< cD rn CL CL 0 S'0 ~w w~ ~~'rn m~ c'D(<D('D33 ~rn0- COC wa 9U w N 5-., :2 3 ID r , o~~ 50 =r ao Mcr x n o o is S< CL agr, yco 2: c a' eD CID 9 _ a o =r Q O N ? y0 ~ co 'a 7 3 Q3 0 0 7 7 W - 0(C~ SN m a o S I~ N~~' O~ ,yfD N"~~ 0(D 0 O 0 3 (D 0 + O C = " co 0 (D rtS ~N(D r► C y ~ O ~ - p_ n N ~ Z 'D (D (D N S S a S C. • O A m m CD 0 x C ED Q =r D (SD _ O p a' (D _ p (C 5. (CD C > ~ N C 0 S 0i 7 N 0 (D C ~ 0 a 7 C - y,yf° ~ 3 cD < 0 (D (p > ° ' C > S Q ~C C 0 ~ N c of O c•s o ° Aa N (DO C0O N D % ~ 7~ 0 i► (p 0 ( S.w @r. ~ : . ~ (D 7 CL ~ ( a• CDD ~t o = (D m (A CL CD m °fl C. '7 O " N 0 N ~o (D ~w (p 3 (D (D d a) . o (D rt Co ° 3 O . - = 1 N 3 a C.~ ° °3 cDm 0 a, o 0 3 m~ o ?a ° C roc C0w -0- c~ m ° rt~ - cr rm~ CL co 0 N r Ord O (D CD =r w CD U) -1 ° ..C (p O N C ~ =i0 ' N S CL CD cr CD 'o 0 C. O N M CL :3 (A (5* 0 CL CD 'o CD ~(C = , ► CD < 0 D m CD 'a x 8 SD a) 0- OBO 0) CL < =r :3 0 0 0 (D O a n - ' D OoI Q Q C (D C 0 N ? • 0) Q ) C. 7 ( ;w C co (D O 0) 0Sp CD C 0 • 0 S o coQ CD O 0 N nC oho vc- ~a y oCD cc <S M m cD x m C 'c° 3 N v 3 N ° R ~ (a -a m . . o a , 3 Q @ c. o CD 0 N m a =r m co o 3x 0 =r cr Cl)- m c c 3•a CL (D ~ C ° C W m • m (D r. Q C. ~ C• N O = s O ~ S N v C m~ N 0 m m o ° 3 (D S o (D ~ ~ ~ a _ 0 (c S O I@ CW c N c -0 (D BCD (D • ° N o at k c~ x 3 CD 0 =r (D - a O in 0 _ - _ =r 0 =r M 0 N _ c r (D a D C = . ► N 0 (D S m . S •a o o S = (D 0) 7 SS - 0 (D N . a (D (D 7 (D N m * N` n CO) n W n ~ w C CO) o CO) 3 3 0- 3 0 V m cn V - m y 0 rn v T CD 0 3° (D 3. CD o 0 0 co p . ► (C C7 pa . ► 0 o _ 0 o rn y 3 - a w fl: rn 3 m N a m ° a n~ m a (D a > 'o cu - m cp n , r. S o D m' cc o co fl; c CD m < 3 n y 0 O N O O 0 (D O O S 0 CD O 7 o, 0 7 0 3, 0 o a ° O 'a 3 2 cn a to o m 01 C C a (D rt - ;a 00 c < < C . CD - > > CD (<D 0 v o c -0 . a s CD m 3 ( D Cl) m -a co v v o C (CD N N O O O -9 O (D N n S O 3 CD 0ca0 -o < • a o 0a) E. O'v v ° Q~ LAQ~.oas _ (0 a vi a 0coco c(D <.m (o > a° a co W3 '•c CD p a c ° 3 m Oi ID a m a - m 9 m z a O Z x D N m OD MM ~z MM a (A m~ ZZ ~W z " 3ccm rz Dy m W m O z a M m z m H D M O L nm 00 c 3 ~a O z a O z 0 M z c) W W W W D D D CA) 3p~ 301%0 -0 1 pdpprj c o W ~ > O.(~~ 7 CL co) C.0 S` .p,Q c (1) 1 n 0 M w ~ M. 2) CD ) 0 Sr = CL (a CL 0) < 0) fl;~v CD p rWQcc ;w 3 =r CD ~ ( ~ 0p N 3 o C.D C ( p A H =r~ =r (D~ • (a a . o (a 4% (a CL . aa cr (a CD S 01 m = co O (D "o 01 'a p 1 C Cl 0) tD N N - (C D S = 3 0 C ( . --p QO c V1 7 < - . 3 (7 p, p "N S (C N C.10 w C p S= w o (D v S•~ O pcnQ p . ( (p < Ozp CL CD = ~ C (G ~ , S (D •(C (DC C. (D 0) C. 7^' Q Q (D N ( S ~Q("`p<(pN O (D CN S O n (D (D < n (D CN C 5, o c s a ~ a~ c o p C ~ 0) ' p 0 :7 :3 ai O C C. o c 3 p O y ~ a s (D C 3 ~ CL CL c C co C. CL . N01~ j'a S .C.N O 3 01 (D @ 5~ C c LO C (D < Er O m- W (D = rt . v 7 p r- (D (o c O O C to to = . o~ a m 01 O 7 w~. =r N (0 (A O y ~O N 0 ((DD O(D O~.-••: y N N C N o d 0` Wo CD (1O 3 p (a Qp Z-. tD = ; A('~ CL 0) (Jtp C'(D CA 01 C p O 0) ca ~p ~ N Qrt(D x (D-0 CO (SD Q 3 ~ r L ~ N 3 U) ~ G = (p (D co O3 0 3 T°° " (n S prim n o (D wo-«~' o C ~.3no 3~ .R- • =r c ~3 0 ` C p m ~ 0 _ 0 a 01 O p 01 (p p C O N =w C, (ND n 0) 0- y (p ~p N C p ~ O C C 3 7 C (6 O 3 Q N ~ ~ N O'C O (D -p < O p C C O C. % N < <n C 'D S (D S (D (D O w 00 (D t/J ~ C 00 C-9 i> S S~ (D p . j p M CD a (7 = CD Q M O (D N 3 0 p v CD 3 r- =r p =r Sv~p;~•~C ODD ?M 0) rtc C,< ('D-0 fSD O N 0M00 vy C(C w j p1 < c (n (D UY A p - Q r! Q 7 - CD (~D (p O 0 01 H 01 3 0) N O1 Co Q •fl N C O' ~ Q p (D C N Q ' Q~ N N 0 CO C CO W p~(n?0iQ ~ N (40 (D N~ c ~ C'O Q C. _C C rt0 ~ < ~ s: CDC ' p n (D y> O S >N Q.- ~ ~ S (D S ~ p ? N , _ Ol m Q7 7 -p (CA D 3 8(0•013 Q 0 ~,C p S,Cr(C N K - . 7 S N- p ~ o C C Q~ ~ O .p. O S O (A c 0 Q (D Q @~ O c < dog p p 30 cC0 y0 -CL S po s S a~sp~ o m. (D N (D p < ' w (D a S (p • o .0 p o . O 3 N CL CL C •3 r- < co p N N rL Er p (D `G D m CD -0 0 3= ~ O < v . 0 i S p 0 m CL g (D -0 p (D N 0) 0 p N 0 13 (n U3 = CD CD (AC.0N ONC CA CO) C.p~3 (ny=33 (D g (A (0 p S ~(D3 ' (D m~.~o °c~D S d (D p o-~a v o 0) 0Q~ S(D p 0)N~0 (D CO o C. ap c = S c• _ :3 'a (D 9 : ~ S v ) ► c S p :3 3 Q p D Cr (D Ol S a= ~Sw rl 1 S 01 m n (D Q. 7 O(C M- SSp (D p to to cc C CD 3 CD O p = (D y (D _ n CO) o n to o n CO) n CO) 0 3 CO) O 3 a n , ~ c c a 30 r r cn o CD O c a c n o v > > n v n o 3 D 3 D p o 3 C (o (o S 'A< ~ CL N N o -0_ p ((D S C ~ N S 3 - C 0 > > 0 > 0 p c 3 d O c 3 n~ S m 0 p N p CO) CD p ( p Q CD Q CD C D m D y cn - C O O (D (n 7 T p p O N cn a co 0 1 0 1 O 1 0-0 ` 0-0 000 000 o 0- CD C 0 A -n'3 ( o N O < 3 p ;&o 3 v < ~0 3 v _ Q -10. c > > o ~ m3 C 3R p 7 1 C O oa !;a rm m m m0 ZZ Oft ~W zm SCAM)o M r z~ m m W m O X m z m v O C- m 0 4 3 O z 3 O z O Z O 9 0 ii 7. (o C). CA) w w w -I ~-4 V oD D (J1 A W N z 0 ic =r (D fl: O ~ oN O O n CD O z 0. ~ o0aoi0o(0nD ~ 0 coD c°D 0CD ib M 0"o Can~o 03 A2 ( :3 M 00 cocrt N -Ov r O Q 0 S 7 (D (D El"s 0. , aJ ~C ' 0 N C N c i, y m m°-~•( CO °i, ~ , D= Qn o ,v Q U M 10 CD c m z a-m o m ~ ~ na Q 3 c = o 0 w o m :3 D. a_ ° n :3 o r 0 ~oCD(o 2 a o c.m3 = o (D and 0 (D CD (D CL ~ ~2~03cD 00 ~oa O to w(D c A('~ Co 0 O,0 (D m O ~ (O «Q O_ c (D 0 an CD CO m0 °E- 2 0= ~ ~c Q ~ 5. 3 'D co O 1 2 a w CD 0 c =.O0(amwN < 0 -9 =r go M = CL WS W co ° (D m " c o~ = v n o o o $ o a e 3 c D cD(D (o m c o 2 ate o a w c o in y 0 m w y _ O-fl m (D ~ 21 0 _ _ @ "m N O ~ CD U) 00 cn0 (n c 0~ v ~ =r c~ v, s . =-►Mc 0 ° =r 3 as 0) CL =r .(D~~? w~0°: o .<a°N 3 » Q w c~°--%=r D~ u°, ~ rn . (n Cr CD (n~°- °.ma Mc 0 :3 >v,o (u 0°yvo3N cc ~ CD ~m 3 s R(D m~3~v U o (D co O a, 0 a, =r . N ~~sN c o v, (D0 (CD ~.'A - N a m c (D SUN a ° m O (o C. C D) ID O r =r C 3 c ~ 3 '0 cr.:- m c( c (a CL D 0 0'< (Dc cn?~ a m W - 3" ~ m n 0a CL = o W. 3 m~ 0 N = CD (D =3~ ° A NnvN ~ (p co 0 Cr (DD ~a5. "C 'O o (D nv ~(a~~ « c0o°-'wmNC 0 ~ 0 0=0.%o0 3 1 ° 3 a r --o rnavo~o~ (D o m00 O' d c 0 3 0N0;=~ (D :E ? ~sm p ~0 m e ~0.2.CL w CL CL v o N O _O (C~(o Q ID r = OF ONrN,wcr cr (DQ S 5(5=(36000 w<0 (D 0 CA O (n (D O o ° v o a: n r' o 0 0 0 v rn CL o CD a, m N c o 0 w m w 3 C D rn D D a a CD CD 0 v m c -0 3. CD 0 0 w CL O 3 rn vQ o~ 3 d O a O z 3 c m OD m ;v r M MM IC 0 0 Z ~z ~W zm 3y~ rz a 0m W m m O m 3 a O z 3 O z O z O w w ijo bo D C6 cD OD V 9) V• 'p W N D A c ~D o~ ~w M 0 -0 m @ c 3D ND oT 0) w 0 M o C ) n CD (D a CD H 7T (D :3 Cl) (A -0'0 < M c l fp n. N (D > y. (D cD CD Q 3 (D cD a < N cD o ~ -C ' o 0) (D :3 0 - E; -2 P 0 CD OL O U) (A =r U) CL D -0 2) w ~ 0 0, . o c m 0 N - n Q O rn (A co :1 =r O D CL o) a0 ID 0) cr a, CL 0 0 9) CD a) 2. C.0 gr v, v, ~0 g 0 aQ rn<7-- ID ID < o CD j C p a - ? CD N o CD N ' c CL CL 0) FW da ~ c "0 CL C ?(1) 3 O w -,a y, S CD (AS 0o a ~ D v o M a !n c a s . 0) CL 3 a- CD c _ CL O j 2 0 7 N .N~. o N Q a CD d y CD (a c 0 cn Q a cn ~ 32 L CD 0 c cr :E D 0 3 N O CL 5, C (D A N N rt N or = 3 ~o m 0 N W D Q _ 3 0 m 51 CD ~ P" fu ~ -0 (o 0 cD p~ Z U) a Q 7 v C (D 0) 3 CD cn m CD co CL 0 0 Q Q =r O► O 01 a (D o x, (A n _ (D m Q (D 0 0 N N CO < G r• 0 (32 ~ 3 CL (M cr CD O (Al < 0 . C 00 O ~ 7 CL 3 Q CA C N N (D T N O U) 57 'C Q =r 13 . :3 CD M U) R a (D U3 a, l< oa ° (D 5 o a o N n `D- ~ 3 ' CAI (D cD O Q cD ~ O CD h LA. O -0 rn 3 Q 0 CD < N O 'O 3 CD 0 c~ n CAI a 0 N O 0 0 <_.<'u o * v aA 0 ~ ~ (0 3 CL cD cD 3 O D O z 3 D N C z M OD zz 3~ ~z mm 3y m~ zz r z " r, (AX rz a z LA mm C rA a M O C_ M n 1 3 a 21 0 z 3 O z -1 O M z G) W W iD t0 D CD rn c U N' A n Z a . co ? w w "'a -3 0 D v v► g g w 00 m m C C wo ao < 5"1 • 0 -0 3 ~ O <C CD Er Q3 al mO a 0 0 0 r. (D ° o ° ' n~ (D o a) m n c n m ~c nabC:D s' 2 a ~ C) ' ° ic o°: - 0 3 warn o ° a sa•o aim o 0 m yam ~ 0~ cv~ewR§.@ o O 15-0 o 0) N N C ~O 0(D N (D N CD .N. O tpp n 01 ~(D p 2~`- O 3 Cr m 0 m my (D m ~ p. O N ~D N w w 0 :3 % WD CL (D a =r 55 CD -or CD M CD-0 - o N 0 3 K0 = 0 Q= n < ~ o o o ~ ~ n o v~ vrnv co 3 `2 m • c D 0 3 y 0 C~ a1 0 , . c _ C C O C< O O ~ ao 0 0 rt N N CA a ( w N a 2 , 0 O CD v (D U13 o-a ~a~ v~' N w -CL5 s ,~4 CL ~ w v , L ~ CD U) v ? 0 O N ~ A 3 o ~ N ,y+(p -.1 m ~"0 ~ ~v 2 , = (D C CD 0 W v aN-„coa o ~ te a? CD :3 w ~ CL CD m a a a 0 M c< m '3° ' -a m 0 ID 09 v o cn 0 CL :3 AA w - c CL CO co A CD CD (D a c.Kp CL o - ~E Q o o 0 3 (A =r DaoCL CD CD 3 c l< -0 S. 0) 3 0-O D n- a e CD a N CD. Qw m co CO w 3 (,2 CD CD C O ~ CD O . . --a = a(D p O 7 -1 -1 CD m 0 0 Oa s 7 a1 m . .N+(D cD N 3 C ~ N N E 0, CO ~(D a O.N CD O O D CA o m< cn n G ;MI _ o' (DD 0 d N 0 O U ~ c 3 am o CD o 3 U c ~a CD a) o. a~ 0 1 0 m n VI v 0 0 <; ~ CKC N < 5'2 =v 01 Q. V M z M y D V O L nm 00 =-1 c 3 LYLa 3 p T Z m a 3 M z z =i O O z z Z O T x a m oa 3 r M MM 3N M8 ZZ 00 ~W z " Z(AX r Z a y 0 mm 9 cc 0 SA) co 00 m n A) 0 =r (A C. N (D rn am' o" ~cfDc D wovD ~ m D -1-i M mv~ 2m - cnc m aoo°'< oCCD ° = (D ( - CL Z .mcn 0 M ~v 0 ,'a0 ow o0 ~c0,0 o 0 EUCD (D0 0)0.T ?:20'~ g :3 (D v, CA ~i °'C D ca w cr CD w (D CL 2 CD OMMA ~ C CD0 C ~C• 5' O~ ni n ~a c C O c~ .C.o.c O o .o °w 0 y~= O v M '0 CL M0 =r o U M. 3 O f/i N < N CL n O o CL M CD O- 71 - - ~ 0 v, a- ~7<~ CD a (D < am Q - w.~ m 1 m cD . 3 3 f, 01 to a m cD 7 CD it o v a c3 M- 0 3Mco =C-=r or <01 p m - Qn fDc vn o0 o~CL ~ .0 (D oM r.CD C 01 CD CT CD % -n ' 3 =r om ' D 0 0 CD = ao o 0 0? C. co O ~c cn . . p1 O ~ 01 < v Co to !A --L O N + 3 7 CD 0. W CD ~ CD .gym S M O a) -0 ~V1 N orn M CO) O• (D 01C=. E o N c-DD' Cr CL o~CD C• O 7 a cr O CD O 0 CD C. 0 u (D y _ = A M C N C C O~ o. CD O r. c a N N N - CL ~CD . f D v,o =(A 3 CD C 7. ..3 n v5 w3 CD am= oom C. ' v0-' ~n BCD w:3 X01 , -►~°o~ o morn r . v0 CL La a N •p C-v CD 0 (C N 7 (D 01 s `D j C 7 0 "w a32m v-o Q. v N s ° n1 c c003 c ~ 3 CL .v M vcuc CD C N C (C n N (D M .n► (D (D ~ O " fD o V C D C o o o' - 13 O a 0 < 0 0 0 c o 0 0 v 9 o, CD 0 Cl) v 0 O o~ O-o cC O, oT _ . ~ OL M M z I M a V M O 0m o n c 3 D 3 p T z m 3 M O z z D O M O z z O M M x m 0 oa xx ~x MM 3 v1 m~ ZZ O° z " 3cc x ~z~ a N mW M W W t~ m n N W N ~ W N ~ ~ ~ 0 La w m = f D (D . U D NN co . • . . 3-0@0 p~ C mCL 7 (D 01 ° W j - (D 3 c_f ~c~ c(D M c~ c B. r .r M 0(D(0 M 2 CL NmR~ pcD M j ai . (D X 3 c~ ca ► 21 m D Q W CD N O = '0 5.3 = 3 CL = 3.=r = w w a w CL (D o m o ~ ' CL _.w w w D) w C (7 =r 7 w Q- C o C~° cu O ? w w 0 ° O O ar m So 0 v°i o Sw ca o 2 ~ 0 w w -.10 V1 CO rt 3: N O 3 ° O 0 3 c (D -~o r.o C. (D _ O CO O'er cn (D CL a) Om mm ° Q m.o~ o. o ooh ° ~ < 5~ , W 0~3~ 0-0(D CL n m (D m CD m o m o Qrn~ -a m m =r 0 N (D O O N O o (p > (C 7 (D 3 CD ~3 0 =r o_ > w ND~ -paw cno0 CD O 0) 0 0 -.1 CL % 0 (1) G 0 D) O (D 0 < Q 0 (D -9 =r = :3 ix ° v, - w O --h am 0 o° on 3 Q rn o 3N co rn 0 CD w o .0= Q (D C. N 0-0 C y (D N (C m CD 5.0. 7 y ° pf (C C (D ' CD V O C C w (D CD C =r M. (D .a W 00 (D w (D S w O C (C 0 ca 0 co V F O eD v) 3 N m .O+ ~ _ O O 3 y o ° m O o Q. < 0 D c a m N 'o (D 3 N ,nC Q N O (D S 3 m CD C G 0 0 a a Cl) v - (3/1 ~ O ° mzcn ovv_0 --I °0W <_'oa CL o t° ° -n . O w C. ~ 3 0 z 3 m a N C m o> mm 34 '0;0 M f" 3-- m ~ zz ~W z " 0m> a to rO a N m W m O m 3 O O z 3 O z O Z W .a W ~ D LA -1 O CD _4 O (D d o 53 c o ~m ;0 m cn D o D 3 0 50 0 31 t (a 0 (D (n y -'gy 3 - CL - 0 t7 < CD O O '0 - N O (a r c- =r O O CA CO (D O(c ° f° 3-4 mO (D O ; m a w m a0 So CD 0 3 v m ~,ma c ~ O = co m 0 Q w al ~ s w o ° 5 ~ y :3 0 co =r 0 m A r cc r 3 C m o 3 C Q 0 0 2) u (D ° C = 01 _ 7 = n 3 (Q 9 (D co :3 Ca 3: Q L CD 0(0 mUQ O 0 o o m v, c w -1 M ~Z3 (GQ CD CD c: n; (o z (D 0 c w c 0 m m (Dm.0)*= M(n a • m c a . = o m ~(0 c.N.~ CL ;w O Q CD Q m a m m . NSO3O@QO-- ° (G . d m W (0 N y 3 f C O <D m O N N O p Q Q? °m Q n - m Qo ~ em u,3 CD W (~~(DCD 7C Om o w rt 0 0 - x 7 O 7 N -a ~a (0 (D c p1 v o m (mn 0~n ao <b am Q 0 N N co (n L La. 0 CD ~°0)~v(D~ ; fD =r Q =r r SS <.~30~3< o n 3 W Oa~~= u,(_°=(~,r-o 0 0 0 m o v ~ O n CD 3 v rt m O Q 7 0 < m N 0 rn 3 CD (D rt O 3 CD 0 N .a O 0 vca v-v-1 <S < v ° . La,a:F> j ~0 M ( N CL 'm m V I m z m a T O C- nm 00 c 3 D 3 p T z m ; m z z z a o z Z CO) OD zz rz mN mm zz ~W zm 0;0 a atom Dz~:j y mW m RECORDING REQUESTED RETURN TO: TOWN CLERK TOWN OF TIBURON 150 TIBURON BOULEVARD TIBURON, CA 94920 RESOLUTION NO. 47-2010 A RESOLUTION OF THE TOWN COUNCIL OF THE TOWN OF TIBURON AMPLIFYING AND SUPPLEMENTING PROVISIONS OF TITLE IV, CHAPTER 16 SECTION 16-21.020 (F) OF THE TIBURON MUNICIPAL CODE (ZONING) WITH RESPECT TO PLANNED DEVELOPMENT #4 BY APPROVING A PRECISE DEVELOPMENT PLAN (PARENTE VISTA PDP) AND ADOPTING A MITIGATION MONITORING PROGRAM ASSESSOR PARCEL NO. 038-111-16 WHEREAS, the Town Council of the Town of Tiburon does resolve as follows: Section 1. Findings. A. The Town of Tiburon has designated a 10.2-acre property located at the end of Antonette Drive and Parente Road as Residential Planned Development (RPD) on the Zoning Map and in the zoning regulations of the Tiburon Municipal Code, Title IV, Chapter 16, at Section 16-14.020 (B), with a further zoning designation of Planned Development #4 on the Planned Development Map in the aforesaid Section. All future Tiburon Municipal Code Section references in this resolution and its attachments shall be to Title IV, Chapter 16 (Zoning) unless otherwise specified. B. Tiburon Municipal Code Section 16-21.030 (D[3]) provides zone regulations for the RPD zone, specifying the approval of a Precise Development Plan prior to subdivision, grading, or the making of improvements on property so designated. Basic zoning parameters such as density of development, floor area limits, height limits, and setbacks are to be specified in an approved Precise Development Plan for the property, based on site-specific characteristics to which an appropriate amount and layout of development may be tailored. The purpose of the RPD zone is set forth as follows: The Residential Planned Development (RPD) Zone is intended to protect and preserve open space land as a limited and valuable resource without depriving owners of a reasonable use of their property for residential purposes. The regulations of the zone are designed to insure, to the extent feasible, the conservation of natural resources and the retention of land in its natural or near TIBURON TOWN COUNCIL RESOLUTION NO. 47-2010 9/1/2010 natural state in order to, among other things, assist in the containment of urban sprawl and protect the community from the hazards of fire, flood, seismic and other catastrophic activity, and to otherwise implement the goals and policies of the General Plan. C. Tiburon Municipal Code Section 16-52.060 (B) establishes the Precise Development Plan purposes as follows: - To provide for review by the Town a detailed development proposal for a designated area with unique site characteristics or enviromnental conditions, in both written and graphic form, to ensure that new development in such areas is compatible with the existing land uses, development standards (including but not limited to, setbacks or building envelopes, coverage limits, and height limits) and identified constraints; 2. To demonstrate consistency of a development proposal with the goals and policies of the General Plan; 3. To preserve and conserve critically limited open space for the protection of the ecology and the environment, and to safeguard against the adverse impacts of fire, noise, water pollution, the destruction of scenic beauty and hazards related to geology, fire and flood, while at the same time providing a reasonable use of the land. Section 16-52.060 (E) sets forth principles to be applied in the review of Precise Development Plan applications. Section 16-52.060 (D) declares approval of a Precise Development Plan by the Town Council to be a legislative act. E. The Town of Tiburon has received and considered an application filed by Lionel Achuck for a Precise Development Plan (the Parente Vista Precise Development Plan) to augment and supplement provisions of Section 16-21.030 (D[3]) of the Tiburon Municipal Code specific to Planned Development #4 by proposing the development of two (2) single- family dwellings and appurtenant improvements on an approximately 10.2-acre property. Approximate lot acreages would be 2.1 acres for Lot 1 and 8.1 acres for Lot 2. The proposed Parente Vista Precise Development Plan would establish a maximum density of 0.20 dwelling units per acre (exclusive of any secondary dwelling units), and provide a basic layout and RPD zoning district parameters for the property, including but not limited to, permanent open spaces, building envelopes, residential use areas, height limits, and floor area limits. F. The Parente Vista Precise Development Plan application consists of File 30703, on file with the Town of Tiburon Community Development Department. Materials from that application include but are not limited to the following: TIBURON TOWN COUNCIL RESOLUTION NO. 47-2010 9!1/2010 7 1. Project description, dated October 9, 2009; 2. Project plans (7 sheets) prepared by Thayer- Architecture, Inc., dated October 9, 2009; 3. Project plans (11 sheets) prepared by ILS Associates, Inc., dated September 9, 2009 4. Project plans (2 sheets) prepared by Herzog Geotechnical Consulting Engineers, dated September 9, 2009 5. Project plans (3 sheets) prepared by Pedersen Associates Landscape Architects, dated February 18, 2010 6. Drainage analysis prepared by ILS Associates, Inc., dated June 15, 2007 7. Geotechnical Hazards Evaluation and Geotechnical Investigation letters prepared by Herzog Geotechnical Consulting Engineers, dated January 26, 2007 and April 20, 2007; 8. Supplemental Noise Impact Study prepared by Rosen, Goldberg, Der & Lewitz, Inc., dated April 27, 2007. The official record for this project is hereby incorporated and made part of this resolution. The record includes the Staff Reports, minutes, application materials, and all comments and materials received at the public hearing. G. An Environmental Impact Report (EIR) analyzing a five-lot project on this site was certified by the Tiburon Town Council on October 6, 2004. An Addendum to the EIR, dated March 2010, was prepared to evaluate the current two-lot project design. The Planning Commission considered the certified EIR and the EIR Addendum in making its recommendation to the Town Council on the merits of the project. H. The Planning Commmission held a duly noticed public hearing on the application on June 23, 2010. Following the public hearing the Planning Commission adopted Resolution No. 2010-(Draft) recommending to the Town Council conditional approval of the project as evaluated in the EIR Addendum No. 2 for the project, and adoption of a Mitigation Monitoring Program for the project. I. The Town Council held a duly noticed public hearing on the application on July 21, 2010, at which it heard and considered testimony from interested persons. The Town Council found, based upon application materials and analysis presented in the staff report, the certified Final EIR and the March 2010 Addendum No. 2 thereto, that the proposed project is, on balance, consistent with the goals and policies of the Tiburon General Plan and in conformance with provisions of the Tiburon Zoning Ordinance. The facts in support of this finding are set forth in the official record for this project. TIBURON TOWN COUNCIL RESOLUTION NO. 47-2010 9/1!2010 Section 2. Acceptance of Addendum to the EIR NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the Town Council hereby accepts the Addendum No. 2 to the Final Environmental Impact Report ["Addendum"] dated March 2010. CEQA guidelines sections 15164 (a) and (b) state that an addendum should be prepared when none of the conditions triggering a subsequent EIR or supplemental EIR have occurred. Section 15162 of the CEQA Guidelines advises the-preparation of a subsequent or supplemental EIR when substantial changes to the project require major revisions to the EIR because of new significant environmental effects or a substantial increase in the severity of previously identified effects. The two-lot Parente Vista project that is currently proposed is within the range of alternatives and impacts discussed in the certified EIR. The Addendum concludes that this project design would not result in new significant environmental effects or a substantial increase in the severity of previously identified effects. The Final Environmental Impact Report and Addendum were prepared under contract to the Town of Tiburon by the consulting firm of Leonard Charles & Associates. Detailed CEQA findings have been adopted by separate resolution. The Addendum further concludes that with the implementation of Mitigation Measures contained therein, all environmental impacts associated with the two-lot project design have been or would be mitigated to a less-than-significant (LTS) level. Section 3. Conditional Project Approval and Adoption of Mitigation Monitoring Program. BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the Town Council hereby approves the Parente Vista Precise Development Plan (PD #4) subject to the following conditions and adopts a mitigation monitoring program for the project: 1. The approved Parente Vista Precise Development Plan shall consist of the following: a. The Project description, dated October 9, 2009, as may be modified herein; b. The project plans (7 sheets) prepared by Thayer Architecture, Inc., dated October 9, 2009, as may be modified herein; C. The project plans (11 sheets) prepared by ILS Associates, Inc., dated September 9, 2009, as may be modified herein; d. The project plans (2 sheets) prepared by Herzog Geotechnical Consulting Engineers, dated September 9, 2009, as may be modified herein; e. The project plans (3 sheets) prepared by Pedersen Associates Landscape Architects, dated February 18, 2010, as may be modified herein. TIBURON TOWN COUNCIL RESOLUTION NO. 47-2010 9/1/2010 4 2. This Precise Development Plan approval incorporates all mitigation measures as shown in the Parente Vista Mitigation Monitoring Program, attached hereto as Exhibit A and incorporated herein. Applicant shall bear all costs for implementation and monitoring of said Mitigation Monitoring Program. 3. Prior to the issuance of grading or building permits for project construction, the project sponsor shall submit-a Design Review application to the Town of Tiburon Planning Division and receive written approval from the Design Review Board. 4. In furtherance of Section 16-21.040 (C[2]) of the Municipal Code, this Precise Development Plan approval establishes a maximum density of 0.20 dwelling units per acre on the property (not including any Town-approved secondary dwelling units) and is intended to reflect ultimate development of the property. No additional subdivision for the purpose of creating additional building sites is permitted, and a note to that effect shall be placed on the parcel map. 5. In furtherance of Section 16-52.020 (I[3]) of the Municipal Code, this Precise Development Plan approval establishes the limit of "floor area, gross", as defined in Section 16-100.020 (F) therein, that may be constructed on each lot as follows: Lot 1: 6,000 square feet, with additional garage/carport area of up to 750 square feet. Lot 2: 9,000 square feet for a single-family dwelling, with additional garage/carport area of up to 1,000 square feet, additional area for a secondary dwelling unit of up to 1,000 square feet, and additional garage/carport area for the secondary dwelling unit of up to 500 square feet. The Design Review Board is directed to ensure that the final house design minimizes visual mass and bulk and fits with the current contours and topography of the site. Any garage/carport floor area in excess of the amount specified above shall be counted as additional gross floor area on the lot. The floor area of all accessory buildings, including any secondary dwelling unit, pool houses or cabana, shall be included in the total allowable floor area for each lot. Floor areas meeting the definition of "basement" in the Municipal Code shall not be included in the calculation of gross floor area. It is understood that the floor area for each lot as specified above is a maximum allowable square footage, and the Design Review Board may, in its reasonable discretion in reviewing Site Plan and Architectural Review applications for each lot, approve a lesser amount of square footage in order- to ensure that the building sizes are consistent and compatible with surrounding neighborhoods in compliance with, and as set forth in, General Plan Land Use Element Goal LU-1. TIBURON TOWN COUNCIL RESOLUTION NO. 47-2010 9/1/2010 5 6. In furtherance of Section 16-21.040 (A) of the Municipal Code, this Precise Development Plan approval establishes that the dwelling unit (main building on each lot) shall be confined to the approved "building envelope" on each lot. Dwelling units shall not exceed thirty (30) feet in height from grade. It is understood that these height limits represent a maximum height, and the Design Review Board may, in its reasonable discretion in reviewing Site Plan and Architectural Review applications for each house, approve a lesser height for the dwelling units pursuant to guiding principles of site plan and architectural review as set forth in the Municipal Code. 7. In furtherance of Section 16-21.040 (A) of the Municipal Code, this Precise Development Plan approval establishes the following standards for the secondary building envelopes associated with this application: a. Lot 1, Secondary Building Envelope. All elements allowed within these building envelopes are limited to landscape improvements, including swimming pools and spas, terraces, walkways, and retaining walls and fences with a maximum height of six (6) feet. Trellises may have a maximum height of eleven (11) feet, six (6) inches. Plantings are limited to those species with a maximum height at maturity of thirty (30) feet or less. b. Lot 2, Secondary Building Envelope. This envelope may be developed with a single-story (maximum height of 15 feet above grade) secondary dwelling unit, with a maximum floor area of 1,000 square feet, and a garage with a maximum size of 600 square feet. This envelope may also be developed with landscape improvements, including swimming pools and spas, a tennis court and a bocce ball court terraced into the slope, terraces, walkways, and retaining walls and fences with a maximum height of six (6) feet. Trellises may have a maximum height of eleven (11) feet, six (6) inches. Plantings are limited to those species with a maximum height at maturity of thirty (30) feet or less. All elements allowed in the Lot 1 Secondary Building Envelope and the Lot 2 Secondary Building Envelope may also be located in the Primary Building Envelopes for Lots 1 and 2. 8. In furtherance of Section 16-21.040 (A) of the Municipal Code, this Precise Development Plan approval establishes a designation of "private open space" for all areas on Lot 2 outside the primary and secondary building envelopes. The disturbed areas shall be landscaped immediately following the landslide repair work. Additionally, all landslide repair areas shall be hydro-seeded following grading for dust control and soil stability in accordance with geotechnical engineering recommendations. No new landscaping or vegetation shall be planted TIBURON TOWN COUNCIL RESOLUTION NO. 47-2010 9/1%2010 6 on any private open space area outside the "building envelopes"' for both Lot 1 and Lot 2 other- than that approved as part of a detailed landscape plan and palette to be submitted with the tentative subdivision map application and incorporated into the subdivision improvement drawings. 9. In furtherance of Section 16-21.040 (A) of the Municipal Code, no improvements of any type, including fencing, shall be permitted outside the approved primary and secondary building envelopes for each lot. This limitation does not apply to the private roadway leading to Antonette Drive; driveways and retaining walls supporting driveways; utilities; landslide repair devices and revegetation; drainage ditches; or other ancillary improvements necessary for installation of the subdivision improvements as approved in the subdivision improvement drawings. 10. In furtherance of Section 16-21.030 (D[3]) of the Municipal Code, all portions of each lot designated as "private open space" herein shall be contained within and protected by an open space easement or easements to be offered for acceptance to the Town of Tiburon by separate instrument as part of the parcel map application. Said open space easement or easements (if accepted) shall be recorded in conjunction with the recordation of the parcel map. All portions of said open space easement or easements shall acknowledge, if necessary, any existing or required roadway, drainage and/or utility easements and any landscape installation (e.g. entry landscaping, retaining wall screening, and mitigation planting) and maintenance agreements that are required as part of this Precise Development Plan or permits issued in reliance thereon. Open space easement or dedication documents shall be reviewed and approved by the Town Attorney and Director of Community Development prior to acceptance for filing of the parcel map application. 11. Colors and materials of residential improvements shall be low-reflectivity; medium and/or dark hues that minimize contrast with surroundings and reduce visual impacts, as shown on the project plans (7 sheets) prepared by Thayer Architecture, Inc., dated October 9, 2009. 12. Draft CC&R's, deed restrictions, and/or joint maintenance agreements or other similar instruments for the subdivision shall be prepared and submitted for review and approval by the Town Attorney and Director of Community Development as part of the tentative subdivision map application. Said CC&Rs or other instruments acceptable to the Town Attorney shall contain provisions and limitations as set forth in this Precise Development Plan approval and the adopted Mitigation Monitoring Program to the satisfaction of the Town Attorney and Director of Community Development. These instruments shall contain, without limitation, provisions for ongoing maintenance of the private roadway, common areas, ongoing maintenance of drainage structures and facilities, and ongoing removal of invasive plant species (French broom, pampas grass, etc.) from the TIBURON TOWN COUNCIL RESOLUTION NO. 47-2010 9/1/2010 7 property, and shall be recorded in conjunction with the parcel map. 13. As part of the installation of the subdivision improvements, applicant shall remove dilapidated fencing and fence-posts, litter, garbage, and other junk materials from the entire site. 14. If lighting is proposed for-the project roadway, lighting details shall be reviewed by Planning Division Staff prior to the approval of subdivision improvement drawings for the project. 15. Appearance and any proposed vegetative screening of project retaining walls shown on the subdivision improvement drawings in excess of forty-two (42) inches in height shall be subject to review and approval by Planning Division Staff prior to approval of said drawings. 16. A detailed landscape plan prepared as part of the subdivision improvement drawing submittal shall be reviewed and approved by Planning Division Staff. This landscape plan shall include removal of any remaining invasive plant species, common area plantings, entry landscaping, retaining wall screening, and any landscaping required in adopted mitigation measures. 17. All grading involving the use of heavy construction equipment shall be limited to the period between April 15 and October 31. The Building Official may authorize limited extensions of time to this period in his reasonable discretion. 18. No smoking shall be permitted on site by any person, contractor or employee during any phase of project construction. A water truck shall be present on the site during vegetation removal. These requirements shall be noted on the subdivision improvement drawings and shall be incorporated into construction documents for the contractor(s) performing the work. 19. This Precise Development Plan approval shall be valid for thirty-six (36) months following its effective date, and shall expire unless a time extension is granted or a tentative subdivision map has been approved in reliance on this Precise Development Plan, in which instance the Precise Development Plan shall remain valid coterminous with the tentative map approval. Section 4. Effective Date. BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that this Precise Development Plan approval shall become effective thirty (30) days after adoption of this Resolution, pursuant to Section 16-52.060 (D) of the Tiburon Municipal Code. TIBURON TOWN COUNCIL RESOLUTION NO. 47-2010 9/1/2010 PASSED AND ADOPTED at a regular meeting of the Town Council of the Town of Tiburon held on September- 1, 2010 by the following vote: AYES: COUNCILMEMBERS: Collins, Fraser, Fredericks, O'Donnell, Slavitz NOES: COUNCILMEMBERS: - - None ABSENT: COUNCILMEMBERS: None 1 i CHARD COLLINS, MAYOR Town of Tiburon ATTEST: DIANE CRANE IACO OWN CLERK Attachment: Exhibit A (Mitigation Monitoring Program) TIBURON TOWN COUNCIL RESOLUTION NO. 47-2010 911;2010 9